The Train
Personifying The Iraq War
This piece personifies the conduct of states leading up to America’s 2003 invasion of Iraq. Using the Realist theory of international relations, it models states as individual actors locked together in the anarchy of a train with no driver. Each major country in this saga is modeled as a person, fighting for order and survival in the treacherous confines of a ceaseless train. The piece is not an allegory but a model of the Iraq War. Each key assumption of Realism is present, and the major events, from Operation Desert Storm to the UNSCOM nuclear weapons inspections, faithfully recreated. Through it, we can understand the logic (and the absurdity) of the machinations of states during this time and how actions echo across the international community. In doing so, readers can grasp how international relations is conceived by no small portion of its scholars.
A steel train whips through the dark, somewhere along its earth-spanning journey in a frozen wasteland. On board are many dozens of riders, reposed on the bare floor of the train, quite still.
Some of the passengers are small and deathly slim. Others are robust, sturdy with relaxed attitudes. One, huge and thick with a neck as broad as a manhole rests with his back propped against the wall of the jolting train. The people are simply-clothed and carry few possessions.
The train will never cease its route around the circumference of the world. It has no driver, though the inhabitants of the train have long wondered about that — now theorizing that the very own momentum of the train is the propellant of its path. After much practice, the inhabitants learned to grow mushrooms in the cracks in the floorboards and to water the fungus with the condensation that trickles down from the walls and ceiling of the carriage.
The people on the train are no strangers to one another. In the confines of the long carriage, they have spent much of their existences examining their neighbors. Some are friends. Others are wicked enemies. While they all crave stability, each cannot help but wonder when another will set upon them either in pursuit of belongings or to reassure their own safety from aggression. So they watch.
Ail, the huge rider with a neck the size of a manhole, does not fear. Ail’s body is so enormous, so rippling with muscles that no other human on the train could overcome him, even in surprise. Ail proudly guards a large swathe of the carriage, allowing him to grow line after line of fungus that he consumes with vigor. Though others snark that it is the size of Ail’s plot that allows him to maintain his strength, Ail muses aloud if his own unique talent is the root cause.
No matter, Ail is friendly with many of the strongest in the train even when they gripe. By and large, each of them is happy with their statuses. Others on the train are not. If they have not failed to master the techniques for culturing mushrooms, the small spaces on the train that they cling to are ill-suited for such endeavor. Cracks in the floorboards are few, or the condensation from the ceiling reaches them in sparse droplets. Hungry and weak, they yearn for more and better space.
However, the times of the great brawls for space on the train floor have passed. Mostly now the riders focus on cultivating more fungus from the areas they inhabit. Only in rare occasions do they scuffle for small stretches of floor here and there. Fresh in the minds of the passengers is the beating that the vexatious Hosi received from Ail and a handful of others on the train. Hosi, frail, sickly, yet bombastic and bullying, had tried to muscle one of his weakest neighbors out of a small and well-tended plot. Ail had led a group of some of the train’s strongest in bundling Hosi out of his neighbor’s plot and delivering a powerful set of blows to his chin, chest, and kneecaps. The group had agreed among themselves to bind one of Hosi’s wrists down to the floor, so that he posed a diminished threat to his neighbors and even to his erratic self. Ail had led this intervention, spinning his massive weight though perfectly-executed kicks to blow Hosi backward without the faintest of ripostes. Every inhabitant on the train had watched Ail’s efforts in awe, and were cheered by his decision to protect a rider from the undue aggression of a neighbor. It seemed now that Ail was the barrier to prevent any rider from taking space from another.
So the inhabitants of the train carried on their cultivation, gripes, and examinations as they hurtled through the desolate wilderness. Despite the occasional scuffle around the cabin, tension had declined and there was a general sense that the riders could enjoy some feeling of safety in their plots, big or small.
“Ail, don’t you think that your plot is too large?”
“Ail, do you think that you can get everything you want by flexing your muscles?”
The taunts came from the center of the cabin. Though small and frail, the riders there were proud. The condensation from the roof of the cabin barely touched their little plots and their fungus grew small and blackened. Hosi lay on one edge of the group.
