Sitemap
Tyler Haulotte

Tyler Haulotte

Justifying Philosophy

Why philosophy needs no apology.

4 min readJul 15, 2014

It’s a common experience for me to come across articles which attempt to justify philosophy, either entirely as a discipline or a choice for a major in undergraduate study, and afterwards be some combination of sad and annoyed. I think that it’s really important to emphasize that attempts to apologize for philosophy or the humanities in general will always fail. If you’re trying to convince someone of the utility of philosophy, they have frankly failed to understand the purpose of the pursuit, and to attempt to describe its utility is selling out its true nature. There’s no point in this debate, because the way that the other person is thinking about the topic of discussion is inappropriate, and before there’s a change in mindset in the questioner it’s simply impossible to have a fruitful discussion.

There are several examples of this sort of thing. Here’s a passage which appears in The Atlantic, which I chose not because it’s especially exemplary of the problem or because I found it particularly offensive, but because it’s the most recent one I’ve come across:

“But, for the most part, the philosophers aren’t deploying their firm grasp of Kierkegaard in their private-sector work. Rather, it’s the skills that philosophers are trained in—critical thinking, clear writing, quick learning—that translate well to life outside of academia.” — Rebecca Rosen, in “What do Philosophers Do?”

Another illustrative passage occurs at the end with a comment by a former Ph.D. student:

“If I had to highlight one weakness in my postgraduate training it would be the lack of discussion of how the skills developed during a philosophy Ph.D. can be used elsewhere.” — Carl Baker, in “What do Philosophers Do?” by Rebecca Rosen.

Here we see close reading of philosophical texts disparaged in favor of the skills one acquires from philosophy which can transfer over to the world of business. This is the typical defense of the humanities: they have a utility which extends outside of its ivory tower pretensions, and they ought to be saved for precisely that reason. Here we see that philosophy is justified only in terms of its extrinsic value to what the article dubs (in single quotations, as if the article itself is skeptical of the term) “the real world.”

Get Tyler Haulotte’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Of course, the philosophy defended in these articles is a humanities purged of its supposedly “unnecessary” or “eccentric” elements, which have no immediate utility for “the real world.” I am reminded here of Zizek’s analysis of cultural capitalism, wherein commodities attempt to eliminate the guilt of the purchaser in being merely a consumer through the corporation’s supposed humanitarianism.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpAMbpQ8J7g

One might formulate this new vision of the humanities in a sales pitch—similar to Tom’s one-for-one—in the following way: critical thinking without Kant.

This captures the new vision of the humanities posited by this movement, to retain “the humanities” while eliminating their excessive close reading component which is not useful to the “real world.” Close readings of Kant, one can hear them say, won’t help you in the real world. You will not be interviewed about the transcendental synthesis of apperception.

What it also captures, I think, is the utter absurdity of this movement. There is no “critical thinking,” as we commonly understand the word, without Kant, because Kant identified the schema in which the word “critical” acquires its proper meaning. The discipline of philosophy defended is completely alien to how it is understood by those who practice it. In the same way that for Zizek cultural capitalism only makes a spectacle of humanitarianism, this philosophy is only a hollow shell of its true self: a series of platitudes or mindsets without the accompanying work involved in true philosophical exposition.

This is not to say that one has to have read The Critique of Pure Reason in order to think critically. Instead, what I’ve meant to suggest is that these apologies attempt to think of philosophy or the humanities purged of its real content miss the mark completely. It defends a philosophy of business, totally divorced from its tradition. They attempt to get to the real core of philosophy—the wisdom and critical thinking—without engaging in the texts which they see as superfluous by comparison. The truth of the matter, however, is that the supposedly superfluous supplement is actually what is essential, and the supposed core is actually very unphilosophical platitudes and “mindsets.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElnGREiaR5M

The reason I believe all of these attempts fail is because they do not treat theory as an end in itself. Philosophy is told, in these cases, to serve a higher purpose in the real world, but this philosophy completely is alienated from its history. It’s, in short, to think of philosophy unphilosophically. To treat theory as an end in itself means a deep respect for the philosophical tradition without any extrinsic justification. This doesn’t mean that theory doesn’t have to deal with practice, but instead that theory is always already practice.

When people ask me why I study philosophy, I don’t really know what to tell them. I suspect that I ought to answer that it will allow for me to think deeply, or that it will help either myself or others, that I will attain some “enlightenment” from it. I started with these sorts of more utility oriented answers when I was first beginning to study, though I was never so pretentious as to believe I was being led towards enlightenment. I even tried to convince others of the value of the discipline at first. But I began to realize that I was lying, that I didn’t really believe that I was helping others by studying philosophy, and that even if I was that wasn’t the real reason I was doing what I was doing. I eventually came to the realization that I simply have a profound respect for the work that is done in philosophy, one which I ultimately find difficult to articulate or explain, and that I simply can’t do anything else.

I refuse to apologize for philosophy, because I don’t think that there is any need for an apology.

--

--