Sitemap
David Tucker Whitaker, Full Friday

David Tucker Whitaker, Full Friday

Servant Leader | Problem-Solver | Speaker - helping individuals and teams achieve triumphant breakthroughs.

How to Win with Gamification

6 min readMar 11, 2014

--

Over the last few years, gamification has become one of the “go-to moves” for companies looking to drive digital engagement and retention. According to Forbes, between 40 and 70 percent of the companies on their Global 1000 list are either using gamification, or plan to by 2015. That helps give some context to the new wave of sites proliferating the internet with badges, points, and other rewards. There can be little debate on whether gamification can create brand loyalty, and repeat customers — that much we know for sure. What is more difficult to define for most brands (and even some of the experts) is how to do it right.

What is Gamification?

In his book, For the Win: How Gamification Can Revolutionize Your Business, Kevin Werbach defines gamification as “the use of game elements and game design techniques in non-game contexts.” It’s a broad conceptual definition that covers a wide range of potential applications, from business, to civic or employee engagement. It also gives brands, and developers a lot of latitude in defining how they approach gamification, and as such, explains how real world applications vary greatly in structure, and effectiveness.

When done correctly, gamification changes a user’s experience from that of a passive visitor to more of an active participant. It creates a sense of community via competition and other forms of motivation that intuitively responds to a users psychographics, preferences and behaviors. In a very fundamental way, the success of gamification initiatives rely heavily on the platforms ability to appeal to users need for recognition, achievement, or plain old greed, and applying those carrots into a structure that is consistent, intuitive, and enjoyable. Like so many things in the life, the devil in the details.

LinkedIn’s onboarding and profile management provides user with constant incentives to complete or update key areas of their profile. This approach to “gamifying” person input is subtle, but creates just enough incentive and motivation, to be effective with Linkedin’s largely professional user-base. But they are not alone. This tactic is being employed by many business and consumer-related sites with the ideal outcomes are fairly consistent: a) users who invest more time in setting up their online experience are likely to be more rewarded and engaged, and b) the mere act of investing time in your profile creation makes you more likely to stick around.

Conversely, the NFL went for a more splashy approach when they launched NFL Fan Rewards back in August 2012. The much ballyhooed program (reportedly the work of Seattle gamification company, BigDoor) featured all the bells and whistles, but could never achieve any real success in driving fan engagement, and was shutdown less than year after it launched. This was a shocking turn of events for many reasons, including the fact that the overwhelming popularity of the NFL, and the expertise of BigDoor was not enough to turn this investment into a winner.

The NFL FAN Rewards program gets sacked

The failure of NFL Fan Rewards highlights the challenges of developing gamification for both businesses and consumers. Even with a brand as strong as the NFL, and with a user base as loyal and well-defined as pro football fans, they were still unable to create a solution that met the needs of the league, and the expectations of their users. That kind of disconnect can be attributed to any number of variables, but almost all of them fall under the category of poor design. In the case of the NFL, they may have went for a hail mary, when a five yard pass would've sufficed.

Gartner’s research indicates that 80 percent of current applications will fail to meet their business objectives due to poor design. It’s a sobering thought, but not really that surprising. It’s easy to see how well-intentioned designers and business leaders would be signing off on strategies that fall short of expectations. Finding the right balance of game elements, functional workflow, usability, and enjoyment is a an extremely daunting task, even while looking very straightforward. Just think about how many actual big name video games have failed. How about movies, albums, investments, sports teams, and so on. Organizations spend big budgets on big projects that are sure to be a big hit. Right up until they’re not.

Gamification is near the peak of Gartner Hype Cycles and like most new trends and technologies, the initial hype surrounding the trend creates unrealistic expectations for success and many poor implementations follow. — Brian Burke

For web companies, there’s a big risk of turning customers away with cookie-cutter, or cluster$#&% programs that simply don’t address the unique needs of a business or its users. Many of the high hopes (and high investments) in systems designed to drive longer, and more frequent user sessions, will actually result in the opposite, if they result in anything at all. Even those ill-conceived programs that manage not to repel users, still run the risk of ending up in one of those “How not to…” blogs posts (like this one) that can be equally hard to live down.

Gamification Done Right

Get David Tucker Whitaker, Full Friday’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Most are familiar with the more notable examples of success with gamification. Foursquare is probably the poster child for gamification, having made badges famous among millennials. In recent years, the company has toned down the emphasis on badges to cater to a broader market, but the fundamental structure of the program still remain. Yelp leveraged a relatively tame gamification structure to drive exponential user acquisition, retention, and a strong user community. Duolingo, a relative newcomer, is a well-designed language learning app that uses simple gamification to incent users to learn more. The success of their gamification is tightly woven into a simple learning process, a clean, friendly interface, and a straightforward point system that’s easy to understand.

Nick Draeger does a good job of outlining the 5 Essentials of Gamification Design:

  1. A clearly defined learning objective
  2. How will it benefit the user
  3. Clear rules
  4. User feedback
  5. Focus on intrinsic, not just extrinsic rewards

For those embarking on gamification projects, and who are really looking to dive in to the details, there are numerous resources available online, including courses, whitepapers, and research data. Here are our best practices for getting started:

  • Start with a good product — No gamification, no matter how fancy or well designed, can makeup for a product that nobody wants to use. Gamification is an element of UX that sits on top of solid product development, so even if your game design is on par with legendary greats like Super Mario Brothers or Tetris (dating myself a bit there), it really won’t matter if your underlying product is more akin to jacks. Though Yelp’s Elite status is important, there success has less to do with gamification and more to do with a good product/market fit and a big audience of self-proclaimed foodies and critics.
  • Keep it Simple, Stupid (KISS) — More times than not, gamification projects fail because of complexity. The types of complexities that distract users from deriving the core value of the product, or are too cumbersome to be done repeatedly. Like actual video games, gamification must have high replay enjoyment, and should ultimately incent users to do more of what they already want to do, not force them into what companies want. Overly involved game design forces users to think too much about how or why they use your site, which invariably means that most of them won’t.
  • Design for YOUR users. Forget about what other companies are doing. Forget about what Bunchball, Badgeville, or BigDoor have in their latest case studies. Start where you would for any new project intended to engage your users. That’s right, start with your users. For your program to be effective, it can’t be derived from a generic, one-size-fits-all approach with no relevance to your users, but one that is uniquely designed to grasp the interest of the people who visit your website and buy your products.

There is certainly a lot of buzz surrounding gamification, and the rush to get in on the hype will lead many brands to an expensive (and embarrassing) dead end. But where there’s smoke, there is usually fire, and for gamification, the fire reflects real grounded insight into how companies, employers, schools, etc. can use proven game principles to incent all kinds of constructive behavior. Like fire, though, the trick of gamification for many organizations will be using just enough to illuminate a path for users, but not so much that they burn down their brands, or their reputations.

Let me know what you think. Tweet me at @davidbuilds

If you enjoyed this post, please click the Recommend button. Thanks!

This post originally appears on Bravegenius.com

--

--

David Tucker Whitaker, Full Friday
David Tucker Whitaker, Full Friday

Written by David Tucker Whitaker, Full Friday

Servant Leader | Problem-Solver | Speaker - helping individuals and teams achieve triumphant breakthroughs.