Have College Sports Lost Their Way?
This article was first posted 28 November 2012 at ParlorCityFootball.
Introducing the Conversation
Grand Canyon University has recently announced that they were accepting an invitation into the WAC (Western Athletic Conference) of the NCAA’s Division I. Paul Fain published an article on the Inside Higher Ed website raising some thoughtful questions in reference to Grand Canyon’s for profit status and how that could affect fundraising, and by inference NCAA compliance. This case is particularly significant because Grand Canyon is the first for profit institution to join Division I. This means that ‘donors’ are really ‘sponsors’ and that GCU’s athletic programs are not ‘extracurricular activity’ but sports ‘business’. Which begs the question: should athletes at GCU on athletic scholarship be considered ‘amateur’ or ‘professional’?
Before I take this discussion too far, I must say that it is entirely possible that this conversation as specifically involving GCU could prove to be a moot point. They may offer scholarships through a non profit or foundation associated with advancing the mission of the college. But as I will argue below, this isn’t just about GCU. It is about calling the NCAA what it really is – a Sports Franchise.
Get Zach Smith’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The NCAA Franchise
‘Franchising’ as a business practice is generally defined as the right or license granted by a company or individual to another company or individual to market an existing product or service. Within this context, the NCAA is the ‘franchise’ and its sanctioned athletic events are the ‘product’. The participating colleges and universities are both the franchisers and the franchisees, much the same as the teams in the NFL. Skipping the history of the NCAA, we will say that current NCAA members are the franchisers and when a new member is added that member is the franchisee. After the franchise has been awarded, the franchisee then becomes a part owner of the franchise or in this case, a voting member of the NCAA. Similarly, just as the structure of the NCAA mimics a franchise enterprise, so does the ‘economy’ or the exchange of goods and services between the university franchisees and the individual consumer. The universities sell tickets to sporting events, the rights to TV broadcasts, and market fan apparel. Successful teams often secure large financial prizes for their parent institutions. And all of this is accepted blindly because these institutions are legally chartered as not for profit – which really only means that in exchange for tax breaks there aren’t any shareholders reaping profits off of the athletic feats of young athletes.
College sports are big business. The athletes performances are the product being sold by the members of the NCAA to the consuming masses. In function, these athletes are professionals whose performances are bought, sold, watched, evaluated, and consumed. The fact of the matter is that whether or not an athlete is or isn’t compensated (via scholarship or otherwise) for these performances is irrelevant. The point is that a university can sell a product or service that is not strictly in line with the academic nature and mission of Higher Education (nullifying the appropriateness of tax exempt status) AND profit off of it, while demanding that amateurism remain crucial to the academic development of the student athlete is a whole lot of crap.
The truth is that the NCAA is a cartel of higher ed institutions operating a very profitable sports franchise.
I find it fascinating that the NCAA so adamantly insists on a standard of amateurism in spite of the obvious business of college sports. But I find it even more disturbing that institutions that are dedicated to the academic pursuit of knowledge and truth (to say nothing of justice!) can so willingly ignore these issues in favor of financial boon.






