The Subaltern can Write
Recently, there’s this feeling that I’ve wasted a significant part of life trying to challenge determinism. I’ve read a lot but never thought much; done plenty but never with the dedication commanded; observed and understood, but never acted. Bluntly, I’ve given in to determinism.
Tracing the dichotomy was quite a challenge, but I’ve found a contestant. Personal encounters with marginalisation have shaped my identity into that of the subaltern. My purpose is merely a pastiche of challenging(?) those in power. The optimism that things can change and the reality that they will get worse has destroyed me. The only question that remains is “Now What?”.
Get Soumya Mondal’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
I don’t have an answer, but I’ve read ‘The Sublime Object of Ideology’ and ‘Burnout Society’ and the mediocre book that commands people in the name of religion. Ideology betrayed me, burnout clouded my mind and skepticism killed my hopes of rebirth. A health crisis led me to the question of mortality.
What if the dream of changing the status quo dies?
Dreams are precious and it’d pain me to kill them, but if I trade angst for greed to be higher in the pecking order …
Won’t the gains trickle down to the oppressed ?
Power and materialistic gains can significantly improve the quality of life of people. But power corrupts, and the corrupt kill communities faster than empowerment can build them.
Won’t I naturally qualify as a guiding example for those who starve for representation?
Does hollow representation change things?
Won’t I at least improve my life?
My great-grandfather crawled out of his village one night. My grandfather prayed for days to be able to walk in society with his head held high, my father ran for years to be at par with his contemporaries. Don’t I owe a better life for myself to those who sacrificed theirs for me to be here? I do. But I’ve been a participant in the achievement society for long enough to know that my life won’t improve any further than it is now.
The introspection over death made me realise a few things. The angst needs to be traded but with passion and not greed. Averting the acquisition of power for ideology is deeply unethical. Without strength there is no means and without means the subaltern can’t lead a dignified life. Hollow representation may not change things but brings more people into the fold, the stochasticity of nature will ensure some positive outcomes. Personal fulfillment doesn’t come from achievement but from facing obstacles that lead to milestones. Happy communities are formed by empathetic fulfilled individuals. Lastly, the subaltern should always remember that self-oppression is oppression as well. The pedagogy of the oppressed should have remembrance of the past, courage to face the present, and hope for the future.
My reading failed me because I never read for my sake, I read to be fluent in the oppressor’s rhetoric. I never thought deeply because I was an escapist trying to be free from the curse of thinking. I was never passionate because all my goals were built around angst and not love. I’ve been an observer because I thought that some elusive understanding of the world would befall me and I’d know what to do. Hence today, I look at my failures and decide to act.
The subaltern may not be able to speak because our voice is muffled by the noise of the oppressor. The subaltern can however, write their destiny on the paper of determinism.









