Sitemap
Ramee Deeb

Ramee Deeb

Filmmaker, photographer, and an art enthusiast. News Editor @mtvlebanon

Placebo

7 min readApr 20, 2016

Since our birth we are constantly being trained to form a certain image of a reality that surrounds us, where our first interaction with the environment is based on what our physical bodily senses mediates for our brain to metabolize and render. In the outside world there are no colors, no sounds, no smells, they are merely constructions made in the brain for it to comprehend the complexity of the world. It is through the process of observation and interpretation that we become capable of drawing lines to the entities surrounding us, we secure the storm of experience and stimulation onto fixed points, thus forming “familiar” patterns and constructs that allow us to operate in a constantly shifting set of dimensions and realities.

In its pursuit of finding these patterns, the brain tends to leave out a lot of beauty as much as disfigurement in its rendition of the flawed perceptions creating a ‘perfectly’ flawed physical reality full of gaps and defects; which only comes to show how flaccid the brain is in being faithful to reality.

In the physical world there are only electromagnetic radiations we call light (optical illusions included), air compression waves we call sound, and aromatic particles we call smell, which only comes to assert that the way we direct our attention shapes our perception of reality where our continuously displaced cognitive practices are ‘building’ that simulation of the world we call: reality.

So what is reality after all? It’s whatever your brain tells you it is.

In a world where everything we experience is essentially an imitation of an imitation of an imitation, people tend to forget to ask or question what they think or believe, incubating themselves in a ‘comfort zone’ reality which they would nurture and eventually start to believe in. This reality is bound to a number of constructs mainly developed around a set of lies, outbursts of madness, dreams, hopes, fears, convulsions of faith, and sensual expressions. What these people do not realize though are the multiple mutations and combinations that are bound to emerge while coming across irregularities and instances that might seem to their brains as illogical, especially while being ‘shoved’ around and molded by stimulation and other physical inputs: leading them to rejecting these thoughts or even the possibility of a reality that lies beyond the walls surrounding their safe zone.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
It’s only in your brain, get a hold of yourself.

I believe that people choose to accept being moderately deluded to remain safe only when it is on their own terms and when it is their choice, that is to remain ‘protected’ within the boundaries of that sanity-preserving “reality” shell that they have built around themselves(religion, faith, beliefs, etc…), where even the simple notion of non-uniformity causes terror as if the world is crashing down. The disintegrating relationship between what complies as reality and what doesn’t, contextualizes the nebulous characteristic of how reality is formed in the arena of public imagination. On one hand, artists and other creatives are capable of acknowledging those irregularities and re-calibrating them in the form of art works and creations, whereas non-artists tend to reject them head on.

“Most people are not just comfortable in their ignorance, but hostile to anyone who points it out” — Plato’s allegory of The Cave

What would happen if someone who have lost their sight at the age of three suddenly became capable of seeing, and the flood of light came straight in his eyes, how would his experience transcend his previous notions and ideas of what reality actually is?

In Plato’s ever-known allegory of the cave, he proposes that “life is like being chained up in a cave forced to watch shadows flitting across a stone wall”, where all you see are merely shadows and the echoes of the world ‘behind’ you that eventually project a representation of that real reality. I find this idea quite intriguing especially that it still applies in today’s visually deterministic culture where seeing is believing, whether directly by our eyes or recorded through a camera; the construct of reality goes through four sequential processes: mediation, interpretation, appropriation, then fixation.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Alma and Elisabeth — Persona, Ingmar Bergman 1966

There are a number of films that conjure up theories of having ‘other’ universes out there that run parallel to the popular ‘mainstream’ one, Inception (dir. Christopher Nolan, 2009) and The Matrix (dir. The Wachowski Brothers, 1999), but none was capable of doing so with the minimalism conveyed in the Ingmar Bergman’s act of ‘keeping his hand in the creative process’: Persona.

In short, Persona is the story of a young nurse, Alma, who is put in charge of taking care of Elisabeth Vogler, an actress seemingly healthy who suddenly decides to become mute mid-performance of Elektra. The two characters are set on a secluded beach house which was given to them as a safe haven for the actress to recover from the trauma.

While remaining abstinent from speaking, Alma goes on speaking to Elisabeth non-stop about her life and dreams, confessing her secrets and doubts about her decisions and life choices, mainly revolving around her love life and work, only to never receive any answer. In her silence, Elisabeth is imposing her powerful character onto the seemingly weaker Alma, whose personality becomes submerged with that of Elisabeth’s, turning into a metaphysical performance of needs and desires.

What really struck me during the film is how Alma is capable of reciting her life to Elisabeth, until she realizes that she is the subject of a study where she suddenly become very defensive and things go haywire this point on.

Get Ramee Deeb’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

We can tell through the course of the film, that Elisabeth did not just suddenly decide to refrain from speaking, but it was the shock of realizing that her acting did not quite feel real, especially in the sequences where she is witnessing newsreels on the television from across the world of a reality that is unfolding in front of her eyes.

I believe what happened with Alma’s case is quite interesting, mainly because she had no problem taking the objective position while recalling her life stories to a total stranger, one being of a beach orgy (which I believe is one of the most erotic scenes in cinema history), but when she is faced with Elisabeth’s silence all her stories echo back to her, and suddenly her reality falls upon itself and starts crumbling: she has a weeping episode where she does not know what is going on in her life. The convergence of the two faces only comes to show how similar yet at the same time different the two main characters are.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
“If she won’t speak or move because she decides not to, which it must be if she isn’t ill, then it shows that she is mentally very strong. I might not be equal to it.” — Alma

I like to assume that Elisabeth represents the ‘real’ in this dichotomous relationship that binds the two protagonists, and Alma is somehow stuck in the sedated placebo reality that she has created to herself outside of that setting (at first she refuses that she has made the wrong choices and tries to convince herself of their validity).

Digging deeper into the visual currency of the film, I believe one should not go further than looking towards the human-ness that is conveyed throughout the film, purposefully showing only what is absolutely essential to the flow and structure of the storytelling process. Masterfully planned close-up shots as well as moments of breaking the fourth wall, only serve as a way to bring the viewer closer to the “real” experience conveyed by inviting him/her to animate the flow of events by giving input to them.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

The title of the film itself reveals that there is something being hidden behind the masks being worn by the characters, who might even be sharing one mask perhaps? Regardless, the endless possibilities of interpreting this experimental work of art where we witness hopes, dreams, torments, and tragedies being projected on the screen, shows that our idea of reality is nothing but a tiny slit in the infinitely morphing array of realities.

Pandora’s box has been opened, you are only as real as your imagination can be, so dig deeper into that rabbit hole as you might never know how that might be.

Ramee Deeb is a filmmaker, photographer, and an art enthusiast. MA in Media Studies from the American University of Beirut.

follow Ramee Deeb

References:

1- Plato. Plato: The Republic. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1946.

2- Persona. Directed by Ingmar Bergman. Performed by Bibi Andersson and Liv Ullmann. Los Angeles: Released by United Artists, 1966. DVD.

3- AndreaCaligiuri. “Slavoj Žižek Su Persona (I.Bergman, 1966).” YouTube. October 14, 2013. Accessed April 20, 2016. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ykSrVd8X5I.

4- Barthes, Roland. Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography. New York: Hill and Wang, 1981.

5- Mitchell, W.J.T. The Visual Culture Reader — There Are No Visual Media. Edited by Nicholas Mirzoeff. Third ed. London: Routledge, 2013.

--

--

Ramee Deeb
Ramee Deeb

Written by Ramee Deeb

Filmmaker, photographer, and an art enthusiast. News Editor @mtvlebanon