The Foetus conversation
A doctor’s dilemma
What are the main ingredients for an intense conversation on Foetuses? You need a Doctor who has been there, done that; you need a friend of the doctor; you need the proper environment and then finally you need someone to observe the conversation.
Dharwad is a simple town. Located in Karnataka, I opine it to be one of the most peaceful and culturally rich places in South India. So peaceful that it is easy to ignore the town completely. In such a town, do my Parents live. And only a few weeks ago I gave them a visit.
What does a stressed design student do when he finds a retreat in a place like this? I lazed off right from the beginning, of course. Right until at 3.00 PM, we had an unannounced guest at our doorstep: One elderly woman, and oh I should be condemned for calling her elderly, for although she was somewhere in her seventies, she looked no older than fifty. She was a gynecologist and a family friend, and naturally the doctor who took me out into this world twenty two years ago. She was visiting us to discuss her new book, which she intended to write on the story of her hospital.
As all conversations happen, this too derailed from the subject and went everywhere. It began with the discussion about a dancer whose mother or grandmother was once a devdasi, a sex worker; soon from sex worker the conversation somehow managed to land itself into the topic of her past delivery cases.
“I was quite young back then,” the doctor recounted. “Young enough to not know how to stop pondering over what is right and what is wrong. We all have that phase, don’t we?” the doctor smirked. “The hospital was new, fresh with the smell of the first happy patients. I think this was in the 80s, I am not quite sure. One evening, I had just finished carrying out a delivery and was about to sign off, when I received a call requesting me to carry out one last delivery before I left since we were short of gynecologists that day. I agreed and went up to the ward which temporarily belonged to this pretty young woman who was carrying, and her water had just broken. I examined her and with a smile I had assured her that it would all be okay, and saying so I had left to arrange and cleanse. And that is when I got a call.” Her eyes bulged, especially as she stressed on a call.” What call, I asked. She looked at me and paused before replying.
“The nurse was frantic. The woman whom I had just met, had broken into a violent series of convulsions. That is not normal, Varun. That is not normal at all. I ran to her ward as fast as I could. But alas, her state was beyond cure. She was dead before I reached.
“Again and again I had asked myself, what had I done wrong? Convulsions such as these are not natural; they either suggest a severe misjudgment in our primary diagnosis, or an anomaly as inexplicable as a sudden hemorrhage. Right then and there I had decided that I was not cut out to handle patients yet. But I changed my mind the very minute I saw the faces of her family.
Get VARUNASURA’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
“What would you be expecting to hear? You would be dreading the moment when you have to meet the family. They would cry, they would blame you, they might even become violent. What I witnessed, however, was an entirely different event. Blank faces, and why, I swear I saw a glint of relief in the husband’s face. Very strange, it was. Very. And after I was done explaining the inexplicable, the simply nodded and asked one simple question: ‘Before we cremate her, could you take the baby out of her body?’
“It was a very simple question, wasn't it? Well to ask at least. The question sent me reeling with confusion. ‘The baby is dead,’ I had replied, ‘Why would you want it to be taken out even then?’ Their stony faces had simply responded with blank looks and a reply which was something like, ‘Please do it.’ To console myself, I created explanation that maybe, they would want to cremate the bodies separately. Anyway, I was in no mood to argue, so I relented.
“The next morning when my maid saw me depressed, sitting in a corner of my house, she approached and as any good woman would do, asked me what had happened. I told her, and only after she gave me her opinion on it did the whole incident’s strangeness dissolve, but only to make way for shock.
“ ‘ Very simple’, she had replied casually, ‘ In their religion you cannot poison a woman while she is still carrying a baby; and obviously they did not want to face the society after having gone against this!’ only then it had struck me that convulsions and severe vomiting are sure shot signs of poisoning.”
“Did they do that to avoid a girl child to be born?” my mother asked.
“No, I don’t think that was the case. I am guessing it was a case of dowry, and maybe they had murdered her to prove a point.”
The doctor’s voice was monotonous as she said these, and when she saw the ripple of shock pass through her audience, she only smiled sadly. “This happened in Dharwad, you say? But Dharwad has such an open minded community!” exclaimed my distraught mother.
“Superficial open mindedness, dear, that is what it is. Culture does not change a person from inside, it only adds layers to your behaviour! Allow me to take another example to justify, if it does not disturb you.” Without waiting for my mother’s permission, she went on. “I had aborted at least a dozen babies for this sex worker who obviously did not care to use protection” she started, and just before my father could protest in horror, she added, “but of course this was so many years back; this was before abortion and sex determination was banned, Putta .” (that’s what our family friends call my father.)
“ Once again her case was in front of me, but this time it was a little different, more serious. This time she wanted to keep the baby, and when she approached the client who had knocked her out, he had thrown acid over her genital organs.” I let out a gasp. “ What was I supposed to do? Thankfully I could save the woman, but I had to sacrifice the child.The woman was heartbroken after that incident.” Uncomfortable silence ensued.
“But why would you even agree to abort a baby? Wouldn’t your own ethical principles make you stand up against such atrocities?” my Father asked. The very moment the question was posed, I knew that it would not be easy to answer.
The doctor gave a tired smile before responding. “Maybe it did. Maybe I did not sleep for many days after that incident. Maybe I thought, ‘How can I be sure that this woman will be able to feed her child every day?Would her life be better or worse after the child? Maybe I pondered, ‘What if the child ends up the same as her Mother: broken and beaten?But then who was I to make her decision.Anyway, does that even matter? What mattered back then, was to make sure that the woman lived another day. Back then, maybe I stopped acting to make sure the woman has a good future.
“But time and again I ask myself, now that I have more time to waste: ‘Is that what doctors are supposed to do? save lifes, and don't give a damn about how that life is lived?’ and to this day, even after the retirement, the dilemma persists.” saying so, she turned to face me. “You, young lad. I ask you the very same question before I leave, and I am expecting you to find out the answer.” I leaned forward.