Ail paid them no mind. He had long since grown used to the resentment of riders with less strength or sustenance. Besides, he was better friends with the bigger riders who lay along the edges of the cabin where the mushrooms grew lush. Since the end of the great brawls, these edge riders had prospered and developed better techniques of growing fungi. Their success had yielded mutual association based on warmth, power, and conceit.
In this cabin of newfound calm, night gently fell. The riders ceased their murmuring and settled into quiet rest. All that that could be heard through the darkness was the gargling motion of the train, the tiny slaps of falling condensation, and the light thud of foot soles over wood. A crack like a wet log breaking pierced through the carriage. The rapid thumps of legs in retreat and a primeval roar wrenched every rider awake. The sun poked above the icy horizon and its earliest rays illuminated the bloodied, squirting face of Ail.
His fingers were closed tightly over his gushing nose, his body doubled over as he hawked tears and rasped out moans. Ail’s partners, the edge riders, were around him and trying to lift him to his feet.
“Who did this? Who stamped on me as I slept?” Ail yelled through flecks of blood.
The cabin fell silent. Then one of the riders in the central region near Hosi spoke.
“It was Alcara. I heard her get up in the middle of the night.”
Ail faced the big riders around him and they nodded. Ail’s slick hands wiped blood from his eyes and he strode to the central cabin area where skinny Alcara lay. Her back was pressed against the floor, body tensed, her gaze locked up at Ail’s. Ail raised his foot and crushed it over her skull. Her unconscious eyes rolled back and her form slackened. The inhabitants of the carriage watched grimly as Ail placed kicks into her chest and arms. The snap of bones was percussion to the rhythm of the train. When Alcara’s body was a purple mess Ail wheeled around and staggered groaning into his plot.
The edge riders were all in support of Ail’s retaliation and voiced this loudly to the rest of the cabin. Ail’s most trusted friend, the ruddy, sturdy Mardain stood to address the riders:
“I am still shocked at the depravity of Alcara’s unprovoked attack on Ail,” Mardain pontificated. “This rider needed to be totally incapacitated so that she could do nothing like this again. In fact, I am quite certain that Alcara had been planning this for some time. She was jealous of Ail’s strength and the influence he exerts over this cabin.”
The weaker and smaller inhabitants gazed on at the big riders. What kind of disagreement could they voice? The strongest of the train would never hesitate to commit violence to punish aggression against them. Besides, what was Alcara thinking by setting upon the mightiest among them?
For days, Ail stayed hunched against the wall of his plot. His head was buried in his arms. His breathing was loud and labored. The other riders watched him uneasily as the light ebbed and grew in the cabin. Ail shifted little, raising his head in odd moments to glare out at certain members. Only in those seconds was his shattered, blood-crusted face visible.
Alcara remained strewn as Ail had left her, her chest just barely rising and falling with life.
In an evening when the weak sun was weaving its last orange rays over the wilderness, Ail raised his head and spat out one word: “Hosi.”
In the next moment, he bellowed it. “Hosi! Hosi played some part of this!”
The cabin was still. The inhabitants eyed each other uneasily. One of the edge riders, a haughty, lean man who had played victim to many of the great brawls of the past, spoke up. “What do you mean, Ail? You are accusing Hosi of helping Alcara attack you?”
“Yes, Falaice,” replied Ail, “That wretch played a part in this. I know it.”
“How can you be sure of this? Hosi has been pinned to the ground since you apprehended him.” It was Perger, the beautiful, pink-faced rider who had once been a mortal enemy to her edge rider neighbors. Through years of careful friendship, she had re-established their trust.
“For this very reason Hosi despises me. He will harm me in any way he can. What’s more, I heard him whispering to Alcara a few nights ago.”
“Is that so?” Falaice said, his brow furrowed. “I had not heard any such sound.”
“Yes, they were whispering,” said Ail, irritated. “They were conspiring for this attack.”
Ail’s partners, the edge riders, exchanged glances. What sounds had Ail heard that they had not? And besides, should some small whispering necessarily imply conspiracy?
