[Frame for Work] A List of Meta-frameworks
The Self-Life-Mind Schema and Other Creative Heuristics
Last month, I created a Thematic Card called Meta-framework and published it through Possible Press.
This card provides a unique and fresh perspective on the concept of “Meta-frameworks” and comes with a 27-page Thematic Brief that shares the story behind the theme.
The Thematic Brief includes the following sections:
1. Are You a Theoretical Thinker?
2. The “Ontology — Realism — Hermeneutics” Schema
3. The “Self — Life — Mind” Schema
4. The “Variant > Quasi-invariant > Invariant > Invariant Set” Schema
5. Why Do Theoretical Thinkers Love Meta-frameworks?
If you want to support my exploration of the theme “Meta-frameworks” help me take the next step toward creating a Possible Book! You can purchase the Thematic Card directly from Possible Press:
Today, I am making a list of my favorite meta-frameworks.
Over the past several years, I have worked on connecting THEORY with PRACTICE, developing a set of knowledge frameworks. Eventually, I began using some of these knowledge frameworks to curate other knowledge frameworks — these I now call meta-frameworks.
What’s the difference between meta-frameworks and regular knowledge frameworks?
Both serve as cognitive tools for knowledge creation and curation. However, they differ in what they structure. When meta-frameworks are used for knowledge creation, they generate regular knowledge frameworks, which, in turn, produce insights. When meta-frameworks are used for knowledge curation, they curate a collection of regular knowledge frameworks, which are then used to curate data.
Meta-frameworks for Knowledge Creation
A meta-framework can generate regular knowledge frameworks — for instance, an abstract model can be used to create a concrete model.
In February 2023, I applied the Project Engagement Approach to the field of Business Development, leading to the creation of the Business as Engagement framework.
Below is the basic model of the Project Engagement approach:
This approach led to the identification of three types of projects within business development.
- Project 1: Focuses on discovering new ideas for business development.
- Project 2: Involves the daily work activities within the Business Value Chain.
- Project 3: Aims to transform the ideas behind a business into concepts that contribute to cultural and societal development.
Building on this foundation, I applied Project Engagement Approach (v2.1) to create an expanded version of the Business as Engagement framework.
More details can be found in A Possible Theme called “Business as Engagement.”
Meta-frameworks for Knowledge Curation
In my past practice, I have used meta-frameworks for knowledge curation, aiming to turn Pieces into a meaningful Whole.
- Pieces: Several knowledge frameworks
- Whole: A newly curated knowledge framework
- Container: A meta-framework
In my 2019 book draft, Curativity: The Ecological Approach to General Curation Practice, I introduced a new term, “Curativity,” which refers to “curating pieces into a meaningful whole,” defining a general social activity and a universal experience.
To avoid unnecessary debate over the concept of curation or curatorial practice, which traditionally refers to “professional curation in the context of art and museums,” I coined the term Curativity to support my argument for an interdisciplinary view of curation. Thus, Curativity is an ontological-level invention. It points to a new space for knowing and understanding.
The diagram below shows the basic elements of Curativity: Pieces — Container — Whole. The basic assumption behind the diagram and the new term is: “In order to effectively curate pieces into a meaningful whole, we need containers to contain pieces and shape them.”
At an epistemological level, Curativity differs from mereology in philosophy and mathematical logic. While both address the relationship between parts and whole, Curativity is more concerned with action, experience, and value, whereas mereology focuses more on abstract reasoning about parts and whole.
Between March 2019 and December 2024, the applications of Curativity Theory have evolved into three main directions:
- Knowledge Curation
- Action Curation
- Mental Curation
These directions align with the three types of containers identified in the 2019 book. Specifically:
- Knowledge Curation and Mental Curation are primarily related to Cognitive Containers.
- Knowledge Curation also intersects with Physical Containers.
- Action Curation is associated with Social Containers.
The Three Types of Containers:
- Physical Containers: Shipping containers, bowls, rooms, places …
- Social Containers: Families, communities, schools, groups, events…
- Cognitive Containers: Frameworks, concepts, diagrams, models, theories…
Moreover, there are three dimensions to understanding the concept of a container. For instance, a book can serve as both a physical and a cognitive container.
A Story of Using Meta-frameworks
I often apply the “Double Containers” principle in knowledge curation projects — one container is “Hard,” and the other one is “Soft.”
