Sitemap

Are Mobile Games a Form of Art?

Video Games Made the Cut… What About Mobile?

4 min readJan 6, 2014

--

In 2012, the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) acquired 14 video games for its collection, sparking a heated debate over whether video games qualify as art. Some argued that, with a major museum exhibiting video games, the case had closed: video games would henceforth be considered Art (with a capital A). Others balked at MoMA’s decision and rejected the idea that video games were anything more than entertainment. Still others gave credit to games as design feats, but differentiated design from art. The impassioned debate continues today, with museum acquisitions at the forefront (just last month the Smithsonian acquired Halo 2600 and Flower for Playstation 3).

What about mobile games? Mobile games are sweeping the industry, so naturally, it seems time to apply the same question to this new medium. In 10 years, will MoMA be exhibiting smartphones with Candy Crush Saga on-screen? And if so, how will they determine that mobile games have made the cut?

It’s hard to predict, but two categories will almost certainly be on the radar of decision-makers: game design and game legacy.

Game Design

Game development lies at the cross-section of design and technology. Game developers are hyper-focused on user experience, and designers spend hours behind their computers striving to create games that captivate users with creative visuals and immersive play.

The merits of a game’s design fall into two buckets. Outwardly, we can evaluate the game’s aesthetic quality. Infinity Blade for iOS comes to mind as the pinnacle of a picturesque game. Its sparkling seascape is stunning, to the point where screenshots from the game could be mistaken as paintings of 17th-century ships and cavernous islands.

Screenshot from Infinity Blade III: Heroes
Screenshot from Infinity Blade III: Heroes

More often, though, games win admiration for Interaction Design, or the ability to create a unique and complex experience for gamers. Interaction Design is important; MoMA curator Paola Antonelli identified it as her main criteria in selecting video games for the museum. Mobile games, in all their touchscreen glory, have unique interactive capabilities. Designers have the opportunity to reinvent their development as a result, designing games specifically for touchscreens and handheld devices that users can flip, turn, curve, and swipe.

A number of popular games illustrate the range of possibilities for touchscreen-centric Interaction Design. Fruit Ninja is reliant on players’ ability to whiz their index fingers around the touchscreen at lightning speed, slicing fruit and avoiding bombs all the while. The 3-dimensional puzzle game The Room adds subtle and sophisticated elements to its touchscreen controls: to open a locked case, players must finely swipe a circle to line up the keyhole, use a drag-and-drop motion to place the key into the hole, twist the key by swiping in a quarter-circle, and open the case by swiping up and down. The motions require concentration and delicacy of touch.

Of course, code is the driving force powering a mobile game’s aesthetic and interaction design, which is why MoMA used code as another criteria for choosing those 14 games back in 2012. When looking at mobile, we can also evaluate the elegance of its source code. The most celebrated mobile games in the future might just be those with the best-written Objective-C.

Get SponsorPay’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=YzGjO5aHShQ

Game Legacy

After game design, the next big question in the mobile-games-as-art debate is cultural relevance. Have mobile games changed our day-to-day culture?

To an extent, yes. Half the U.S. population — over 150,000,000 people — plays mobile games at least once a month, and at least 53% of smartphone users have been playing games on a daily basis since 2012. These stats come to life during commute time. Anyone can survey their bus or subway car and count the rows of passengers playing games on their phones. Mobile gaming has changed the way people interact with devices and has defined the cultural phenomenon of portable gameplay. That’s a meaningful and perhaps even artistic feat.

The long-term legacy of mobile games is harder to predict. Will particular mobile games or characters leave their mark? Will our culture accept and place a new generation of iconic Marios and Pac-Mans on the map? Will we one day look back on mobile games as a crucial stepping-stone for the next big thing in gaming?

The answers to these questions will likely determine which mobile games rank as artistic achievements. We won’t know the outcome for a while, but maybe the next time you curve your iPhone with finesse to cross your game’s finish line, you’ll recognize the beauty in mobile gameplay.

Further Resources:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_games_as_an_art_form

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/13/arts/video-games/pixels-floating-on-the-art-worlds-margins.html

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/gamesblog/2012/mar/15/journey-game-or-interactive-art

http://neoludica.blogspot.it/p/artisti.html

http://www.wired.com/gamelife/2012/11/moma-videogames/

http://journals.sfu.ca/loading/index.php/loading/article/view/119

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/27133/The_Art_History_Of_Games_Games_As_Art_May_Be_A_Lost_Cause.php

http://www.polygon.com/2013/12/17/5222078/smithsonian-acquires-flower-halo-2600-for-its-permanent-collection

http://mentalfloss.com/article/51196/how-and-why-moma-acquired-video-games

--

--

SponsorPay
SponsorPay

Written by SponsorPay

SponsorPay fuels the app economy by creating smarter solutions for ad monetization.