Sitemap

JavaScript Postfix vs. Prefix

Interesting part of JavaScript 👻

--

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Recently, I started solving some interview questions, and one of the questions was to create a counter with several actions. Here is the task description.

Implement a function makeCounter that accepts an optional integer value 
(defaults to 0) and returns an object that contains the following methods:

get(): returns the current value.
increment(): increments the current value and returns it.
decrement(): decrements the current value and returns it.
reset(): resets the current value to the initial value.

At the first glance, I was like…okay, this sould be easy for me to solve, but I did not pass the task.

This was my approach:

interface Counter {
get: () => number;
increment: () => number;
decrement: () => number;
reset: () => number;
}

function makeCounter(initialValue: number = 0):Counter {
return {
get: () => initialValue,
increment: () => initialValue++,
decrement: () => initialValue--,
reset: () => initialValue,
}
}

const counter = makeCounter(1);

console.log(counter.get())
console.log(counter.increment())
console.log(counter.increment())
console.log(counter.reset())

Can you guess the result?

Get Shan’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

The result is 1, 1, 2, 3 , I thought it should be 1, 2, 3, 1 , but why?

Blind spots

  • The makeCounter function accepts a parameter with a default value of 0. In my approach, I used the parameter directly, which caused some bugs. I should have created another variable and assigned the value of initialValue to it to help keep track of the state.
  • The initialValue++ is a postfix increment operator, which returns the value before incrementing. Therefore, when I executed counter.increment() to be 2, it had the previous value of initialValue, which was 1, and so on. Check the diagram below for more clarity.
Press enter or click to view image in full size
diagram-1

Solution

  • Create a variable to keep track of the latest state.
  • Use prefix increment operator to make sure getting the updated result.
interface Counter {
get: () => number;
increment: () => number;
decrement: () => number;
reset: () => number;
}

function makeCounter(initialValue: number = 0):Counter {
let value = initialValue;
return {
get: () => value,
increment: () => ++value,
decrement: () => ++value,
reset: () => ( value = initialValue),
}
}

const counter = makeCounter(1);

console.log(counter.get())
console.log(counter.increment())
console.log(counter.increment())
console.log(counter.reset())

Here is the diagram.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
diagram-2

--

--