Ender’s Game
**So, it probably goes without saying that what follows is going to have spoilers. For the movie, the book, and the subsequent books.**
You could say I’m a bit of a fan of Ender’s Game and the books that follow it. Medium is tied to Twitter where my screen name is spkr4thedead51, a nod to the sequel novel Speaker for the Dead. And the name dates all the way back to my AOL Instant Messenger handle, so it’s definitely been part of my identity for a while. In college, I even wrote two essays referencing Ender’s Game, and the essays weren’t particularly laudatory—the novel has issues, as does the new movie.
The novel
The novel is more or less an underdog coming of age story. Ender Wiggin is a young, smaller than average wunderkind who is routinely picked on by his older brother, Peter, and by kids in his school. Except Ender isn’t really an underdog. He is so preternaturally intelligent that he is able to overwhelm all of the obstacles that face him. This is what makes the novel so enticing to teenage and preteen readers, especially those who are reading science fiction novels at that age. If you were a smart kid and somewhat awkward socially, feeling like an outsider at that age is almost de rigueur. So here is a character in Ender that it appears you can identify with.
But the thing is, you actually can’t identify with him. He’s smarter than you. He’s younger than you. He is willing to do things that no normal 10 year old—and you were more than likely normal despite feeling otherwise—is actually able or willing to do. Norman Spinrad called Ender’s Game a “masturbatory power fantasy”, and it’s probably the most accurate description of the book I’ve ever heard. The book glories in the domination Ender is able to gain over his rivals, both adult and peer. And in the book, Ender fails to become a real hero or even an antihero. That is the real failing of Ender’s Game. Even though Ender is so much better than everyone else in so many ways, he lacks the things which make him a real person.
The most important of those is agency. In the novel (less so in the movie, but, unfortunately, in a way that doesn’t improve things, though I’ll get to that later) Ender takes truly independent action only a few times—primarily in the fights with the school bullies, Stilson and Bonzo. In both of those events, he never truly has to deal with the results of his independent actions. When he fights and kills Stilson after his monitor is removed, he is not told that he killed the child. All he knows is that he won that fight and all the fights after that. And then he’s removed from the situation so that he won’t actually have to face the true repercussions of what he did and none of those potential fights in the future are even possible any more. And the same pattern occurs in the fight with Bonzo in Battle School.
The most important lack of agency though, is the battle simulations he commands in Command School. Through the entire process he is unaware that he is actually fighting the Buggers. And we’ll leave aside the fact that as smart as Ender is, he never realizes the truth about who he’s fighting, which is pretty hard to swallow against all the other insights he has along the way. I believe that Orson Scott Card removes that agency from Ender so that it is easier to redeem him in the later novels. Committing xenocide is a hard thing to recover a character from unless he’s not aware that he has done that. But in removing Ender’s agency, Card doesn’t allow Ender to undergo the growth and gain the true self-awareness necessary for Ender to be considered a hero.
There are obviously lots of ways to define a hero. But in all of the best examples of heroes in literature and movies and even real life, the person who we consider a real hero has made a conscious choice, knowing the possible repercussions of their action. Ender does not have the option because he is lied to. In the book, when he finds out what he did, we are told that he has a mental breakdown and collapses. And then, through the prompting of the mental connection that the Bugger’s queen had created with him, he finds the last queen’s egg. And then he writes a book called “The Hive Queen” that we are told absolves him of his xenocide. I say “told” because it isn’t something we see happen in Ender’s Game. It doesn’t even happen in the original sequel Speaker for the Dead. That novel is set 3000 years later where Ender has become an adult and is still alive due to the effects of relativistic space flight. And he has now come to terms with what he did and is trying to find a place to let the Hive Queen re-establish her species. The moral growth that would normally be required for a character to become a hero has occurred entirely off-screen.
Get Greg’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Card recently tried to fill in that gap with the book Ender in Exile, but still fails to establish agency for Ender in his period of moral growth. In that novel, he comes to terms with his brother who has established himself as the new Hegemon in charge of all of Earth and its colonies. He also obtains forgiveness from the Hive Queen in the egg. In both cases, his growth is entirely the product of the actions of other characters. His coming to terms with what he did is not something he himself controls. As a result, the best version of Ender ends up being the adult, well-adapted version present in Speaker for the Dead and the subsequent novels in the original series—Xenocide and Children of the Mind.
