Sitemap

UX, Privacy and the Internet of Things

4 min readNov 11, 2014

--

A short talk at Web Summit Dublin 2014

I just returned from Web Summit Dublin, a 20,000+ attendee mega-conference that features a diverse swath of international startups and corporations from around the globe.

I was invited to be part of a panel about the Internet of Things — a fairly recent buzzword for an idea that people have been tinkering with for some time now, that everyday objects are connected to a network in order to give them added smarts and utility.

In the same bucket, this means everything from your Tesla making itself smarter over-the-air, to the Nest thermometer keeping your home cool, to the smart watch keeping tabs on both your fitness and who your friends are.

As user experience designers, we have a responsibility to provide clarity —what a product can do and also how it does it, in human terms—with a heavy dose of empathy, a consideration of the unique contexts, emotions and concerns of its target audience.

I discussed 3 themes that those making connected products should consider from a privacy standpoint:

Awareness

While connected devices have been around for a while, what’s revolutionary at the moment is how affordable and nearly invisible they’ve become. Products like Belkin’s WeMo suite of connected light bulbs, coffee makers, and even slow cookers can be controlled from anywhere and use the user-friendly If This Then That protocol to allow you to create highly customizable behaviors for them using natural language, all while looking like every day devices.

Is total invisibility always a good thing? Or do we as designers need to consider the need for a visual distinction between so-called “smart devices” and everyday objects?

Take the Webcam that might be sitting right in front of you on your laptop, a nearly invisible black dot. When it’s on and streaming your image to someone, a little green light turns on— a design decision meant to protect your privacy.

Get Ron Goldin’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

What affordances for smart devices can appropriately let us know what the device tracks, how it’s tracking it and why?

Control

Connected devices mean that our once commonplace objects now have the potential to be infinitely connected to anything and everything on the Internet—social networks, search engines, and other devices.

The potential of that connectivity is exciting and no doubt companies will be making it easier and more seamless to connect them, possibly as easily as how we click “Connect with Facebook” to tie together all your software services today.

In the process of making Internet of Things objects easy to connect and set up, it may be helpful to recognize the distinction between three levels of privacy — the individual, the semi-private network, and the public network.

Individual: There are things that only you care to track yourself that are either not particularly interesting to other people or perhaps sensitive.

Semi-private network: There is a segment of the larger network that you want to share with. This can be broken down differently depending on the product. For example, your immediate family or your significant other may be an appropriate recipient of your health information, your colleagues may want to know your whereabouts if you’re at a conference together, or your friends may exchange live fitness goals if you’re training for a marathon.

Public Network: There are many possible “public networks” as well when you think about connected objects. Think of city planners using data to try to understand how to improve traffic, for example, or a musician getting real biometric feedback from fans at a concert. There are situations where data can benefit the public, however it’s defined for the application (see below), and framed and implemented the right way, this can be a win-win for the customer without breaching privacy.

Customization of how data is being shared is critical. Can the user turn it on and off? Instead of making it all-or-nothing, can the user customize exactly what is being shared and how?

Value

While many Internet of Things devices are marketed for individual benefit (convenience, cost and sustainability, for example), the data they generate can have a broader value to society. Consider government and local utilities trying to better understand behavior patterns affecting power usage to optimize the efficiency of the power grid.

In the software world, many of us have signed legal contracts to share our data in exchange for services, whether we’re fully conscious of it or not.

If the sign up flow for Facebook said, “Sign up is Free in exchange for free reign on your personal data”, I know my mother would nuke her account immediately.

Due to the sensitivity of tracking our actions and behaviors in the physical world, we have to be transparent about any intentions of using data for anything other than the end user’s benefit.

Instead, companies need to consider creative ways of incentivizing someone to pro-actively opt-in to share their data for the greater good, whether by making its group benefit clear, or even offering the customer more tangible incentives for sharing (such as cold cash, in some cases, as some companies are starting to do in the software world).

If you have any great success stories on dealing with privacy concerns when designing for connected devices, I would love to hear them.

--

--

Ron Goldin
Ron Goldin

Written by Ron Goldin

Product/Design. Ex-Meta, Google, Uber, Microsoft. Views are my own.