We need new ways of learning: Participatory action research can pave the way
The Future-is-Now Challenge
As a result of the triple crises of a pandemic, economic upheaval, and prevalent structural racism, many learning organizations are struggling to fundamentally re-examine their programs, paradigms and pedagogies. Practitioners (program leaders, mentors, teachers, counselors, etc.) are questioning how to better integrate active anti-racism principles into learning design. They are experimenting with new technologies for student-centered virtual instruction. And they are investigating how to respond to the trauma and mental health vulnerabilities young people are experiencing, reacting in real-time, often without adequate resources and supports.
In this current context of systemic upheaval, how can youth-serving organizations take measure of what has worked in their histories and channel that self-knowledge into future imaginations? What is the best process to fuel change?
In Challenging Times, Participatory Action Research and Design Shows a Path Forward
In our work at Convergence Design Lab, we consistently observe how learning organizations that engage both their instructors and their youth as collaborators in the participatory research and design change process, not only walk the walk as equity-first organizations, but generate the most highly innovative, impactful and enduring solutions.
In an evolving education ecosystem, participatory action research and design is needed now more than ever. But what might participatory engagement look like in today’s climate?
Participatory Processes Produce Results
To envision a future, we look to an historical account. One of Convergence Design Lab’s first forays into participatory action research and design occurred in 2014 when we joined forces with the New Practice Team at Archeworks to redesign learning environments in two struggling Chicago public schools. Our Digital Atelier Toolkit documents the process.
We engaged students, teachers and staff in a participatory design process to explore the design question:
How might we design a replicable model for a safe, creative and learner-centered environment that shifts the traditional concepts of “schooling”?
The results shared here tell a story of transformative change.
Since that time, we continue to build on this powerful process with several learning organizations. Below, we unpack some of our learnings collected over this time with the aim to share what change-driven work looks like in action. We hope you find a few of these insights applicable to your own practice:
KEY INSIGHTS
Those CLOSEST to the work engage and invest in the change process with clarity and introspection
The most insightful impact stories are often sourced from UNCONVENTIONAL DATA.
A commitment to CHANGE drives a design process through COLLECTIVE IMAGINATION.
Insight One: Those closest to the work engage and invest in the change process with clarity and introspection
Even as external researchers, Convergence Design Lab starts its process by engaging youth and practitioners as co-investigators in discovery. As direct participants, we trust that these are the folks closest to the work. In our experience, the ones with the greatest “situational knowledge” generate key insights and ideas based on what they see, think and experience each day. The capacity to re-design with a robust sense of possibility, however, requires a dual mindset, one comprised of both empathy and optimism. When participants coalesce together around these shared mindsets, together, they get to the work, understanding that the process is part of a cycle — a spiral staircase of understanding, of looking at the data they’ve collected, of asking questions of that data, and of collecting more data to answer deeper questions.
Recently, we worked with the Youth Digital Media Activism community of practice organized by Chicago Learning Exchange. We asked the practitioners from these informal youth media organizations to identify evidence of “youth voice” and present this to the entire CLX network made up of over 200 learning organizations in Chicago. The multitude of ways that mentors in these programs located and advocated for youth voice through exemplars inspired all those who witnessed.
This slide below drawn from the virtual presentation of Community TV Network’s project to CLX organizes quotes scraped from both formal surveys and observed comments during workshops and Zoom calls.
Insight Two: The most insightful impact stories are often sourced from unconventional data.
Digital documentation and experiential anecdotes reveal a great deal about the ways practitioners build relationships with youth, how technology is integrated into workflows, how youth collaborate and co-create, how tensions are resolved, etc. Youth and practitioners can capture these moments in a variety of media forms (eg: drawn pictures, overhead conversations, audio recordings, photo/video, etc.)
Get Mindy Faber’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
In our work with our client/partner Spy Hop, a youth media organization in Salt Lake City, as well as the Youth Digital Media and Activism community of practice through CLX, we urge practitioners to think outside the box when it comes to collecting data that can provide evidence of impact.
- Anecdotal stories from youth and mentors
- Youth produced media artifacts including process pieces
- Documented conversations (between peers, mentors, audiences, etc.) including informal exchanges on social media or offline
- Timelines and storyboards of key learning experiences
- Infographics of the ephemera of learning experience (sights, smells, sounds, touches, etc)
- Repeated phrases, mottos, taglines, inside jokes, nicknames
We love some of these inspiring examples of how we turn unconventional data into impact stories. We used these in the bi-annual evaluation report produced for Spy Hop.