For knowledge curation projects using meta-frameworks, the structure can be set up as follows:
- Pieces: Several knowledge frameworks
- Whole: A newly curated knowledge framework
- Container 1: A meta-framework
- Container 2: A Possible Book (or another medium)
In this example, Possible Book serves as Container 2, but other formats can also be used, such as a series of Articles, a Conceptual Deck, a set of Thematic Cards, a Knowledge Map, a Workshop, a Course, etc.
Let’s see an example. In 2022, I developed multiple frameworks for creative life development from different theoretical perspectives. By November 2022, I initiated a knowledge curation project to bring these frameworks together into a cohesive structure.
I began with the following diagram:
The diagram above highlights three theoretical approaches:
- Activity Theory
- Curativity Theory
- The Project Engagement Approach
It also presents the following four frameworks:
- The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) framework
- The Life—History Complex
- The Creative Life Curation framework
- The Path of Creative Life
My primary interest lies at the intersection of Knowledge, Creativity, and Adult Development, which I broadly refer to as Creative Life.
Though there are many important aspects of creative life, I selected the transformation between Individual Actions and Collective Culture as the focus of the Creative Life project.
Initially, in 2021, I only considered Activity as the mediation of this transformation. However, I later realized that this was just one possible path. By incorporating additional theoretical perspectives, we can find more paths to the creative life.
- Path 1 — Activity Theory
- Path 2 — Curativity Theory
- Path 3 — Project Engagement
These three paths can be understood as three social theories. How did I curate them together?
I used Ping-keung Lui’s theoretical sociology as a meta-framework to curate these approaches into a meaningful framework.
Lui’s theoretical sociology is structured as a nested framework. See the diagram below. According to Lui, “The realism comprises a subjectivist structuralism and an objectivist stock of knowledge, while the hermeneutics is an interpretation and an analysis. Second, I shall present an ontology that nests the realism within its boundaries.” (p.250, 2016, Aspects of Sociological Explanation)
Lui’s grand theory can be understood as a dialogue between philosophy and sociology. While ontology and hermeneutics are well-established philosophical terms, realism — positioned between them — is not traditionally philosophical. Lui emphasizes that Realism is the sociological matter proper (p.251, 2016, Aspects of Sociological Explanation).
I applied Lui’s nested structure to connect my four frameworks, revealing their placement within different layers:
- Ontology: The Path of Creative Life and The Life — History Complex
- Realism: The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) Framework
- Hermeneutics: The Creative Life Curation Framework
Lui’s approach also introduces a new tool called the Semiotic System Diagram, which represents a network of interconnected concepts. He applied this method not only to map the semiotic system of theoretical sociology but also to analyze and compare other sociological theories. By comparing different semiotic system diagrams with that of theoretical sociology, Lui can use his theoretical sociology to support and contain various empirical sociological theories.
Following Lui’s method, I created a semiotic system diagram to explore the Creative Life Strategy. Since the previous diagram illustrates the basic structure of the map, I collected key concepts from my four frameworks and integrated them into a cohesive system.
The result is the following semiotic system diagram.
The semiotic system diagram uses three colors to distinguish different parts of the framework:
- Blue > Ontology: The Path of Creative Life and the Life—History Complex
- Green > Realism: The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) Framework
- Red > Hermeneutics: The Creative Life Curation Framework
Each section highlights key concepts derived from the original frameworks. While the overall diagram is intricate, it remains structured rather than chaotic.
The first part — Ontology — encompasses The Path of Creative Life and The Life-History Complex. See the diagram below.
In my semiotic system diagram, I use “Container = The Fleeting Moment” to represent The Path of Creative Life.
The core of the Realism section in this diagram is the Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) Framework. See the diagram below.
The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) Framework is built around a primary conceptual pair: First-order Activity and Second-order Activity.
Additionally, the AAS framework emphasizes several key dynamic movements, including Unfolding, Discovering, Producing, Modeling, Storytelling, and Evaluating.
The third part of my semiotic system diagram is the Creative Life Curation Framework. See the diagram below.
In this section, the concepts come from Curativity Theory.
For more details, refer to Three Paths of Creative Life and A Semiotic System Diagram.
Finally, the semiotic system diagram was used to edit a book draft titled Advanced Life Strategy: Anticipatory Activity System and Life Achievements in December 2022. A more recent draft, Strategy as Curation, expanded it to the Advanced Life Strategy Toolkit (v2, 2024).
