Automatic Task Planning
In recent talks and discussions, there’s been a noticeable surge of interest in a classic AI topic: optimization, particularly in the context of manufacturing orders. Optimization is a crucial aspect of AI with far-reaching implications across various industries. It involves finding the most efficient way to complete a set of tasks. In manufacturing, this translates to scheduling production orders in a way that maximizes productivity while minimizing costs.
Imagine a scenario where multiple jobs need to be scheduled, each consisting of several tasks that require specific machines and operators. The challenge lies in efficiently allocating these limited resources to complete all jobs within the shortest possible time without overbooking any resource. This is where automatic task planning powered by AI comes into play.
In this article, I will provide an overview of the problem and explore the possibilities that automation offers. Whether you are an AI enthusiast or a professional looking to streamline your operations, this discussion aims to shed light on the potential of automatic task planning to revolutionize manufacturing processes.
Problem Statement
Let’s consider a simple problem involving a list of jobs. Each job is defined as a collection of tasks, with each task having a specific duration. For instance, a job might consist of five tasks, each requiring different types of machines or operators.
To illustrate, imagine Job A includes the following tasks:
- Task 1: Cut. Duration 2 hours, requires Machine X, and an Operator
- Task 2: Wash. Duration 5 hours, requires an Operator
- Task 3: Sew. Duration 3 hours, requires Machine Z and an Operator
- Task 4: Paint. Duration 2 hours, requires an Operator
- Task 5: Pack. Duration 1 hour, requires an Operator
Both the machines and operators have limited availability, which adds a layer of complexity to the scheduling process.
The challenge lies in efficiently allocating these limited resources to complete all jobs within the shortest possible time while ensuring that no resource is overbooked.
Why We Can Solve This with AI
This problem is a perfect candidate for AI because it involves making complex, non-trivial decisions automatically. If we attempt to solve it using brute force, we’ll quickly realize that the number of elements to calculate becomes excessively large.
In more detail, each job can be performed in various orders, and the number of possible combinations grows exponentially. The impact of job sequencing is difficult to anticipate in the allocation of limited resources.
AI algorithms, particularly those in the field of optimization and scheduling, can efficiently explore these vast solution spaces. They use sophisticated methods to find near-optimal solutions without having to examine every possible combination. This capability makes AI an essential tool for solving such complex scheduling problems.
Initial Approach: The Baseline
As a starting point, let’s consider a baseline approach: assigning each job according to the order of arrival. In this method, we schedule tasks sequentially, attempting to start each task as soon as the required resource becomes available. If a task cannot be performed immediately because the necessary machine or operator is occupied, the job is paused until the resource is freed.
Here’s how it works:
- Job Arrival: Assign jobs in the order they arrive.
- Task Scheduling: For each job, start tasks as soon as their required resources (machines or operators) are available. When we start a task, we should finish that task without interruptions.
- Resource Blocking: If a task cannot be started because its resource is currently in use, pause the job until the resource is available.
- Parallel Tasks: Whenever possible, start all tasks that can be performed with the available resources simultaneously.
This approach is simple and easy to implement, serving as a useful benchmark for more advanced methods. However, it often leads to suboptimal schedules, with many idle times and resource bottlenecks.
Second Approach: Constraint Programming
To enhance our initial approach, we can utilize constraint programming to optimize the scheduling process. This method allows us to re-order jobs and allocate resources in a way that minimizes the maximum planning time (makespan), ensuring a more efficient schedule.
Get David Puiggròs’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Here’s the process:
Define Constraints: Set up constraints to ensure:
- Each task is assigned to the required machine/operator.
- No machine/operator is assigned more than one task at a time.
- Tasks within a job must be completed in sequence.
Formulate the Problem: Use constraint programming to model the scheduling problem. Define the objective to minimize the makespan, which is the total time required to complete all jobs.
Solve the Problem: Apply a constraint programming solver to explore possible schedules, reordering tasks and allocating resources to find the optimal solution.
Constraint programming systematically narrows down the search space by eliminating schedules that violate any constraints. This approach effectively reduces idle times and resource bottlenecks, leading to a more efficient and balanced schedule compared to the baseline method. By leveraging constraint programming, we can achieve significant improvements in job scheduling and resource utilization.
Scalability
Additionally, using this approach, we can scale to more complex problems that are extremely difficult to manage with a human workforce alone. AI can handle vast amounts of data and intricate scheduling requirements efficiently, making it possible to optimize even the most complicated manufacturing processes.
Conclusions
Both approaches are automated and can enhance the management of manufacturing orders. However, an AI-based approach offers additional benefits:
- Optimize Business Variables: AI can minimize the maximum schedule duration or other specific business variables.
- Introduce New Orders Minimizing Impact: AI can incorporate pre-agreed delivery dates into the optimization function, allowing urgent tasks to be added with minimal disruption to existing schedules.
- Generate Different Scenarios: AI can simulate various scenarios, such as adding tasks or changing resource availability, and predict their impact on the schedule.
- Calculate Resource Bottlenecks and Underutilization: AI can identify resource bottlenecks and periods of underutilization, enabling more efficient use of resources.
- Optimize Resource Scenarios: AI can find a balance between time reduction and cost minimization by adjusting resources accordingly.
- Handle Increased Complexity: AI can manage additional constraints and data, such as varying performance of resources, date limitations, and dynamic resource availability.
The most interesting thing about all this is that we have everything ready to incorporate AI into planning: the tools and the algorithms already exist. The data are already present in our ERPs. We just need to focus on our business: constraints, variables and set the objectives.
The potential for improved efficiency and optimization in manufacturing planning is within reach, waiting to be utilized.
As AI technology continues to evolve, its applications in task planning will only become more robust and versatile. For those in the manufacturing industry, now is the time to explore and adopt these innovative tools to stay ahead of the competition.
Have an optimal day! Salut i intel·ligència!









