Overvaluing Higher Education
These are not the qualifications you’re looking for
Maybe this is something that is more common in first or second generation immigrants to the US, but lately I’ve been noticing an alarming trend of people who blindly place way too much value on higher education. In a lot of countries, if you don’t have a college degree, your chances of pursuing a career and/or providing for yourself and your family are slim. Because of this, a lot of immigrants bring this mentality with them to the US and continue to place a lot of value on education. I know this because this is how I was raised by my immigrant parents as with most of the people I grew up with. A lot of people correlate education with job security, which isn’t a terrible belief to follow, but is also misguided and if followed too blindly, can lead people into a lot of debt, wasted time, and disappointment. The more education you have doesn’t result in a proportional amount of job security or pay. In fact, in many cases it can make you worse off.
In our economy and the closest thing we’ve seen in human history to the free market, employees are hired largely based on the value they bring to an organization. This “value” could really be a variety of things, such as their effectiveness as a salesperson, efficiency as engineers to create and innovate, effectiveness of dissecting legal documents and translating them into billable hours, ability to educate students with high graduation rates, etc… The list goes on, but notice that almost none of your effectiveness (or how well you do your job) is defined by your level of education. Yes obviously you can’t be a doctor without going to medical school, and you can’t practice law without passing the bar, but sadly now even people in these competitive professions have trouble finding and keeping jobs that pay what they need to make the time and money spent in school worth it (especially where I live, in California). I can’t tell you how many people I’ve met who blindly believe that by simply getting an extra degree, employers will knock down their doors throwing insanely lucrative job offers at them. I understand where this belief came from, but in reality this almost never happens unless the position is directly related to the experience the person gained during their time in school (eg. research labs).
Get Jason Youn’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Here are some examples I’ve experienced first hand:
- I often interview candidates for software engineering positions. A lot of people somehow think that if you have a PhD from MIT, you’re automatically a better software engineer than someone who only has a high school diploma. Watch any movie or TV show when they try to introduce some egghead genius programmer. They’ll almost always throw in something like “graduated top of his/her class at Cal Tech”. In my years as both a hiring manager and software engineer who has worked with many other software engineers, I’ve noticed that people with post graduate degrees often are less qualified than their non post graduate educated counterparts. Instead of investing their time getting work experience and learning practical skills, they spent that time in a classroom and labs, expanding their theoretical knowledge. That’s fine if they’ve planned on staying in academia, but it is usually not the case for most people. I recently had a candidate interview for an internship and she was finishing her 2nd post graduate degree in Computer Science. I asked her if she was familiar with common software development practices and she laughed, saying “of course, I have a Master’s degree in Computer Science!” I replied, “Ok, great! Can you give me an example of when you would use an abstract class vs an interface?” followed by some more similarly basic questions and not surprisingly, she couldn’t begin to answer any of them.
- I have a couple of friends who recently graduated law school and passed the bar. They have a mind-blowing amount of student loan debt ($200k+), that costs as much as a monthly mortgage payment to pay back. They also haven’t been able to find jobs so they had to go into deferment, where their debt has only grown from interest. Because of this, they took jobs that pay half of what they expected they’d be making after law school and are faced with trying to make rent while paying $3,000+/month for their student loans.
The majority of people don’t want to change the world. Most people are practical. They want to live comfortably and provide for their family, and preferably have a fulfilling career. The most common way to do this is to obtain a high-skilled job, and the best way to get that is by having marketable skills, and the best way to get that is by experience. Sometimes this means they have to take an internship position in the beginning, or a job that doesn’t pay well or isn’t fun, or having to deal with difficult bosses. But the time and stress invested is traded for valuable experience that they can use as they further their career. Yes most high-skilled positions require an undergraduate degree, so go for that if you think you should. But seriously think twice before thinking about getting that Master’s, and if you decide to pursue it, try to validate your motivations.