In this story, Lui’s “Ontology — Realism — Hermeneutics” schema was used as a Meta-framework.
The new meaningful whole created is a theoretical framework for Creative Life Strategy, while the new containers were the semiotic system diagram and two possible books.
A List of My Favorite Meta-frameworks
Over the past few weeks, I created several knowledge maps to represent the landscapes of some knowledge enterprises. For each map, I featured several knowledge frameworks that belong to that enterprise.
This week, I realized that many of these featured frameworks have been used as meta-frameworks in my past knowledge projects. It seems valuable to compile them here as a reference for readers.
Get Oliver Ding’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
These meta-frameworks are selected from the following knowledge maps:
- World of Activity (v1, 2024)
- GO Theory: The Genidentity-opportunity Approach (v2, Dec 2024)
- The Advanced Life Strategy Toolkit (v2, Dec 2024)
- The Landscape of Thematic Space Theory
- The Landscape of Curativity Theory (January 1, 2025)
- The Landscape of Concept Dynamics Theory (v1, January 3, 2025)
- The Journey of Strategic Life Theory (V1, 2025) and its Landscape
Let’s explore the list in the following sections.
World of Activity (v1, 2024)
The diagram below illustrates a curated overview of my creations related to Activity-focused frameworks.
Featured models:
- The “Activity as Project Engagement” Model
- The Activity Circle Model
- The SET Framework
- The Developmental Project Model
- The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) Framework
More details can be found in World of Activity (v1, 2024).
GO Theory: The Genidentity-opportunity Approach (v2, Dec 2024)
GO Theory (the Genidentity-opportunity Approach) was launched on Nov 16, 2024.
GO Theory has evolved from my earlier works, including the Ecological Practice Approach (2018–2024), the Project Engagement Approach (2021, 2022), the Creative Life Theory (2022, 2023), and the Strategic Life Development Framework (2024). It results from a creative dialogue between the Ecological Practice Approach and Creative Life Theory.
Featured model:
- The Realism of GO Theory
- The Ecological Approach to Development
- Life Coordinate
- Mental Moves and Social Moves
- The Path of Creative Life
More details can be found in GO Theory: The Genidentity-opportunity Approach (v2, Dec 2024)
The Advanced Life Strategy Toolkit (v2, Dec 2024)
The “Advanced Life Strategy” theme was developed in 2022 while I worked on applying the Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) framework to adult development.
From 2022 to 2024, I developed several related concepts within the AAS framework while also exploring ideas about “Life,” such as Creative Life, Strategic Life, and related themes.
Featured models:
- The Life(Self) Model
- The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) framework
- The Meaning Discovery Model
- The Mental Tuning Framework
- The Strategic Curation Framework
- The Curativity of Mind Model
More details can be found in The Advanced Life Strategy Toolkit (v2, Dec 2024)
The Landscape of Thematic Space Theory
A Thematic Space refers to a cognitive space where a person’s ideas, activities, and practices revolve around one particular theme. A theme can be an established theory such as “Activity Theory,” a general concept such as “Platform” or “Life,” or an idea somewhere in between, such as “Design Thinking” or “UX.”
Initially, the concept was created as a theme to guide the development of a canvas for discussing the development of tacit knowledge in January 2022.
From 2023 onward, it evolved into a theoretical concept.
Now, I am taking it one step further, developing it as an independent theory, separate from Curativity Theory.
Featured models:
- The Life — History — Multiverse Model
- The Thematic Space Canvas
- The Mental Moves Model
- The “Thematic Areas and Thematic Zones” Model
- The Thematic Curation Model
More details can be found in The Landscape of Thematic Space Theory.
The Landscape of Curativity Theory (January 1, 2025)
On January 1, 2025, I made a knowledge map to represent the landscape of Curativity Theory.
Featured models:
- The Basic Model of Curativity Theory
- The Themes of Practice Framework
- The Model of Knowledge Curation
- The Curativity of Action Model
- The Curativity of Mind Model
More details can be found in The Landscape of Curativity Theory (January 1, 2025)
The Landscape of Concept Dynamics Theory (v1, January 3, 2025)
On December 19, 2024, I published The Concept Development Framework (v1, 2024) to summarize my creative exploration of Concept Building, Creating New Concepts, and Concept Development over the past several years.
On January 3, 2025, I made a new Knowledge Map for the framework with a new name: Concept Dynamics Theory.
