What I did this summer to try and push nrtoday.com toward being digital-first.
Part of my internship at The News-Review in Douglas County, Oregon, was to “push the dial” on site numbers. Here’s what I did, and what I learned:
1: I posted more stories more consistently to Facebook.
When I got here, the Facebook crowd was doing really well but could at times be a little spotty, because we weren’t necessarily making sure every free story was published to Facebook.
Disclaimer: Reach is NOT people interacting with the page. It’s the amount of people whose newsfeed it appeared on. It doesn’t always translate super well to clicks, but it’s not a bad indicator.
I started working on website clicks around week 3 of my internship, July 13th-ish. After that date, it’s nice to see that the valleys aren’t as low and there are more spikes, even if they aren’t as high as one or two of the spikes before. I’d like to qualify those spikes before, however, by looking at them more closely.
← This is that first, biggest spike on Facebook, and it came at the same time as a spike in the seismograph, i.e. the June 1st earthquakes (remember those?).
Unfortunately, you should disregard this spike almost completely because it turns out our posts with the most reach at that time didn’t link to our site:
#3 on that list links to earthquake.usgs.gov, #2 links to a Fox 12 post on Twitter, and #1 doesn’t link to anything on our site. It’s just a text post with a recap.
It reached 33,000 people, but this June 1st spike didn’t help our site clicks at all. It may have put our name out there on Facebook to a wider audience, and maybe we got more page likes, interactions, what have you, out of it — but not a single one of those turned into a click.
Here are some site stats to prove it. June 2nd, the day after, they go up a tiny bit:
But not much. That’s only about 3,000 sessions.
That second spike in June, June 23rd, was better as far as site clicks:
Of the top 3 posts that day, two (the second and third highest) were links to stories on our website. Here’s how that shows up on the site:
The memorial follow-up post two days later does better, however.
After that, spikes are not as high but point people to our site more often. Some popular posts include the climber who was rescued by a grandpa-son combo, a bus fire, another earthquake, etc., etc.
When I started working around July 13th, my thought was that we were under-utilizing Facebook. I wanted everything free to go on there, and I thought that if we timed it out correctly (spacing our posts throughout the day and into the night), we could squeeze some more clicks out.
The fruit of those labors are nice to see. Here’s the day I started working on the website:
That huge spike is the fires. That isn’t, of course, my doing: It’s the work of the awesome breaking reporters. It’s also the fact that when I came here people were thinking so much more about social media and the website because of Jeff’s pressure.
I would like to take credit for the valleys not being so low. Since we were publishing more posts, consistently, we got a lot of posts that had a modest reach (2–4k).
Here’s our average reach this period (June 13th — September 9th) compared to the period before.
Because (like my disclaimer said earlier) reach alone isn’t a good thing to go on, let’s also talk likes, comments and shares. Here’s how many we’ve gotten since the beginning of the year:
And here’s how many since summer (remember that big spike at the beginning is the earthquake):
I started right…… here ^
While we’re on the subject of Facebook…
When we made our sports section free and in front of the paywall on the site, we wanted a way to get that free content out to all the viewers. But we didn’t think we’d have great sports reception on our main Facebook page, so I launched a second Facebook (like we’d already done with Twitter).
I won’t talk about our analytics much, because they’re pretty low, but that’s understandable — we’re new.
But we’ve been posting every day, and a few people are commenting and sharing. Here’s our most successful post so far:
The key going forward is going to be connecting with teams. One of those three shares on that post above was from the Docs’ Facebook page, and that was where a lot of comments came from too.
Okay, enough with Facebook.
2: I met our Twitter crowd and tried to strike up a conversation.
Our traditional audience isn’t on Twitter in huge numbers, but high schoolers are in droves. I was clocking almost two tweets a minute when I did a local search.
A quick snapshot of Twitter Analytics dated Aug. 7th:
And here’s the one dated today, September 9th:
If you knew nothing about our Twitter, you’d think this was amazing, but it’s only sort of cool. This doesn’t translate to too many clicks, but I think it does mean that we need to keep the Twitter momentum going.
Here’s what I’ve been doing with Twitter:
Posting every single story that’s free — some of them twice a day. With our amount of content on the website, there’s no such thing as too many tweets. I would schedule them throughout the day as well (We don’t publish every story that’s free on Facebook — only five to seven a day).
Interacting with the community. At all times, I have a TweetDeck set up on another monitor (I switch it out with a Google Analytics display) with a couple columns:
That first column is just what I’d see on my home page (tweets from my followers).
The second one is a custom search: what I typed in was this:
near:”Roseburg, OR”within:40mi
I was hoping this would catch everyone tweeting in Douglas County, but not everyone is geotagged on Twitter (some don’t put down their location), and randomly some tweeters from London started appearing on the feed a few weeks in. So it’s a little buggy.
That third column is all of my tweets. This helps when you have multiple users on the account.
The fourth one I reserve for trends. It’s everything mentioning the Douglas County Fair right now, but I had it on the Stouts Fire or the Cable Crossing Fire at other times.
These columns allow me to see what people are tweeting here and retweet them, favorite their tweets, and reply to them. This was probably the coolest part of the whole Twitter experience.
Sometimes I would have a lot of fun with Twitter because I knew not a whole lot of people read it. When we were hitting record temperatures in Douglas County, I retweeted this guy:
Inane? Sure. Silly? Sure. But it talks about something that was happening in Douglas County right then, and something that happened on a national level (Drake’s rapping) and in the midst of a bunch of serious fire coverage, I think it gave our feed a little character.
