Sitemap
Vasily Gatov

Vasily Gatov

USC Annenberg School of Communication and Journalism, CCLP fellow

Learn from peers

12 min readMay 26, 2013

--

I was following and covering the great tragedy of printed media as many fellow media and communications colleagues in ’00 did. It was a story of digital procrastination, mistakes in both business and creative ideas, undertakings and failures. Since the arrival of a relatively mature digital technology, traditional media - newspapers, primarily - had made all possible moves (seemingly) to catch up with it. But in most cases the management and the editors were fundamentally wrong in the understanding of the ongoing shift.

Today, looking at the developing story of on-line education, MOOC’s and the role played by major universities in this new Euripides scale drama, I can only smile while noticing similarities between the newspaper’ saga and educational one.

Thus the scene is different, the actors aren’t of the same theater school and the economic size and impact of the industry is different, should we look closer at the lesson that media learned (not finally for the industry as a whole but terminally for some of its institutions)?

Early warning - my observations of the online education debate and practice were initially a view of a stranger. Later, when I became more engaged by different Russian schools with teaching and mentoring students, I changed a viewpoint and became an avid proponent of the online education. Some time later my findings and analysis rooted me to a more balanced approach - and some insights from a media industry really helped this evolution to happen.

MEDIA 1991-2004 AND LATER

Since early 90’s, media companies were active on the net. The newspapers were experimenting with various forms of digital content as well as the content’ delivery. Early media websites were at large just a searchable plain text databases of some content produced for print editions, with minor number of the internet-only exclusives. When a wider adoption of WWW protocols and HTML had allowed bolder multimedia sites, the «convergence» issues came to the ground - news sites couldn’t continue to be a databases of dull texts. The technology was coming faster than media organizations could consume it - that gap was often used by an adventurous teams of non-journalists, non-editors to create some kind of web-only media. The rise of the search and an invention of RSS (really simple syndication protocol) opened a door for agency-like aggregation services. Google News, Newser and alike globally (Russian Yandex news, Korea’s Naver) were changing the media industry since - using RSS, search and unseen variety of sources as a core competitive advantage against traditional, editorial-based news outlets.

Since the early days of the internet media a core question was – is there a working business model for the Web? A regular controversy happened around a clash between a typical double conversion model (sell to the audience, than sell the audience to advertisers) and a miniscule capacity of paid-for media in the net. Not only Stewart Brand’s famous “Information wants to be free”[1] notion played a bad trick with news publishers, but also a failure record of their own attempts to charge the users for an online content. With a few fabled exemptions like WSJ and FT, paid content model wasn’t working for general news and features – just because there was always a free alternative, except some regional monopolies. By early 00’s most of news sites were free[2], offering the digitized versions of the paper editions with some special web content to everyone who cared to visit the www.somenewspaper.com. Publishers were chasing the digital managers with “monetization” failing into false hope for the revenue from advertising that should fall from the skies above.

Neither users nor advertisers fulfilled the promise – most of the newspaper’ web properties of the traditional media were, in fact, losing money (that were still earned from a outdated paper editions). Hence, papers weren’t the worst losers – weekly newsmagazines really broke all records of failure. As they were a “white collars of news industry” they couldn’t keep up without some gorgeous designs and exclusives that cost huge money and could never been cashed. Newsweek, Time Magazine and US News & World Report were spending millions on the websites with free content – while their print editions financials turning into red digits and losing audiences. Look at them now – just 10 years after seemingly best operational years – could this be imagined in 2003?

Since 2006 I serve on the Board of WAN-IFRA, a global association on the newspaper publishers and news technology providers. Annual World Newspaper Congress is a kind of a vanity fair for a successful publisher who is eager to advertise some new editorial tricks or ad sales technology, or structural reforms that address the “convergence challenge”. But The Congress is also a tribune of the industry troubles – as much as publishers agreed to recognize them. It was a controversial task to follow in parallel the “Future of News” debate in US[3] and listen to WAN-IFRA’s executives who were reporting something very different. Guess the topics?

· “Free dailies and weeklies are an awkward creatures of an evil brain that has nothing to do with a quality journalism and a real news publishing business” - that was in year 2000. That shifted to 2004'

“We tried free daily(weekly) and it seems to be a good dynamic idea” (the notion of quality journalism has gone; should be underlined that free daily projects were started because traditional paid-for were already showing signs of decline). The next shift was a 2008 crisis that shaved off many of paper startups and the debate on free papers went to

“Could be better, too expensive, low loyalty, give us the readers back[4]”. Currently, free dailies are facing the same threat of extinction in the developed world with some limited success in the developing countries. No doubt that a brief period of free dailies penetration had played a destructive role for traditional printed media - particularly in the big cities where free papers can sustain a distribution quiz. Readers who betrayed print subscriptions or kiosk purchase of the newspaper had never returned in masses to the old consumption model, choosing Internet or mobile as the primary source.