Featured models:
- The Theme (Concept) Model (2022)
- The Concept Dynamics Framework (2020)
- The “Themes of Practice: Concept, Activity, and Cognition” Model (2023)
- The “Activity as Formation of Concept” Model (2020)
- The “Building A Knowledge Enterprise” Model (2022)
More details can be found in The Landscape of Concept Dynamics Theory (v1, January 3, 2025).
The Landscape of Strategic Life Theory (V1, 2025)
Last week I edited two possible books on strategic life development:
- January 29: Strategic Life Narrative
- January 31: Knowledge Strategy
These books are part of a larger knowledge enterprise focused on adult life development, strategic life development, and advanced life strategy. I recently began referring to this body of work as Strategic Life Theory.
- The Past — Present — Future Schema
- The Potential — Actual Schema
- The Curativity of Mind Model
- The Mental — Social — Material Schema
- The Mental Moves — Social Moves Schema
More details can be found in The Journey of Strategic Life Theory (V1, 2025) and its Landscape.
An All-in-one List
Some knowledge frameworks appear in multiple knowledge maps. Additionally, I’ve noticed that thematic maps of the above knowledge maps can also serve as meta-frameworks.
Group A: Self and Life
- A1 — The Potential — Actual Schema (The Ecological Approach to Development)
- A2 — The Life Coordinate Framework
- A3 — The Past — Present — Future Schema (The Path of Creative Life)
- A4 — The Creative Course Framework (The Realism of GO Theory)
- A5 — The Life(Self) Model
Group B: Activity
- B1 — The “Activity as Project Engagement” Model
- B2 — The Activity Circle Model
- B3 — The Developmental Project Model
- B4 — The SET Framework
- B5 — The Anticipatory Activity System (AAS) Framework
- B6 — The Mental Tuning Framework
- B7 — The “Themes of Practice: Concept, Activity, and Cognition” Model (2023)
Group C: Curativity
- C1 — The Basic Model of Curativity Theory
- C2 — The Curativity of Mind Model
- C3 — The Meaning Discovery Model
- C4 — The Concept Dynamics Framework (2020)
- C5 — The Thematic Space Canvas
- C6 — The Mental — Social — Material Schema
- C7 — The Model of Knowledge Curation
- C8 — The Strategic Curation Framework
- C9 — The Curativity of Action Model
Group D: Themes and Concepts
- D1 — The Theme (Concept) Model (2022)
- D2 — The Thematic Curation Model
- D3 — The “Thematic Areas and Thematic Zones” Model
- D4 — The Mental Moves Model
- D5 — The “Mental Moves — Social Moves” Schema
- D6 — The “Building A Knowledge Enterprise” Model (2022)
- D7 — The “Activity as Formation of Concept” Model (2020)
- D8 — The Themes of Practice Framework
- D9 — The Life — History — Multiverse Model
Group E: Thematic Maps
- E1 — The House of Project Engagement
- E2 — The House of Creative Life Curation
- E3 — The House of Creative Life Strategy
- E4 — The House of Slow Cognition
- E5 — The House of Creative Enterprise
- E6 — The House of Knowledge Discovery
Moreover, some meta-frameworks are not included in the above knowledge maps. I’d like to recommend the following two models.
Group F: Thematic Schema
- F1 — The “Self-Life-Mind” Schema
- F2 — The “Variant > Quasi-invariant > Invariant > Invariant Set” Schema
The “Self-Life-Mind” Schema is inspired by the “Ontology — Realism — Hermeneutics” Schema.
The “Variant > Quasi-invariant > Invariant > Invariant Set” Schema is part of the “Ecological Formism” model.
Wow! A Total of 38 Meta-frameworks!
This article explored my favorite 38 meta-frameworks for knowledge creation and curation. These frameworks help structure insights, connect disciplines, and shape meaningful wholes. Moving forward, I will continue refining and expanding these tools to deepen knowledge engagement.



![[Frame for Work] A Multi-layered Thematic Map and Project Engagement](https://miro.medium.com/v2/resize:fit:1358/format:webp/1*MnhxhEa4XZtOSQTLbqK16A.jpeg)



![[Activity Analysis Network] #22 — Closure and Unfolding: A Thematic Trip and the AAI (2026) Journey](https://miro.medium.com/v2/resize:fit:1358/format:webp/1*2pflQsd3ITBDa-YJslWfDg.jpeg)



