The car cruised on the highway connecting New York City to New Haven. My heart was at its fullest as it was Parents’ Weekend, and I was so eager to see what my eldest and her fancy college had to showcase. Fall had started, and the more North we drove, the yellower the leaves became and the more charming the palette turned… As I admired, with gratitude, the beautiful nature around me, the disciplined cars in their respective lanes, and the clean roads, my heart beamed with love for this country. The kind of love that is reciprocated: I love it and it loves me, I respect it and it respects me, I give it and it gives me back. And as my eyes were busy observing, my thoughts wandered, and I couldn’t but question: Who said that one should belong to only one place? Who said that one must love only one country and have allegiance to only one nation?
Nowadays, many (fortunate?) people, like myself, enjoy dual citizenship and display allegiance to more than one nation. In some instances even, the country we sought education and refuge in, turned out to be better for us in the long run than our birth country. What does this make us? Where does this place us on the Nationalism scale? Are we patriotic or are we traitors? and is this even important on the big scheme of things?
The belief that one should only belong to one nation is now obsolete, in my mind. It stemmed from the times when people did not have the ability to be in two places at the same time, when one used to travel only to work while leaving the nuclear family behind. Of course, we can never feel that we belong when we are geographically detached from the people we love the most.
Get Rana Sharara-Chami’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
This naturally leads me to wonder: do we long or do we belong?
Longing is a human behavior; it is a craving, usually of something that is yet unattainable for one reason or another. Historically, just like a burning desire, once we attain what we so wanted, we cease to long for it, unless we fall in love with it or with how we feel around it. “It” can be our nation of origin, a country we moved to, a person we are attracted to, or even… sushi!
According to Brené Brown, belonging is “being part of something bigger but also having the courage to stand alone, and to belong to yourself above all else.” She makes the distinction between belonging and fitting in and how, when we don’t belong, we change our behavior and habits to “fit in”. When the latter is the case, it becomes much harder to truly belong, and we are left off with feelings of longing for somewhere else.
But this may be simplistic, and location does matter. Some countries make it so that there’s no path for citizenship; hence, we never feel that we truly can belong, or that we even would want to. In some places, we are perpetually considered as if we are solely there to work. As a result, this is how we also experience ourselves over time: that we are merely physically present without enjoying the benefits of being a citizen and of integrating in a system that will assure our growth, freedom, and sustainability. Oddly, this somewhat makes it less confusing; it results in us longing all the time, while continuing to exclusively belong to our original home, defined, often, as the country of birth. When we feel included and are part and parcel of something bigger, while still being true to ourselves, only then it becomes easier to belong… When we belong, the longing dampens and may even potentially turn into a flat line connecting our past to our present with no life to it whatsoever, representing a nostalgic memory lane more than anything else.
But one doesn’t only long for people. Many a times, we yearn for the actual emotions triggered by specific memories, moments, or smells. For example, I long for my walks by the Mediterranean Sea, alone or accompanied. I long for unannounced visits from friends, I long for loud deafening music in pubs and restaurants, and I long for the smell of my mom’s Turkish coffee that I never actually drank. But just as there are instances we long for, there are others we gladly gave up… I don’t long for cars honking all the time for no reason, I don’t long for the suffocating smell of indoor smoking, and I don’t long for unanticipated events throughout the day, every day. Occasionally, what we long for and what we gladly gave up overlap. I know people who long for the chaos they so badly avoided, for the smell of burning rubber they grew up disdaining or even for the sight of litter on the streets that they so often criticized. They still, and will always, consider their original nation, as the most beautiful country in the world, rubbles and all…
Here I am, a living proof that a person can simultaneously love and belong to more than one country. However, as I reflect on my feelings, I cannot but wonder: am I idealizing my new home? Am I in a new relationship and am still infatuated with the novelty and excitement? Am I only seeing the good now because this is what I need at this stage in my life? I don’t necessarily have the answers… What I do know though is that I am a little less romantic for my old home…The longing for my country of birth will always be there, but it’s not as absolute and not as organic as it used to be, maybe because I was, in fact, able to attain my yearning desire to go back. Over a decade, slowly but surely, I was able to satisfy the craving … Currently, I know exactly what I still long for back home: few people, few aromas, the sea, the sun and lots of good memories. Maybe with time, the longing will grow so much that the “be” in belong will become redundant, like a zero on the left… Or, the belonging here settles in, the “long” in belong falls off, and I can then just be.








