Classifying Cash Flowing Real Estate
a strictly financial perspective
From a strictly financial perspective there are four basic classes of income producing property. Within those classes are some specialized sub-classifications, which sometimes have different financial standards. For example, a government (as tenant) Class A investment is not comparable to a multifamily Class A Residential product, a Strip Mall or an Industrial property.
The following financial classifications focus on risk versus reward perceptions within the real estate investment market.
A is for Apple; “Class A” investment property is every savvy investor’s fantasy. Great location, clean and presentable, cost effective maintenance; a fat and happily nurtured cash cow with a projected 10+ years of stable income. With a Class A property, you should expect improving rents over time without having to lift a finger other than to check your bank balance! Such jewels are hard to find; when you do, expect a cap of 4-5% out of the best of these. Think; “Gold with cash flow”! Most ordinary investors are lucky to have even one of these in their portfolio. Many investors never actually get to own something like this, usually elbowed out by hedge funds and instituional investors. If you do, it will surely be the apple of your eye!
B is for “below par”, which means a lot of B class properties pose as A’s. Sometimes you’ll even see a “C” trying to pose as an “A”; those stand out like a turkey among swans. Simply put, if it does not closely meet the specific criteria, it’s not an A, it’s something else. So one of the best ways to categorize a “B” class commercial property is to see if it is missing one of the “A” class attributes. Expect a CAP rate of 5-8% against Net Operating Income when it comes to selling or acquiring a “B” class property.
Now it gets a little more complicated, separating the C’s from the other C’s and the D’s!
C is for “cool”, “crowded” and “crashing”. Yeah, you sure get all the varieties and vagaries here. What’s best about C+ properties? Stabilized cash flow from older, maintenace heavy real estate usually situated in blue collar and industrial areas. Honorable people and businesses that pay their rent month after month and can’t or won’t pay management fees or spend a dime on preventative maintenace. Sometimes it’s just that the property is old and tired in a desirable location.
Get The Affinity Group’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The really good ones of these are professionally managed, “well let” properties (90%+ occupancy), or perhaps even have a waiting list hovering in the background, especially on the smaller products. How about 100% occupied with no renter changes for years? These properties can be hard to find, but they are all here and much desired by savvy investors who are more than happy to pull out a 9-12% CAP rate (or higher) with a minimum 4-5 year projection of that income as solid. Mister Savvy understands he has to nurture his cash flow and flip his products to stay ahead of this highly aggressive financial return curve and he understands the sometimes very subtle differences between C+ Deals and the less attractive “C“ and “C-“properties.
The lower end of this market segment, referred to as C- are often distressed properties or even something crashing out of another class in a spiral of imploding economic viability.
Then there’s the rabble, the busted flushes, the orphans. These are most of the “D” properties, properties that are not quite broken, but are perilously close to it. With any properties in these classes the challenges and costs of rehabilitation can be large and dangerously unpredictable. Whatever you think you can do, these deals are all a challenge to even the most skilled investors and should not be undertaken lightly.
D is for distressed, dysfunctional, dying and development. Commercial Property Dysfunctionality (CPD) is the condition forced upon an income producing property by bad circumstances, poor management and irresponsible, uncaring or even distressed ownership. Family and partner disputes can be a huge factor in the economic collapse of a property — as can age. Cash flowing properties need nurturing and that takes up time and energy too.
The essence of a D class commercial property is essentially this; it’s a property that for whatever reasons nobody cares about and you can only put commercial back in its’ description if it has an 80% or higher potential be redeveloped for positive cash flow.
With many “D” properties, the owners have drained the income for years, investing little or nothing in maintenance and marketing, until the property begins to crash from neglect. They then attempt to market it as a “B” property based on its long gone glory years, hoping for an unwary or inexperienced Buyer. Inexpert Buyers are in relatively short supply these days. So it’s always going to be tough to sell a dysfunctional property, but nothing as impossible as selling “D for dead” and that’s the only consolation we can offer these owners. Creative professional marketing and a vigilant realism as to pricing is what usually sells these properties.
Just because it’s economically dead does not mean a property is worthless; it just means it’s not commercial and produces nothing more than weeds in the often long wait for economic rejuvenation or a higher and better use. Sometimes dead means a property crawls back to being raw dirt before finding a better or new life. The best you can hope for is that the process does not cost you more than its’ worth and whatever it does cost can be recovered immediately — with a profit.
So what’s the honest economic classification of your cash flowing property? How much do you value your credibility? By the way, whatever you say your property classification is, unless it’s a very recognizable A Class, don’t expect everyone to agree with you!
This article was first posted on ‘‘The Affinity Group’’
By David Tracey
ooOOoo