THIS IS DATA? DIGITAL AND EMBODIED EXPERIENCE
Some of the most illuminating data springs from sensory data such as gestures, expressions, movements, sounds, utterances, and captured in the moment acts of doing and working by youth and practitioners. Dr. Sarah Pink refers to this as the ephemera of embodied experience, sensory evidence often captured using media as “digital ethnography”. The insights that flow from analyses of fleeting and spontaneous instances often convey a rich story. Such revealing moments of impactful learning can elude the external researcher and are BEST experienced directly by participating youth and their practitioners in the observable moment which is why participatory action research advances collective knowledge around what works.
In the example below from Spy Hop’s Voices of the West program, Spy Hop mentor Gabby Huggins standing behind her student explaining how a wide angle lens on the camera can capture openness in the landscape of her rural community. This digital ethnography informed an impact story in a video white paper you can view on Vimeo here.
.. youth had cameras in their hands, responding to a prompt to make a film about something meaningful to them within moments of being introduced to the progam — Excerpt from “This place doesn’t feel the same”: A Summary of Findings on Spy Hop’s Voices of the West, Convergence Design Lab (2019) — digital white paper by Virginia Killian Lund
INSIGHT THREE: A commitment to change drives a design process through collective imagination.
At its heart, participatory action research and design is generative and action focused. Participants know at the outset that the insights and ideas cultivated will be channeled into the design of a new course of action. If the intent is to reimagine a more equitable future, they understand too that the community must coalesce around a shared purpose.
Therefore, the more collaborative and inclusive the process, the higher the likelihood that a participatory research and design process will generate insights, ideas and program changes that will have resonating impact.
While this may sound complex, at its best the process is natural, enjoyable and engaging. Prompts like these can help participants surface underlying beliefs, tensions and shared values.
- What do you notice that surprises you?
- What confirms what you already believe?
- What challenges something you thought to be true?
- What do you want to understand better?
Based on dots connected and aha moments generated during reflection, action plans can take shape in a variety of forms and dimensions. Keep in mind that these action plans do not have to be large and complicated to have a big impact.
CONCLUSION
Participatory action research and design is a way to fortify the infrastructure of schools and nonprofits every bit as much as brick and mortar investments. The beauty of participatory action research and design not only lies in its capacity to help organizations tackle immediate pressing challenges, but also in the way it plants seeds of collective resilience that can produce habits of innovation. A process that allows everyone in a learning ecosystem to meaningfully contribute strengthens the connective fiber of social and human capital. When these connections, networks and collective mindsets take root, learning communities are empowered to overcome challenges and innovate new solutions for the present and future.
If you want to learn more about collective resilience through participatory action research and design, please reach out to us at Convergence Design Lab and start a conversation.
Mindy Faber and Margaret Conway, Co-Founders, Convergence Design Lab
REFERENCES AND RESOURCES
Digital Atelier Toolkit by Archeworks and Convergence Design Lab
The Work Speaks for Itself: Understanding the Impact of Youth Media, 2018–19 Spy Hop Evaluation Report by Convergence Design Lab
“This place doesn’t feel the same”: A Summary of Findings on Spy Hop’s Voices of the West, by Virginia Lund (2019) — video white paper https://vimeo.com/388247448
Design Justice: Community-Led Practices to Build the Worlds We Need By Sasha Costanza-Chock — An exploration of how design might be led by marginalized communities, dismantle structural inequality, and advance collective liberation and ecological survival. https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/design-justice
Digital Ethnography Research Center — Dr. Sarah Pink’s research on digital ethnography can be found here.
Youth Participatory Action Research (YPAR) Toolkit by Youthprise
Participate helps learning organizations create online spaces for collaboration, communication and learning and is close partner of Convergence Design Lab
Chicago Learning Exchange is a membership network comprised of over 200 Chicago learning organizations and is a close partner of Convergence Design Lab.
Spy Hop is one of the country’s leading youth media organizations located in Salt Lake City and a long-term close partner of Convergence Design Lab











