Square Dancing: Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy
It is getting dark. Zhang Mei-Jin, 48 years old, is walking to the square of Foshan wonderland city housing estate. On the one hand, she is smiling. Because she made her scheme to let her dancing group get more and more members. It has already been the biggest group over this housing estate. On the other hand, she is worrying. Because she is afraid that if there is anyone will complain about them today. But she shook her head and forget everything. She knows where she is going is getting light.
It is big day for Mrs Zhang who is a housewife for over 20 years, because she heard there is a journalist will come, although she knows the journalist is only a student. “Come on everyone, pictures! pictures!” she shouts excitedly to every group member of her when I am trying to take pictures of them. It destroys all my imaginations to housewives: boring, indifference and dull, I suddenly swallow those negative words down. But maybe I am wrong. Zhang is not a housewife , she is a square dancer.
“This is my job,” Mrs Zhang points to her group and says, obviously she doesn’t want to admit she is a housewife. “I have done this for about 4 years, at the beginning I have only 4 or 6 members. Now you can see how many I have already got.” you can see how proud she is when she is talking about her group. Their formation is so tidy, Mrs Zhang and one of her partners, Mrs Zheng, lead in the front, others arrange in a rectangle. 10 times 7, around 70 people there. Almost all of them are above 40 years old and housewives or retired women. There are but a few males. It is really a big group, it looks.
The reason why people go to do square dancing is varied, but most of them just want to do some exercise and keep fit. One of the most funny answers is from an African boy. “My mother focus me to dance here,” the boy, whose Chinese name is as same as a Hong kong movie star — Liu De-hua, says. “My mother said if I want to be a Chinese, to dance well at first.” It made me laugh out loud and fell awkward. I never do square but I am a Chinese. There is another function of square dancing — arrange a blind date for their marriageable children. A senior woman’s words, “this young man is coming for blind date”, made me quickly explain, “No, I am coming for a interview”.
It hasn’t been a cakewalk, though for Mrs Zhang. She learnt how to dance on the internet, she never got any training before. She invited a professional dancing teacher to teach their group. Zhang have already faced many tough competitors and troubles. But she won.
“This is the best group here, I can guarantee that,” One of key group members, Deng Yang-hua, who is a 47-year-old housewife says. “The dances of other groups are old-fashion and outdated. Those are for old people. Our dance is moderately difficult and really effective to keep fit.” As what Deng says, to be a good square dancing group needs accurate locating but also low price. “Initially, we collect 5 yuan per person per month for lighting and sound fee,” Deng says. But now it is free. There are 4 key group members afford all fees. They also think it can reassure people that they are not making profit.
Although those strategies work well, but it is not enough. There was a deep scheme. “I was appointed to another group before.” Deng suddenly lowers her voice. “At that time, we are just a small group, around 20 members. Mrs Zhang let me to join an another dancing group. Absolutely as a spy. Then after I got along well with people in that group. I persuaded them to come to Zhang’s group.” In this scheme, Deng poached 11 people, that’s why she became one of the key members.
Since then, the quarrels between each square dancing groups in wonderland city housing estate has never stopped. Other groups has tried to grab people back and condemned Zhang’s group openly. But the quarrels are not only to Zhang’s group. I have even heard that group A appointed leader’s husband to group B for poaching group numbers and stealing secrets such as where they invited their dancing teacher. I can not confirm if it is true. But that kinds of spy things are really normal between them. Also there is a group that they are seemingly in peace. “There are alway 18 members in my group,” Feng Tian-mei, one of leaders of a group, says. “Our dance is much harder. It needs dance basic. So it is not that easy for every.” But they are just a the tip of the iceberg. The issue of spying and quarreling are going on. I think even you are a politician and know well about the situation in Ukraine, you can totally understand what’s going on here.
Get Will Shum’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The wonderland city horsing estate is just a small case. This spy phenomenon on square dancing is all over China. According to folk statistic, there are 200 million people are doing square dancing at the same time in China. If you go through Weibo, you can read many articles about all kinds of ridiculous spy war on leadership and development of square dancing. For instance, there is an article describe how a senior woman turned over a leader of a square dancing group by using her husband’s seduction. But it is reasonable for me. one day, have-nothing-to-do-all-day people find out their career. It is a great opportunity for them to let themselves be on stages. So think why they put that much enthusiasm, energy, time and scheme on square dancing.
