I don’t think iBeacons will ever kill NFC
That’s very unlikely
One of my friends recently wrote a post: “iBeacons: NFC-killer for Retail?” and I totally disagree with the assertion that iBeacons can kill NFC, in general and in retail. There are two reasons why I think that way:
- Betteridge’s law of headlines
- Benefits of NFC outweigh the benefits of Bluetooth/Bluetooth Low Energy (the technology on which iBeacons is based on).
Allow me to elaborate
Security
Whether you use Bluetooth or NFC, you are still transmitting sensitive information. But here’s a twist — Bluetooth has a range of a couple of meters whereas NFC has a range of couple of centimeters and having a low range actually makes NFC more secure against attacks and eavesdropping since Bluetooth requires you to be in the same room as the victim in order to snoop on the victim’s device whereas NFC requires you to be at least an inch close to the victim. NFC also uses encryption while transmitting data whereas Bluetooth doesn’t. Infact, NFC is so secure that it is used to securely pair bluetooth devices and payments in retail stores these days.
Get Suyash Srijan’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Bluetooth, inherently, is a very insecure technology.
Cost and Power
As you all know, running a Bluetooth device consumes power, even when the device uses Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE). On the other hand, NFC is based on Radio-frequency identification, also known as RFID, so a passive NFC device does not require a power source. There’s also licensing and patent costs involved when using Bluetooth and manufacturing Bluetooth devices are more expensive than manufacturing NFC devices.
It’s more expensive to implement a device powered by Bluetooth and there will always be some power consumption.
Effectiveness
Bluetooth Low Energy uses RSSI fingerprinting and triangulation as part of its localisation methods, methods that aren't perfect and easily affected by polarization of the antenna, multipath propagation, obstacles and more.
Bluetooth Low Energy is pretty ineffective indoors, like in retail shops.
Requirement
NFC is simply more popular and better so there is simply no requirement of Bluetooth Low Energy (or iBeacons). NFC is used for a lot of things including payments, customizable NFC stickers that can trigger a variety of actions, railway/train cards, quickly and securely pairing with Bluetooth devices, etc. BLE isn't simply that powerful and the demand isn't just there because NFC works perfectly fine. “Interactive tours”, as mentioned in that post, is easily possible using Google Indoor Maps and coupon discoverability is also easily possible with the help of Groupon.
There isn’t an actual requirement of iBeacons or Bluetooth Low Energy in retail stores or in general.
I really don't understand the point of creating methods that are limited to one platform instead of utilizing something that is a major growing standard being already used by millions of people worldwide daily and is proven to be great. By creating iBeacons, which has several implications pertaining to security, effectiveness and cost, Apple is simply limiting adoption. Also, I don't think anyone would like companies sending them deals and coupons and other kind of spam whenever they enter a store.