Quality journalism has been in the editor’s domain (WAN-IFRA has a sister association WEF - World Editor’s Forum[5] - that debates the professional agenda and cares about press freedom, speech freedom and journalism excellence) until 2007, when publishers realized that good and recognizable authors, investigative reporting and quality analysis could be a clear competitive advantage of the old model over the new - “free net” one. Since than, the editor’s gathering was bragging about “destructive Google News”, devaluation of writing and storytelling with an Internet and other issues that were exactly “Future of News” debate topics. Surprisingly, by 2009 US publishers barely were visiting World Newspaper Congresses - partly due to a tough economy of the American press, partly due to usefulness of the debate.

The threat of non-professionals who occupy the traditional printed media audience - came into agenda in 2007, with a wide acceptance of blogging. The Net eased the access to self-publishing, reporting, photo and video opportunities - and the distribution equality. No printing presses, paper supply chain, mail or truck delivery, no kiosks, just a display of a personal computer. The monopolies that grew for 4 centuries around Guttenberg’s invention started to loose a competitive advantage - with no alternative model in hand.

The destruction of the agenda - the most recent addition to the claims against the new news outlets. Although newspapers are now deep in the internet market, with multiple web sites and services, they (with some exceptions) still consider that place an enemy zone where treacherous adversaries are fighting them (actually, very few are able to overcome the perception that everyone has the right for a free speech not the registered entities only). That is so painful to recognize that a monopoly is no more.

It has to be said that many - if not all - of this issues were really threatening or damaging the newspaper industry. Still, even after crises of 2007-2013, the newspaper industry exists despite of everything. But what really worries everyone inside it - whether this is a “metered living” like a hospital-supported life of the patient with no chances to survive, or there’s a new life after death for a system? Does the society (as a whole) and the consumer of media (personally) needs it - and that’s only a matter of time when a new form of beneficial relationship will be reopened?

SIDE DISH: THE ROLE OF ADVERTISING

For news media, advertising is a century-long partner. At least since W.R. Hearst “double conversion model” became a standard for newspapers (and other broadcast media later), the ad business is the publisher’s best friend (and the worst enemy, same time). For a whole century (at least we have the data as far as 1919 for the US market) the cash inflows to a particular publication were the measure of success. Same is true about every market that operate under a minimally free economic conditions - “invisible hand” buys a space and eyeballs where they are really present; advertisers invest pragmatically and logically, because somehow the quality of placement is connected with a quality and quantity of sales.

There’s nothing wrong with advertising, there’s nothing bad about trading traffic to dollars. Free publications were common since 18th century (although systematic publication of PennySaver started in 1961[6], but there was some examples of earlier origin), and with the right scale and market they perform well.

There’s nothing tragic about technology missing promise as well as a customer weak loyalty. When digital distribution arrived, traditional legacy media just couldn’t get the basic idea – every next step in tech development will only make things more accessible. Never try to piss against the wind, as Russians say, You’ll feel miserable.

Legacy media couldn’t make a correct conclusion early enough to make a general shift in expectations. As You create a “free value”, general consumer will stick with “free” but not with the brand. News and commentary couldn’t be an unchangeable value – contrary, it’s an easy deceiver’ zone. Chris Anderson in FREE explains that more than clear – no paid-for offer sustains a free offer of seemingly similar value (even if it’s grossly worse in-depth). There’s no way paid-for can compete with free in the field of recurring consumption – as soon as the customer recognizes the annual cost of paid and minimal loss from free, as Anderson stated.

Generalizing the finding on legacy media failures with Internet, one can say – too late, too lazy, too free and too linear. If a researcher could assume the power that newspaper publishing has by 2000, the failure looks even more tragic – the industry in USA alone has lost a whole half of the income, according to Newspaper Association of America data in just 4 years of continuing decline. Worldwide this scaling is still happening, cutting the newsroom jobs, print capacity, workers time and people’s interest to what is considered “quality journalism”.

The most obvious conclusion from this story is taking us directly from the world of media to the world of another medium – education. When digital reality – with the changes across every domain, from consumer to advertiser, from carrier to concept – surrounded the newspaper world, the bravest and the biggest had risked their way out to the better future. See The New York Times and The Guardian crusades. But in “normal”, typological newspaper the management and the editors were making their mistakes:

- waiting too long to react;

Get Vasily Gatov’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

- underestimating the power of a future consumer and the impact of his/her perception change (much lesser loyalty to brands[7], high awareness of cheaper and free alternatives[8], fluctuating demand for quality[9], etc)

- matching the late reaction with the “Big Guys” strategies and practice;

- misplacing local monopoly to “strength” sections in their SWOT exercises;

- assuming the future will be based on the rules and people from the past.

Every mistake newsmen made 10-15 years ago one can now trace in the hot collision between universities and emerging online education.