The movie
Now, in the movie, the story stays pretty close to the Ender-centric story presented in the novel. A side story about Ender’s brother and sister is entirely removed, which is understandable and a good decision cinematically. Unfortunately, some of the other necessary changes don’t happen quite as well as they should have. The most obvious of these is that a lot of time passes in the novel and the attempt to show this in the movie was left to voice overs and in-scene graphical changes to scoreboards and similar small flourishes. The result is a very hard to follow timeline. I honestly have no idea how long a period the movie is supposed to be covering. There is a key scene when Colonel Graff gets an update message that says there is something like 35 days until the fleet reaches the Bugger homeworld. In later scenes though, voice overs of Ender writing letters to his sister suggests that several months have passed. Watching the movie though, nothing occurs that makes it seem as though more than a few weeks have passed from the opening scene to the finale.
I think one of the best ways that they could have solved this would have been to do a montage of the Battle School battles. Instead it appears that Ender is a launchie for about 3 weeks, then he gets moved into Salamander Army for about 4 days, then he’s given his own army. They show clips of the standings board for the armies as Dragon Army moves up the ranks, but we only see one of the battles. And they entirely remove the stresses and successes that Ender and his soldiers deal with. It really cheapens just how good he is at what he does. I think it is unfortunate that they favored including the two fight scenes, which just reinforce the same aspect of his personality, instead of building more depth. And they only give the barest of nods to how Ender goes from being made an outsider by Graff to how he makes friends and allies of the other students. The result is that Ender goes from being a failed hero in the book, to being a flat, failed hero in the movie.
To return to some of the points I made earlier about the book, as a result of casting issues, Ender is significantly older and bigger than he is described in the book. They attempt to compensate by always having some lumbering giants in the background of shots of groups of students and by using angle tricks to make Asa Butterfield looks smaller than he is, but it doesn’t always work. And the sense that Ender is the underdog is never really there, even in the physical confrontations (or rather, especially so when set against Bonzo).
The movie does very little to attempt to return any sort of agency to Ender, though it does try. All of his actions are guided by the adults around him, even in his moments of willfulness. The most significant of these moments is after the big reveal that he destroyed the Bugger homeworld. Ender is given a wonderful rant at Graff that highlights that intention and choice are important issues for identity and the conception of being a hero or doing “good”. And then Graff has him sedated. If that’s not the clearest metaphor for removing agency, I’m not sure what is.
The movie opens with Ender’s quote about being able to understand his enemy only when he can love his enemy. And in Ender and Valentine’s conversation on the boat, they repeat that sentiment. But we certainly never really see that. Especially when Ender says that he is able to use that to destroy his enemy. In his fight with Bonzo, we see him play on Bonzo’s sense of pride and arrogance to try to gain an advantage over him. But then the result of the fight is an accident? Where is Ender’s intention then? How can it be that his choices are important here when a fluke is what ends the fight? That Ender was going to win the fight was never in question. How he won the fight should have been a key part of defining who he was, but then he didn’t actually win—the shower tile did. And then they leave it an open question as to whether Bonzo actually dies or not.
Short thoughts
So what did the movie do really well? The Battle Room was fantastic, though criminally under-used in the story. The relationship between Graff and Anderson and how they dealt with and reacted to Ender was spot on. The actual battles with the Buggers were very well done. That they didn’t try to include the Peter and Valentine story was a good choice, though it was unfortunate to lose the deeper characterizations of those characters to contrast them with Ender. The casting of the other Battle School kids was very well done—Alai and Bean and Petra were spot on.
The relationships between the kids weren’t established as well as I’d have liked, but there is a lot that happens in the novel. It’s a very tightly written story making it nearly impossible to work a lot of it into the movie. But the movie stayed pretty close to what occurred in the book, which was good. On the whole though, I think the majority of what was important in the plotting of Ender’s story arc was included. If you haven’t read the book, the movie is probably quite good, though there are likely areas where the characterization is lacking, resulting in confusion about why Ender or other characters do what they do. If you’ve read the book, like me you can enjoy having the story finally make it to the big screen, even if on the whole the presentation isn’t as full as it probably should have been.
A few days ago I mentioned that I’d probably burn down the bookstore the first time I saw a copy of Ender’s Game with cover art using an image from the movie. While I enjoyed the movie, I would say that it is at best an OK adaptation. As such, there is really no good reason for any of the books to take imagery from the movie. Except of course that the publishers want to capitalize on the release of the movie. So my concern for the safety of bookstores still stands. If the movie had been exceptional, I’d be less concerned. If you enjoy science fiction, don’t mind a few plot holes, confusing timelines, and somewhat flat characters when the spectacle of the movie is good, then you should definitely go see Ender’s Game. If you are emotionally invested in the novel, firstly, you need to calm down because it really isn’t as good of a book as you think it is, and, secondly, you probably will be at best lukewarm about the movie, so maybe go see it as a matinee instead of a full-price ticket.





