Sitemap
7 min readJul 27, 2014

--

Is China getting worse or better?

Whenever I hang out with my Chinese coworkers, they like to complain about China. I never have to prompt them. Maybe they feel ashamed of what’s happening here, and feel a need to apologize. Or maybe, because I’m white and I speak Chinese, they see me as an outsider who they can open up to, a kind of political therapist.

1. The last one to complain was my coworker “Dan,” a Director of Sales in one of our Shanghai branches. Dan and I met for dinner at a restaurant called Crayfish Restaurant, and we ordered a big pile of curried crustaceans. As we tore through shells with our bare hands and sucked the meat out of claws and pincers, Dan launched into a rant that lasted fifteen minutes:

“Why is China this way? During the Cultural Revolution, the educated were persecuted or banished and the uneducated rose to power. Now those same people are running the country. You think they care about cultural preservation, environmental protection? They only care about making money. They have no education!

“And now their children are coming of age, the 90s generation. They care about nothing but money. Everything is measured by it.

“You know, China has 5,000 years of history. As Chinese people we’re very proud of this, very proud of our culture. But what use is our ancient culture now? It’s powerless to change anything.”

2. Another coworker, “Sebastian,” was furious about the lack of rule of law in China. We sat down in a conference room to talk about search engine marketing, but ten minutes in, something set him off:

“You’re American, right? In America, the government must respect the law, and the law exists to protect the people. In China, no way! You’ll find that laws here are very strict. We are not lacking for laws here. But if you have Party connections, you can get around the law. Only suckers like me and you have to obey.

“Our so-called economic development is a joke. When I was growing up in Beijing, you could eat your fill for 1 or 2 kuai. In downtown Shanghai, where can you get dinner for less than 60 kuai? Who can afford to buy a house here? This is our ‘economic development!’”

With each sentence, Sebastian laughed. It wasn’t a mirthful laugh.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

3. Men like Dan and Sebastian tend to complain about Corruption, Rule of Law, Inflation. My female coworkers, on the other hand, tend to focus on the unintended consequences of China’s lighting-fast urbanization: loss of community, alienation, aesthetic impoverishment. Two coworkers, “Liping” and “Jane,” come from two different backgrounds but have very similar views.

Liping went to college in the US, and we used to work together before her H-1B visa expired. She recently moved back her hometown of Suzhou to get married, so one weekend I took the train to go visit her.

Her husband picked me up in his new VW and we set off along Suzhou’s new ring road towards their apartment. On the way, we passed acres and acres of new glass towers, and I remarked how much Suzhou had grown since I visited in 2007. Liping chimed in:

“I hate it! Suzhou used to be special because it was close to nature. We had waterways, fields, you could go pick yangmei right outside the city. Now you have to drive farther and farther away.

“When I grew up, I lived in a courtyard house in the Old City, not far from Wangshiyuan [a 14th-century garden]. We had no running water, so we had to get it from a well which we shared with other families.”

But would she really prefer to live in an old house with no running water, I asked her?

“Absolutely! There was so much to do. I lived together with all the other families’ kids. We used to play with the anthills in the courtyard.”

Get Sam Massie’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Her husband pulled into the parking garage below their new condo, on the 19th floor of a 30-story building. The condo looked spare and spacious, but there were no courtyards and no anthills to be found.

4. Jane grew up in big, cosmopolitan Shanghai, but her sentiments echoed Liping’s. Jane visits her mother four times a week, and since her mother lives near my apartment, we sometimes walk down the same laneway after work. This laneway is a lively little shikumen neighborhood dating from the 1920s, and one day Jane started reminiscing about laneway life:

“On a hot day, you could sit outside on a stool and chengliang [cool off]. You could eat watermelon and gossip with your neighbors. People knew everything about each other’s personal lives.”

She said she wished she could return to Shanghai in the 1930s. I asked her why, given that China was so poor then.

“Back then, the ideal for a woman was to be cultured. She could paint, she could sing, she knew about art and music. Nobody cares about that now. They only care about practical things like money and status.”

I later discovered that Jane had a blog on Tumblr, in which she posted her reflections on art and philosophy and shared photographs from her solo explorations of Shanghai. Few of her posts had comments.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

It’s easy to sympathize with Dan, Sebastian, Liping, and Jane, but they are not a random sampling of Chinese people. All of them have college degrees, and two have lived in the U.S. They all work for a multinational corporation in the richest city in China. By Chinese standards, they are incredibly privileged.

George Wang grew up in Shanghai in the 1930s and 40s, and he shares none of Jane’s nostalgia for Old Shanghai. As a child, he became homeless when a Japanese bomb destroyed his house, and he was forced to move into an attic with his mother, brother, and two sisters. The attic was only nine square meters, and it became a furnace in the summer because it had no windows. They lived there for eleven years. “When people complain today, I just laugh,” he said.

George went to a middle school for refugees, but he had to drop out to support his family. Miraculously, he found a job at a (Nazi) German newspaper, and worked his way up from messenger boy, to typist, to translator, to journalist. He used his savings to attend night classes in English. Decades later, he is now an emeritus professor at one of the best universities in China. He is also a passionate defender of Mao Zedong.

“You don’t understand how bad it was. When Mao came to power, people were starving. They had to develop the country as fast as possible. Of course he made mistakes! But everything he did was for the people.

“Even the Cultural Revolution started as an anti-corruption campaign. So what, there’s corruption now, the rich take too big a share? You have corruption too in America, it’s just ‘legal corruption.’ If you look around, people are laughing. They are happy. Not before. Nobody would smile. Nobody would make eye contact.”

“Everything the government does is for the people. You talk of ‘government of the people, by the people, for the people.’ Which is most important?”

George is more than 80 years old, but he continues to write books about China, together with his British wife Betty, who was also born in Shanghai. “I want people to know where China came from, to know that China is not the villain. Peace is the most important thing in the world. Look at what’s happening in Ukraine and Iraq. When there’s war, it’s the people who suffer.” As he said these words, he actually began to tear up, as only someone who’s lived through a war could.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Who’s right, my coworkers, or George? Everything depends your baseline of comparison. Until the 1970s, China was one of the poorest, most miserable, and most violent countries in the world. Today urban poverty has nearly vanished, college education is widespread, and China is stable and free of foreign imperialists. My coworkers live better than even the wealthiest Shanghainese of the 1930s. Dan and Sebastian both own cars, Liping has a degree from an ivy league school, and Jane buys vintage cameras and goes backpacking in Cambodia. They all have air conditioning. George has a point.

It’s significant, however, that educated people born in the 1980s would experience China’s subsequent changes as a loss. Their experience suggests that China is overshooting, that the rush to develop is creating new problems. It also reveals the influence of travel and foreign media. Thanks to their time in the United States and their consumption of Western film and television, my coworkers have an image — accurate or not — of how their country could be.

At the end of the day, my coworkers’ opinions matter more, because it is they, not George, who will shape China for the next 30 years. There’s no doubt that China made tremendous progress since the 1930s, but that’s no longer the question. The question is, “what now?”

Could all these disaffected, educated 20-somethings coalesce into a force for political change? So far, no. They have no forum, no political party, not even a mechanism for organizing. They only have their American coworker to complain to. But they could influence China’s future in subtler ways: in what they buy, in how they raise their kids.

And things could change if they cease to benefit from the system. Would they put up with 20% inflation? Would they put up with losing their jobs? You can bet that George’s government, ‘for the people’, will do everything in its power to prevent that from happening.

--

--