EDUCATION SKETCH

Internet was born in the universities and research centers - regardless of ARPA’s commission it was conceived as an science’ tool of trade. There should be no doubt about a positive effect that it caused for science and learning - but it took a while to adapt, or, pragmatically speaking - scale the net’s capacity to the interest of the education.

Again, I could only rely on my impressions and sometimes general assumptions that could prove wrong is criticized by an education professional, but I couldn’t escape a seduction to reflect some of the media issues onto education system - because I firmly see and feel important similarities. The deeper and systematic view on those similarities can, I believe, provide an advisory to educators who jump into MOOC practices.

Is education a mass media (or medium)? Should this be a topic of discussion? In my view - the school and the university is a mass media since The Enlightenment Era, simply because it:

· uses exactly the same chain of instruments - content, packaging, distribution

· addresses an audience that could be clearly defined and quantified

· comes in unified form to masses, but could be targeted to serve smaller scale and specific groups (both within the major pipeline and as a separate product)

· uses a double conversion model that is native for mass media but not exactly as a franchise (schools are selling next level of education to those who can buy, for example)

· relies on “editorial” model of content creation and packaging: schools comprise “universal reporters early grades teachers who can actually cover every basic subject”, “special section editors - teachers with a subject specialization”, and other likes

· education is a part of the social contract as free press is (at least in democratic society)

Similar to mass media, the education system comes with nation-wide guarantees and specific legislation, but also could have huge regional and local differences in quality and accessibility. Although differently than a journalist, a teacher bears a specific “social tag” that separates him from other educated people because he is socially entitled to do something.

The development of the concept of online education came relatively late - about a decade later than the concept of digital mass media. There were earlier attempts to digitize learning - with library access, digital publications and research websites - but the prevailing concept of face-to-face education and book hegemony was putting a brake on the brains of educators. Arrival of YouTube and DSL speeds to the mass user assisted the early experimentators in the next move that was overcoming a «face-to-face» concept. Lynda.com and other professional education courses were closely followed with language services that offered some combination of digital pre-recorded courses with online tests and rosters. Digitalization of SAT, TOEFL, IELTS tests moved a frontier even further into educational domain - and prompted universities to the early experiments with online courses - first, text-based. Again, in the early days of online educations those experiments were generally on-campus, intranet-accessible only - due to the faculty perception of hand-over knowledge inheritance. But the rebels came - first as technologists who couldn’t wait for a school and a university to acknowledge the shift that already was in place started to deliver an quazi-educational content (ted.com), later accreting a more systematic form (udacity.com) and, finally, converting into super-schools and super-colleges - like khanacademy.org and soursera.org. This was so bold and so challenging that the leading universities couldn’t just continue looking at the change indifferently. MIT and Harvard came out with eDX, Stanford followed with their unique project, and other grands are coming - individually, collectively or via established leaders like Coursera or Udacity.

[1] “Information wants to be free” – a quotation from Stewart Brand’s Whole Earth Review (May 1985, p. 49). His legacy was persistently used by internet prodigies of 90’s to support a free model for news websites.

[2] “State of Media” report, 2007, Worldwide Association of Newspapers – “Among the reporting newspaper companies, only 1,2 percent charge users for a full newspaper website access, 7,6 percent charge for some parts of the websites (archives, business information)”

[3] Future of News debate – term that was coined by CJR during an active phase of newspaper crisis (2007-2009). FoN debate occurred between a “digital gang of four” (Clay Shirky, Jeff Jarvis, Emily Bell and John Paton) and a group of more traditional media scientists and practitioners, including Rupert Murdoch, CJR editor XXX, Technology Review editor Jason Pontin and some others. While digital side was reading a final goodbye to a printed media, the traditionalists were cursing “digital bloom and goof”.

[4] See http://www.newspaperinnovation.com/index.php/2013/05/03/free-newspapers-in-europe-new-data/ for a free daily circulation figures.

[5] WEF has survived it’s own crisis – in 2010 part of the editors broke with the Forum, creating their very own Global Editors Network (GEN). Although there were other reasons that provoked the split of editor’s community, major claims against WAN-IFRA and WEF were about the outdated approach to the internet development, false understanding of editorial issues in the digital era and lack of technological understanding. The Guardian, El Pais, Le Parisien and some other important media editors lead the split, leaving WEF mostly with the third world issues and personalities.

[6] http://www.wnyps.com/index.php?History - The East Aurora PennySaver was the first PennySaver opened up by RW Publications and was dated February 1, 1961.The first issue was only 24 half-tab pages and was mailed to 6,000 homes. There was a number of subscribtion-based «penny saver papers» during the years if The Great Depression (see - http://www.pennysaverusa.com/about_us/).

[7] Bigger/Lesser Loyalty Phenomenon of the Digital Generations – (should be in Marketing Research Review - add)

[8] Monday Note, by Frederic Filloux (find the research name)

[9] (Marketing Review)

--

--

Vasily Gatov
Vasily Gatov

Written by Vasily Gatov

USC Annenberg School of Communication and Journalism, CCLP fellow