Vanished from the Subway
Looking for Cesilia Pena, thirty-seven years later
Avonte Oquendo went missing one month ago today. Despite near-constant broadcasts on the subway, surveillance cameras stationed all over the city, and some painfully close calls, the fourteen-year-old boy’s whereabouts are as much of a mystery as when he ran out of his Long Island City school on October 4, with no way to communicate to anyone where he was headed.
We’re at the stage now where the brutal reality of cost-benefit analysis kicks in, where the NYPD will likely scale back efforts and reassign cops to other matters. We can hope for happy endings, that Avonte might, somehow, emerge relatively unscathed from the subway system he adored, and brace ourselves for more terrible outcomes. Or worse, no outcome at all, just the void of not knowing what happened.
When people, kids especially, disappear in New York, I think of those who entered that void and never emerged. Every time an announcement about Avonte rings out on a train I ride, my mind goes back a little more than thirty-seven years.
She, too, was fourteen. At four foot nine and one hundred and eleven pounds, she almost certainly looked younger. It’s not known if Cesilia Pena loved the subway, but she used it every day to get to and from St. Alphonsus Commercial High School for Girls, the Catholic school on the corner of West Broadway and Canal Streets. (The school would close just four years later, in 1980.) On the early afternoon of October 6, 1976, once the last school bell rang, Pena and her friends began the long trek back to the Bronx, clad in the light gray jacket, gray plaid skirt and white blouses of their uniforms.
They likely started their uptown journey on the 1 train a few blocks west on Canal, before switching at the earliest possible moment to the 2 train. At 149th Street and Grand Concourse, the first Bronx stop on that subway line, Cesilia was five stops away from her next transfer, the Simpson Street station, after which she hopped on the Bx5 bus to get back home.
Get Sarah Weinman’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Cesilia’s friends last saw her at 149th Street/Grand Concourse sometime between 3 and 4 p.m. on October 6. They probably switched to the 5 train to continue their respective commutes, thinking Cesilia would stay on the 2. But on that day, Cesilia didn’t get off at the Simpson Street stop. She didn’t transfer to the Bx5. She never came home. And to this day, no one knows what happened to Cesilia Pena.
Or at least, no one officially knows. But a witness, whose name was not released to the public, came forward a few days after Cesilia vanished. The witness told police she had seen Cesilia on the corner of 163rd Street and Southern Boulevard in the Bronx, her arm gripped by a man identified as Anthony “Rudy” Flores. Flores was a resident of the Bronx, but didn’t only spend time there, as I’ll talk about later. According to the witness, Cesilia seemed frightened by Flores.
What’s odd about Cesilia being spotted at 163rd and Southern Boulevard is that it’s less than a half a mile away from the Intervale Avenue station, one stop earlier than the Simpson Street station where Cesilia normally exited to switch to the Bx5. That corner is 0.6 miles from the Simpson Street Station, but the more complex route Cesilia and Flores would have had to travel by foot makes it more plausible they encountered each other at the Intervale Avenue stop.
If that’s the case, did they meet earlier in the journey, somewhere between Grand Concourse and Intervale? Or did Cesilia get off a stop too early by mistake, get confused, and run into the man identified as Flores outside the station? Perhaps she tried to get on a different bus stop and was abducted at that point? They are questions without answers. Surveillance cameras didn’t exist back then. Police couldn’t ping Cesilia’s cellphone off a nearby tower. And Flores, when questioned about her disappearance, denied ever knowing her, let alone that he was with her on the corner of 163rd and Southern, gripping her arm tight.
Flores also denied involvement in the disappearance of another young girl two months later. This time, suspicion fell upon Flores in Boston, after nine-year-old Nelida De Jesus del Valle vanished on the morning of December 20, 1976. She was on her way to Blackstone Elementary School on Shawmut Avenue, where she was a third-grade student. Nelida only had to walk one and a half blocks to get to school, a short distance easily accomplished all by herself. But, akin to the Etan Patz case two and a half years later, Nelida never made it. She’s never been located.
Two weeks after Nelida vanished, a woman called police with some interesting information — and unusual possessions. She had run into a man who said he’d found a hat and a pair of gloves on the street, giving them to her. She took a look at the man and grew suspicious: he looked an awful lot like the sketch of a man seen near where Nelida disappeared. The hat and gloves proved to be Nelida’s, and the man was Anthony “Rudy” Flores. Boston PD picked him up and found, to their surprise, that he was carrying a fake badge and gun. But even though he was arrested, there wasn’t enough evidence in the BPD’s belief to charge him, and Flores was released. To this day, Nelida del Valle’s family believes Flores abducted the girl by posing as a police officer.
Two girls seen in the company of the same man. One on her way to school, one on her way home from school. In one instance, it seems he might have pretended to be a police officer, which lends credence to the idea he may have used the same ruse in New York as a different, unsuspecting young girl was on her way home. But Flores has never been conclusively linked to Cesilia and Nelida’s disappearances. He was, however, apparently incarcerated for the abduction, rape, and murder of a woman and her young daughter.
I say “apparently” because America’s Most Wanted reported this information back in 2002, but a search of New York State’s correctional facilities does not turn up an Anthony Flores (or an A. Flores, Antonio Flores, or any other name variant) whose prison sentence matches this particular crime. Reports about Cesilia Pena and Nelida del Valle that mention Flores’ imprisonment do not identify Flores’ victims by name or provide additional specifics. Is Anthony “Rudy” Flores still in prison, or has he been released? Is he, in fact, serving time in New York’s state system, some other state system, or a federal facility?
Answers to these questions, and to the mystery surrounding Flores, are frustratingly difficult to find. But then, a real answer to why Nelida del Valle and Cesilia Pena disappeared thirty-seven years ago shouldn’t be so far out of reach today. All it takes is a fresh look, a reinvigorated investigation. And, in Cesilia’s case, the New York City subway system to give up a longstanding ghost.







