Evasion
As I suggested at the end of my last post, I’ve been bothered by how the terrible academic job market has been used as a way to justify hiring practices. Because no one should expect to get an academic job, regardless of their qualifications, any instance of someone not getting one can be put down to “bad luck”. In that post, I was concerned about how this automatically neutralized claims about the role of white male supremacy in hiring, at least when it comes to discussing why any one over-qualified minority didn’t get a job: the failure of any individual to get a job can always be attributed to bad luck, because of course there are plenty of over-qualified people not getting jobs.
Shortly after I wrote that post, another piece of quit-lit appeared, making related points. The author, Erin Bartram, felt that she was not allowed to grieve over the end of her academic career, partly because she wasn’t supposed to expect a job in the first place. Relatedly, she felt that the profession did not grieve over such losses either — quit-lit is confined to those who quit. Part of the lack of grief is because, as she reports, many of her soon-to-be-former colleagues reassure her that she can still contribute to the profession by publishing.
In that essay, I see many threads related to the general theme of evasion of responsibility. Bartram writes:
I just want us to be honest with ourselves about who exactly we’re trying to comfort when we offer people this advice [to continue publishing] and what we’re actually asking of those people when we offer it.
Reading this made me realize the following: So much of what stayers say to quitters when they leave is to comfort the stayers themselves; to avoid acknowledging the loss to the profession, and to avoid facing how they share responsibility for the loss.
Get liminal traversals’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Take this juxtaposition for example. We continue to tell many quitters that their work is “valuable” or “worth doing”. Yet, we also propagate the narrative that they shouldn’t expect to get a job, or that the people who get fancy jobs deserve them because of their genius. I’m interested in interrogating what we mean by “valuable” in these contexts. As Bartram acknowledges, it sounds petty to ask how your work is valuable if no one will pay you a living wage to do it. But is it really petty?
One way to interrogate the phrase is: Worth doing to whom? Clearly, it’s not worth doing for the person who is being encouraged to do it. Is there some sense of worth doing that is not indexed to its worth for the quitter? Academics like to think that there is, I suppose. That’s the whole basis for sifting people based on their pieces of writing, deciding which essays should be published, and so on. So this person’s work is valuable in some objective sense, but she shouldn’t have expected a job anyway. It’s valuable enough that it ought to continue to be disseminated — hence the plea for the person to continue publishing without monetary compensation. Perhaps the thinking is that in an ideal world, that person would still be able to be paid to do that research.
Somehow, retreating to this notion of “valuable” makes me uneasy. I’m not saying that the only notion of “valuable” worth having is one in which the only valuable actions are those that get you money. It’s more the continued use of the term in these contexts — contexts which are very far from the ideal world. It smacks a little of how white people do political philosophy by appealing to ideal theory [pdf], and in doing so, end up ensuring the irrelevance of their debates to people of color. In some way, the “reassurance” from peers that your work is “valuable” feels a little like the claim from many white political philosophers that one day their theories will lead to actual racial justice.
I need to think more about why that is. In both cases, I think there is something evasive about the answers being given. I’ve already suggested in my previous post that part of what’s going on is an evasion of responsibility, and that’s part of what’s going on in the ideal theory case too — the framework of mainstream Anglo political philosophy defines the details of implementation as out of its purview, and so evades any responsibility as to how useless the framework is for ongoing concerns that merely happen to harm certain groups disproportionately.
The flip side of evading responsibility or even feelings of loss for those who leave is worshipping those who “succeed”. We go on and on about how so many who don’t get a job are unlucky but we don’t acknowledge how their supposed lack of luck is premised upon lucky people getting jobs that they aren’t necessarily qualified for. Instead, the usual academic prestige games go on undisrupted: the disparity in hero-worship between those who get fancy jobs and those who get “only” teaching jobs doesn’t seem to have lessened. (This tweet describes the asymmetry well.) So many self-proclaimed progressives in the academy play lip service to social justice and diversity, but will happily swoon at the feet of the next great white genius as much as any conservative would.