But if you just look through the fighting between each square dancing groups, then think they are not united. You are totally wrong. It is just like in the time of the war of resistance against Japan, you can see kuomintang-communist co-operation. When “enemies” come to a dancing group, all groups will get together and fight “enemies”. That’s what Zhang Mei-Jin is worrying all days. Square dancing has been complained a lot since it has been around. The biggest problem of it is noisy. They all use a huge stereo set and turn the volume high to make sure everyone can listen to the music when they are dancing. “Music is so important for us,” a square dancing women, Liang Qin-yi, 52 years old says. “We need the rhythm to keep the tempo of dancing. I can not dance without music.”
There is a small dancing group in Zhujiang new town of Guangzhou which is just next to a bar called Bangkok bar. The boss of the bar think the square dancing made this city cooler. “Although I will never dance with them,” the boss, Andrew W, who is from Thailand says. “I think they are so cool, I like them, they are decorating this city in some ways.” But he is a small number of people who are not involved the dancing but like it. But most of people especially for whom are living next to square dancing have a strong complain against it.
Because the essential music really disturbs people’s daily life. When I was in the scene of square dancing, the volume of the music is too high to interview. So I must shout. The whole square at that time really became a pop bar for seniors. “Do you think the music is too loud here?” I shout to Zhang. “I have already turn down the volume,” She answers. It is something like people shout very loudly in a pop bar — “Down it! Down it!”.
People who live near the square of wonderland city housing estate have already reached the limit of their patiences. “I can not stand it any more,” Li Ze-Zhan complains who lives in wonderland city housing estate and near the square. “It is really a nightmare for me, the music they play is really loud and vulgar. Sometime I just stay in my office until 10 o’clock when they finish the stupid dancing.” The problem is not only too noisy but also that they occupy the whole square and block some main roads. Егор who is a Russian can not speak Chinese and her English is not very good. Even although she can not stop to complain. “I used to hang out with my friend at that square,” she says strenuously. “But now it is occupied by them. Rubbish! Rubbish! Rubbish!”
Square dancing do bother foreigners, but no only foreigners in China. The square dancing have already crossed the Pacific. August 2013, a group of Chinese senior women dance on the Sunset Park, Brooklyn, New York. They were complained to the police strongly and one of their leaders was arrested. It is not not only case. The square of the Louvre Museum have already been “captured” by Chinese dancing women. “I can see the square dancing every day,” Xu Yue-Chen who is a Chinese study in Eastvale of Los Angeles says. “But it is not a very big group, I think there are around 20 people, all are women. They also play music, I think it is not that loud like it is in China.”
It is like the case people was arrested in New York. There are also measures carried out by government to solve the disturbing problem of square dancing in China. But they do not work well. So the only way for residents who are disturbed is to “fight”. “We have tried to stop them,” Li Ze-Zhan says. “We gathered about 30 people to let them stop dancing or just turn down the volume. But they are too many people. We are almost surrounded by them. They are just like the walkers in the TV series the Walking Dead.” At this time, all dancing groups would get together and kick anti-dancing people out.
“Sometime they (square dancers) are unreasonable,” A security, Zhang Jian-Chen, of wonderland city housing estate says. “We have revived many complains about the dancing. Most of them are about the volume of music and others are about blocking the main road.” The securities have tried many ways but they only get largely unsuccessful. “We have used banners,” Zhang adds. “Banners read ‘doing exercise is important, but people’s right to live in a quiet place is much more important’. I think they just ignored them.” But if we walk a mile in his shoes, I think it is still unreasonable to just stop them dancing. In the view of the spokesman of Vanke company which owns wonderland city housing estate, She wants to work out a way to balance. “It is a recent problem for every housing estate,” Xiao Li says. “Firstly we will try our best to ensure that people live in our housing estates will not disturbed. Then we should come up some ideas to let all people can do exercise every day they want.” She expressed they are having the meeting to discuss how to deal with it. The government of Nanning city announce that after warning the square dancing groups by police, if they still disturb residents. They will be fined 200 to 500 RMB. The government have already found a group to administer tweeters over the city.
On the one hand square dancing is so suitable for both retired citizens and housewives to take exercise. Sometime it becomes the whole career for people. One the other hand it is disturbing people. Its draw people crazy. It’s hard to identify who is who is wrong. I just know it is getting increasingly complex.