Perger spoke first, gently. “Ail, I cannot conclude that Hosi participated in what happened to you. Hosi is a brute, for sure, but he has no connection to Alcara beyond how close they sit.”
“Why do you doubt me?” Ail’s anger was surging. “Do you think I am lying? Look at what he did to me! Hosi will not stop until he taken more from me and come after you too.”
“Even so, Ail, my friend,” it was Mardain’s turn. “It was Alcara that struck you. We think that the danger is gone now that she has been put down.”
“Alcara was just a puppet — Hosi is the schemer! He hates us because we got in the way of his plans for more space in the cabin. He lusts for the chance to seize more floor from his neighbors.”
Ail exhaled for a moment, rising at last to his feet. All the emotion was suddenly vacant from his face. He spoke in a voice low but steady: “Besides, I believe that he is making a knife.”
Only a distant shriek of the train’s wheels could be heard. Each rider’s eyes were on Ail. Even Loma, the chunky and fast-growing rider at the far end who rarely diverged from her careful cultivation, glanced up. Her own knife was stuck down into the corner of her plot.
No one moved to speak. Ail held on for a response, then continued:
Get Ben Sando’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
“I know that Hosi has been building a knife for some time. He has been gathering what he needs from around the cabin and stashing it pieces. I am not sure of how close he is to finishing one, but he will have it soon.”
Ail could make no more provocative an accusation than the crafting of a knife. His own blade was lashed smartly to his belt. A few others in the cabin, from Mardain to Falaice and Yergy — once feared in the cabin but now wasting away from malnutrition — held blades of their own. When the great cabin-wide brawls for space had ended, the strongest riders to survive had sworn that no one could obtain of this weapon other than themselves. Their greatest fear was that an unhinged or bloodthirsty rider would cut and stab at another. Even if the strike did not kill immediately the victim could still die slowly from seeping infection.
“If Hosi succeeds,” Ail continued. “No one here will be safe. Least of all the weakest riders he sits alongside.
“Fuck you, scum,” spat Hosi.
“See,” Ail carried on. “Hosi does not deny it.”
“Ail, we have seen no evidence of Hosi piecing together a knife,” said Falaice. “How do you know of his plans?”
“I had been watching him. Closer than you all. At night he works around the cabin, bumming what he needs from other riders. They will never admit it,” Ail said, turning out to the mass of riders in front of him. “But some of you have been helping him throw this whole cabin into turmoil!”
There were outbursts of protests from a few riders. Others shrank down in silence.
Hosi struggled to sit up against his binding. “I will not answer to the filth of this cabin. Ail trades in lies. I have no need for a knife.”
The clamor on the train receded into a ticking tension. The riders descended to their plots and murmured among neighbors. Rivals eyed one another with suspicion.
“Hosi,” called Mardain. “If you have made any shred of efforts to make a knife, give it up now.”
The other edge riders looked sharply at the ruddy rider.
“Mardain, do you believe this accusation?” asked Perger, her lips parted.
“I only judge from details I have heard firsthand. Some riders in the central cabin have mentioned that Hosi has been gathering bits of metal from his neighbors. Hosi has been making secret trades with his neighbors. I know not of what. And he wears his clothes tighter now. He may be concealing the parts.”
“Who told you this?” Falaice quizzed sharply. “Why did you just tell us of this now?”
“I cannot share who gave this knowledge to me. That would be dangerous for them.”
Falaice was restless and leaned in to press him. “Mardain, how did you — ”
Ail cut him off. “We know enough, Falaice. It’s time we did something.”
Perger’s tone was quick now and she had stood. “Then give us a chance to negotiate with Hosi. Let us make him turn out his pockets, his clothes, to show whether he indeed has the materials you describe.”
“You waste time,” Ail chortled. “Hosi will only deceive you as he is want to do. But I will wait for the outcome of your effort. Mardain, let us see what the others can show us!”
Hosi’s eyes bored into Perger and Falaice as they stood above him. His mouth was taut at the edges. Perger quietly implored him to open his person to their inquiring hands.
“You may search my arms, my legs, and my coat,” Hosi grunted. “But if you touch my mouth or my crotch I will rip off your ears.”