Again, let me just say that these stats aren’t due entirely to me either: Other reporters have also been tweeting and interacting more with Twitter users.
3: As far as other social media…
I posted a couple stories on Reddit that I thought had a possibility of going viral.
These were more the weird stories, like Patio Man. I posted some to r/funny and more to r/roseburg.
Oh, you didn’t know there was a subreddit for Roseburg? There is, and it’s sorta-kinda active, and Ian and I milked that slightly:
Those are the top 6 stories as of Aug. 11, and three out of five are NRtoday links (I’m social_mediacrity and Ian is MrCampbell17).
Get Scott Greenstone’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
There are a couple comments on the links as well, and a discussion about marijuana sales:
This is really nothing, especially if you look at how many clicks we got from Reddit in the last month:
But every little bit helps. And, there’s always a chance our post would go viral, like what happened to the Post Independent. Redditors love weird small-town stuff.
4. I tried to think website-first on content.
Not as much as I might like because of the website’s system, but a little bit.
Videos
The best thing about videos is once you get used to them, they’re easily integrated into your workflow. This one sort of came naturally with the story I was doing:
And this one did too:
Other times, I just tagged along with other reporters who didn’t have time to do videos.
Maps
Working to embed maps in our stories, especially with the Stouts Fire and our bad bridges stories, helped so much.
Here’s what at the time was the perimeter of the Cable Crossing Fire in Glide. When I posted this map on Facebook, we got several comments saying “Thank you!”
Here’s a map of 22 bridges that were structurally deficient in Douglas County (complete w/ Robert James Waller reference):
I also wrote some posts that were solely for the website. Our paper doesn’t publish on Mondays, so we only publish a few things to the website. Clicks tend to be really, really low. I tried to offset that a little bit by writing some online-only content like this post:
We already do polls like this all the time on the site, but there’s never really anything that wraps them up, provides quotes and reports them to readers. So I posted the question on Facebook with a link, got people to vote and asked them to comment, took two of the best comments, and incorporated all that in the story. Really easy content to write.
5. Did that help?
I did push the dial. But I discovered that we need more than just pushing the dial.
First, a couple terms:
Session: A visit to the website. You could click on 10 pages and spend thirty minutes, or you could click on one page and spend ten seconds. Both of those equal one session.
Users: Visitors.
Pages / Session: How many pages people are clicking on when they visit the site.
Average Session Duration: How long someone spent on the site during a session.
Bounce Rate: When someone clicks onto the site, reads one article for however long, and then leaves the site without clicking on more pages, it’s considered a “bounce.”
New sessions: First-time visits.
This summer at The News-Review in sessions is below, compared to the previous period in orange:
Eyes on the site is way up, but engagement is down. And that’s understandable: What we’re getting is fewer paid, loyal users and more new visitors.
Here’s the same time, but compared to the year before:
Let’s talk through those stats really quick, looking at this part:
Translation:
76% more visits were made to the website by 62% more people looking at 40% more pages than last year. But, they looked at 20% fewer pages for an average of 32 seconds less and 29% more often, they left the website after reading only one article. 7% fewer came to the site for the first time.
Where are they from?
Almost half were from Roseburg (48%) this summer. Here are the top 10 cities. Oakland is #16, Canyonville is #20, and Yoncalla is #33.
Here’s a fascinating thing: Only 66% of our readers are from Oregon. The rest are Washington (7.17%), California (6.91%), and every other state in the U.S. U.S. traffic makes up 97% of all of our traffic.
What’s our next step?
“Pushing the dial” isn’t the only thing we want. As Matthew Hindman states really well in “Stickier News,” and as we can see in our stats, we need to create more loyal, returning readers. This digital push has gotten more people coming to our site, but those new people don’t stay.
This is the next step in our digital strategy. We need to get people to stay on the website longer and come back.
A couple ways we can do that:
Site speed:
Slow-loading websites cost retailers $2.7 billion in sales every year, and news sites load the slowest out of all sites. Unfortunately, that’s a lot of back-end programming and server work, but it’s something to think about when we launch a new site (if we do).
Guide the reader:
This is another change that needs to be made in design. The site right now has some related stories at the bottom of the page and trending stories at the top, but both are buried.
One way to fix that is embedding links in the online text (which Ian and I have been doing):
Another great way is to have lists of ‘Related stories’ on the sidebar. That’s another back-end programming thing that I haven’t had any luck selling our old parent company on, sadly.
Go up a notch in design (or several):
75% of judgments on website credibility are based on a website’s overall aesthetics.
Let me say that again: Three-quarters of everybody online trusts a website if it looks nice.
Here are some local newspapers that are doing alright in stats:
This design is really helping these sites increase their market share on the Internet.
Get that newsletter off the ground:
Every $1 spent on email marketing has a return of $44.25, on average.
Get everyone online:
Everyone should have a Twitter. That should be a mandatory part of working at a local newspaper. Not only can they share their stories, they can jump into the state-wide journalism conversation on Twitter, and they’ll have a disproportionately wider influence. The Twitter sphere is small, but lots of decision-makers are on it (government officials, businessmen, personalities).
The Register-Guard’s editor asked everyone to read their news online, exclusively, for a month.
Get yourself online:
Obviously, we can’t ask anyone to do any of this stuff if we aren’t doing it. Charlie Weaver, my student newspaper’s president, told me once that you can’t make the Internet do what you want. I’d add that maybe you have to participate in it, understand it, and figure out what it wants.
I think it’s possible to bring local news to a more prominent space on the Internet if we do that.









