Sitemap
Press enter or click to view image in full size

4 Common Ways People Will Manipulate You In An Argument or Debate

3 min readSep 4, 2014

--

The comments section of any website will open you up to a world of strawman, faulty thinking and downright manipulation. It isn’t just in the online world that this happens, we all know at least one person who does this near enough all the time when you’re unfortunate enough to express an opinion within earshot.

Here are 5 ways that people will manipulate you and your argument. Knowledge of these techniques is key to protecting yourself from their deception.

1. The Longtail Extension

Scenario: Peter believes that the actions of the Israeli state in Gaza had gone too far, he told John that Israel must stop killing Palestinians.

John responds as such: So you think Israel has no right to defend itself? That it should be happy being attacked and the victim of another genocide on the Jewish people? How could you be against Israel’s actions when you would do the same thing?

Simply put, in this scenario John does not feel there is a strong enough argument against the idea of a state continuing to kill innocent civilians. However at the same time he does not want to look at this point of view as it would be more convenient to perceive the situation as being a mere case of defence. Therefore what John does here is that he extends Peter’s statement to the point where it is easily refutable.

Nobody could disagree that killing civilians in Gaza is wrong, but they could if the person followed up by saying ‘and therefore Israel should let everybody attack it and be the victim of another genocide’. Which John didn’t do, but Peter manipulated John’s original argument to extend it to the point of refutability.

2. Ad Hominem, play the player

Scenario: David tells Jane that trying to ban adult magazines achieves nothing for feminism and that there are more pressing issues that women face such as unequal pay.

Get Yasin Aydin’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Jane responds by telling David that his opinion is worthless because he is a man, his input is typical of men and that he has no idea what it feels like to be a woman. Jane reminds David that he can hardly talk about inequal pay because he works for a company which was recently taken to court for paying women less.

Ad Hominem attacks are very common in any arguments, debates or discussions. To attack the player and not the ball for these people is often more convenient than tackling the issue at hand. In this scenario Jane does not challenge David’s opinions but rather challenges David’s character. Putting his character in doubt therefore will put his opinion in doubt. Job done, why would anyone listen to somebody who is unreliable?

3. One Instance To Contrare Them All

Scenario: Ahmet has told his son that when driving he should never drive over the legal limit, especially in 30mph zones. Ahmet explains that at 30mph 80% of victims survive, whilst at 40mph 80% of victims die.

Ahmet’s son responds by reminding his dad that just the other week a 6 year old girl was hit and died after a car travelling 26mph collided with her. It doesn’t matter how slow you’re going if you’re going to hit someone as going slower won’t save their life.

This method of manipulation is simple enough but is used so often. Ahmet has made an argument for respecting 30mph zones and used saving lives as a cornerstone of his argument. His son, with other ideas, has decided to use one instance to to the contrary in order to nullify his dad’s entire premise. A manipulative technique used by many.

4. Absence As Evidence

Scenario: George is discussing Islam with his neighbour Fred. George finds it incredulous that Fred believes the 9/11 attrocity is one which Muslims do not condone. George responds by asking him if Fred has ever seen a Muslim on TV condeming the 9/11 attacks. Fred can’t.

Absence of evidence is a cruel way of manipulating an argument. It often encompasses several manipulative techniques such as distraction, premise assumption and more. If it the sun is shining outside and you haven’t seen it reported on the news that it is snowing in another country this does not mean the absence of evidence is evidence that the absence is therefore a fact.

--

--