“Fine,” Perger said quickly. “But let us search you in front of the others so they can believe what we report.”
Hosi said nothing and slowly stretched his torso back over the rattling floor. His limbs were splayed out and he lowered his eyelids until they were barely slits.
Perger and Falaice set about patting his arms, turning his sleeves up, and opening the folds of his jacket. Falaice drew his hands up the shirt of Hosi and felt at his armpits. Perger pulled out each of the pockets of his coat and trousers one by one. Sand and the dried remnants of mushrooms fell out. Falaice brought his hands closer to Hosi’s waist and Hosi turned suddenly, twisting his pelvis away from the rider’s fingers. Falaice withdrew his hands, paused, and the two edge riders straightened up.
“See,” Perger spoke out to the watching riders. “Hosi hides nothing.”
“Hosi hides nothing?” Ail scoffed, “Did you search all of him? Even the places that Hosi wishes your hands won’t go?”
“Hosi has a right to remain clothed,” Perger rebutted. “And if he had been assembling a knife we would find some evidence of it in the places we turned out. You think he can hide all of this in his underwear and gullet?”
“We cannot be sure Perger,” Mardain intervened. “Hosi could have it stuffed between his legs. Do you want to take this chance?”
“There is no chance to be taken, Mardain! Hosi is only suspected of this because you and Ail throw out accusations about him.”
“It is enough!” Ail thundered. He strode forward from the cabin wall. “There is no time for more of this indecision. Every moment we allow Hosi to act, he will build on his weapon. I will act now to relieve this cabin from the fear of him.”
The enormous rider marched towards the center of the cabin. The thud of his footsteps was interrupted by a deep, dry voice.
“So, the mighty show again that they will do all that they please. And again, the weak suffer at the whims of the strong. Only when we stand up in unison can we bend the strong to our subjects. Act alone, and you will suffer nothing but pain and humiliation.”
It was Yergy, the frail, rangy rider who had once been the great rival of Ail in the cabin. His slender legs were drawn up to his chest as he cast his eyes over the inhabitants strewn across the train floor.
Ail stopped and turned to the once-feared rider. “Shut it, Yergy. If not for you, this cabin would have had the peace it deserves long ago.”
He leaned forward and lashed a kick across Hosi’s face. The shackled rider’s head met the cabin floor hard and remained there. Mardain charged forward and stamped across Hosi’s knees. The two riders bent down and hammered their fists one after another into Hosi’s sides, drawing strangled groans from watching riders. Ail seized Hosi face, slapping it left and right and then ripping his mouth open to examine inside. He dropped Hosi’s head and turned to shake off Hosi’s trousers which Mardain had begun tugging at the ankles. Ail stamped on Hosi’s stomach and the rider’s pelvis jerked upward. Mardain shirked off Hosi’s undergarments and rawboned rider was now completely naked on the train floor. Only flesh could be seen, no glint of a blade, no dull mass of a hilt.
“You find nothing,” Falaice hissed.
“We will find something!” Ail barked, kicking Hosi’s torso as if he could squeeze out some weapon.
“You find nothing, and now Hosi is nothing more than a mound of purple flesh!” Perger hollered as she pointed her finger at the enormous, sweating Ail.
Voices were breaking among the multitude of riders, voices of anger, voices of bitterness. Mardain had backed off from the bleeding Hosi, his face blank in shock. “Look what you have done,” called some of the riders, “You have decimated a rider for no cause at all!”
The riders had risen around Ail and were pressing in on him. Ail pushed his way past but they followed him spitting rebukes.
“This cabin is merely a preying ground for the weak. We are no safer than we ever were!”
“How can we defend ourselves? How can we escape the aggression of the angry and strong?”
The hulking, sweating Ail reached the edge of the cabin. He stared ahead, then shut his eyes as the admonition rose around him. Slowly, he sat. The light from the setting sun washed across the great rider’s shattered visage and illuminated the palms of the crowd beating the air. The train bit across the gold-stained wilderness, shrieking along with its inhabitants as it disappeared into the plunging ravines of the horizon.








