Adjustability > Repeatability
Many pitchers have heard that they need to “repeat their delivery” from pitch to pitch, pitch type to pitch type, inning to inning, game to game. A recent video I watched from Randy Sullivan of the Florida Baseball Armory highlights this topic. Randy mentions that it is impossible to repeat your delivery. However, the highest level pitchers are very good at adjusting. So, our focus should be more geared towards adjustability and not repeatability. In this blog, I will use the vertical release height (release z) and horizontal release height (release x) to highlight the repeatability (or lack there of) of MLB pitchers.
In my findings, the RHP sweeping slider best depicts adjustability in the pitching delivery. To get elite sweep on a slider, a pitcher often cannot simply adjust their wrist angle, grip, or finger position. They are adjusting their vertical and horizontal release points as well. Let’s take a look at the MLB’s most horizontally breaking sliders and those pitcher’s average differences in vertical and horizontal release between their fastball and slider. This is very likely subconscious and is their bodies way of allowing them to really brush the side of the baseball to get elite glove-side movement. With that being said, mechanical cues after front foot strike can be a very slippery slope. I would be hesitant to suggest a change in the vertical and horizontal release with the majority of pitchers. In the Conclusion, I will discuss how this information can be useful for players and coaches.
On the left is the vertical release difference between the pitcher’s fastball and slider. On the right is the horizontal release difference between the pitcher’s fastball and slider. To create elite sweep on a slider, the release point of the pitch likely will be different from the fastball.
Hitters Probably Cannot Tell
Here’s some information to give you a context of how much MLB pitcher’s vertical release height changes between fastballs and sliders.
I took a look at the absolute value top 10 vertical release height differences in 100+ inning starting pitchers. Here were 3 pitchers who’s vertical release height changed greatly between fastballs and breaking balls. Let’s start by taking the most extreme example of this in José Urquidy (98th percentile vertical release height difference). José has a 9.4" vertical release difference between his fastball and slider and a horizontal release difference at 5.9"
José’s results- FB: 0.271 ExAVG, 0.533 ExSLG | SL: 0.231 ExAVG, 0.380 ExSLG.
The fastball results are not great, but not awful either. However, José does not have many outlier fastball qualities besides the above average vertical break.
Now for a less extreme example. Max Scherzer (82 percentile vertical release height difference) has a 2.8" release height difference and a 1.7" horizontal release difference.
Max’s results- FB: 0.229 ExAVG, 0.425 ExSLG | SL: 0.154 ExAVG, 0.215 ExSLG
Get Riley Feltner’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
One more example. Here is the largest deviation between fastball and curveball vertical release height amongst starting pitchers.
Shohei’s results- FB: 0.277 ExAVG, 0.372 ExSLG | CB: 0.180 ExAVG, 0.269 ExSLG.
José Urquidy, Max Scherzer, and Shohei Ohtani are fairly extreme examples of pitchers who’s release height differs between their fastball and breaking ball. If hitters could pick up on this difference, they would be taking advantage of this. None of the above pitchers are anywhere near unsuccessful and none have terrible results on either pitch type. This tells me that any sort of tipping after foot strike is highly unlikely to be recognized by hitters. Therefore, release point differences should not be a cause of concern unless it is extremely dramatic.
Low, Median, and High Variance Fastball Horizontal and Vertical Release
I picked pitchers that were in the ≤ 10th percentile, around 50th percentile, and ≥ 90th percentile for their release variance. As we can see, there is a lot of variance in a pitcher’s fastball release point throughout a season. This still holds true when filtering by zone location.
Conclusion
I am in agreeance with Randy Sullivan in that we should not preach repeatability, but rather adjustability to pitchers. This could be reflected in drills that allow pitchers to throw from different positions. Drills that preach athleticism and adapting to certain “feels” / movements rather than hyper focusing on repeating them. To create the desired movement on a pitch, changes in grips and wrist positioning are likely not enough. This is obvious when looking at the MLB’s most horizontal breaking sliders. Most of their vertical release heights change rather significantly.
I do not think that changing the release point on certain pitches should be taught to pitchers. I could see this being a very slippery slope that could have very negative effects as specific mechanical changes after front foot strike can be very hard to implement. If this is an avenue that a coach thinks could be beneficial to a player, it could be presented in a round about fashion. For instance: a coach could tell the player to really get on top of a curveball, or to feel like they are really getting around their slider. In turn, this will probably create some change in their release point. Coaches should also be aware that this is a natural adaptation for some pitchers to create the desired movement on certain pitches. It should not be discouraged if it is already present or begins to occurr. Pitcher’s fastball release points will change throughout a season, outing, and even pitch to pitch. Hence, repeating your delivery is impossible. Adjust don’t repeat.
Checkout the code for this blog on my GitHub: https://github.com/rileyfeltner . Follow me on Twitter for all baseball content: https://twitter.com/rileyfelt29 . As my final undergrad semester and first coaching season is heating up, I will not be quite as active on here as I’d like. But, I will post whenever I am able!










