Pizza Letters: On making pizza at home
As perhaps an éminence grise of pizza blabbing, I am asked on occasion by various journalists to offer opinion on trends or issues in the pizza world. Because I don’t formally blog these days, my answers often become impromptu blog posts in and of themselves — with an audience of one. Sometimes I miss boring the world with my pizza observations, so I figured I’d share my correspondences here.
For this inaugural Pizza Letter, I’m publishing some of my correspondence with Cara Eisenpress, who emailed for advice on making pizza at home. This was for her July 2014 article on First We Feast: The Complete Guide to Making Pizza at Home, which turned out quite nice, all bias aside ;)
Hi Adam,
Here are the questions I came up with [moved to response below — AK]. I can’t wait to hear your thoughts. Feel free to add anything I haven’t covered or to skip any questions that are too dumb to answer. It’d be great to hear back from you by end of day Friday.
Thank you again!
Hi, Cara,
I’m going to answer in-line below. Feel free to use whatever and to edit down if you need to. I can be long-winded. I don’t know if you’re running your own recipe(s) or whatever, but I do refer a lot to a Foolproof Pan Pizza recipe by J. Kenji Lopez-Alt on Serious Eats. It’s fantastic and I think is the perfect answer to casual at-home pizza-making. I also then offer some tips for people who want to take it to the next level.
Anyway, LMK if you need different answers, etc. Here goes…
1. Is there an ideal pizza dough recipe/procedure for the home cook?
I think there are two kinds of home pizza cook — the serious amateur who’s maxing out his or her oven, hacking it so it runs hotter, who’s always in pursuit of the next 1 or 2 percent improvement; and then there’s the “all pizza is good pizza” person. I’ve been both and in truth switch back and forth between the two modes. The trick, for me, is to know what style of pizza my oven can reasonably produce and temper my expectations against that.
The closest I’ve seen to an ideal home-style pizza recipe is, well, there are two. I don’t know if you want me plugging Serious Eats here, but my former colleague there, Kenji Lopez-Alt, posted probably the two best recipes for home pizza-making. The best one of those two is his “Foolproof Pan Pizza” recipe — http://slice.seriouseats.com/archives/2013/01/the-pizza-lab-the-worlds-easiest-pizza-no-knead-no-stretch-pan-pizza.html
It’ll result in something like the best Pizza Hut pan pizza you’ve had. And it’s an easy recipe. The catch is that it’ll take at least 11 hours for at least good results and a little over 24 hours for the best. Most of that is waiting time while the dough rests and ferments and builds up flavor. Too little time, and the compounds resulting from fermentation aren’t there in sufficient amount for flavor or good browning. This is the case with all pizza doughs. Yes, you could technically bake this after a couple hours, but you’ll have a pale, bland dough.
The other great recipe Kenji posted is for the New York–style square pizza or “Sicilian” pies you’ll find in NYC by-the-slice pizzerias — http://slice.seriouseats.com/archives/2011/01/the-pizza-lab-no-roll-no-stretch-sicilian-style-square-pizza-at-home.html
It’s a little more involved than the pan pizza, which is why I prefer the former for a showstopper of a pizza if I’m cooking pizza for a crowd or at home just for fun.
The styles I’ve experimented with in the past and stay away from now are New York–style and Neapolitan. You just can’t do Neapolitan in a home oven unless your home oven is a wood-fired oven. Yes, there are hacks you can do, and some people have made some very impressive-looking Neapolitan-style pizzas in their home ovens, but those people are like the 1% of home pizza-makers. You really do need crazy high temperatures — at least 800°F — to do Neapolitan properly.
A decent New York–style is possible with some tweaks to the dough that most NYC shops don’t do (adding oil and sugar) and using the right baking surface AND fiddling a lot to figure out which rack to use, whether you need to simultaneously use a broiler or simply finish under a broiler, etc.
For some people, that’s half the fun of making pizza — chasing the incremental gains with each iteration of your recipe or technique.
Get Adam Kuban’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
But if you just want great pizza with minimal fuss, Kenji’s foolproof pan pizza is it.
2. What’s your opinion on delicious shortcuts, like English Muffin Pizza or French Bread Pizza?
I’m more a fan of French bread pizza if done right. Again, Kenji has a great recipe for French bread pizza on Slice/SE. Not to keep plugging his work, but it’s a solid technique. But, it’s a little labor-intensive for something that’s more like “snack pizza.”
In general, I support anything that gets people excited about pizza. Purists may scoff at French bread or English muffin pizza, but I was making that stuff as a kid and I can guarantee it stoked my interest in pizza and led me down the path I’m on today. Why deny future generations of pizza-makers this gateway drug?!?
3. What’s your favorite way to sauce a pizza?
Depends on the style, though I think you can’t go wrong with a simple sauce made from San Marzano or San Marzano–style tomatoes passed through a food mill — with a little salt added post-milling to taste. That will work on anything from Neapolitan to New York–style to Sicilian or bar pies or what have you.
4. Tell me about toppings, from cheese to meatballs. What’s good, what’s bad, what are the right number of toppings and the right amount of ‘em?
I grew up in the Midwest, where THE MORE, THE MERRIER — whether that’s number of toppings and/or the amount of each. Moving to NYC gave me an appreciation for balance, simplicity, and minimalism. Most people here do two toppings at most. But in the last couple of years I feel like I’ve synthesized both elements of my pizza character.
These days I’m equally happy with a minimalist pizza or one with 3 or 4 or 5 or more toppings — PROVIDED the pizza-maker has thought about how they work with each other AND whether each is applied sparingly. If you’re going to do 4 or 5 toppings, you’ve got to go light on each one.
My cardinal rule for saucing, cheesing, and topping is:
“What looks like too little is usually just about right in the end, and what looks like the right amount is probably going to be too much.”
To me, the base, the default, is the plain cheese pizza, and the toppings are like condiments.
5. How can at-home pizza makers cook our pizza well when we don’t have wood-fired ovens, like they do at the best restaurants?
Like I said above, choose a style that’s right for your oven. For most people, that’ll be a pan pizza or maybe a Chicago-style thin-crust pizza whose crust is not dependent on higher heat and short cooking times. Home ovens do vary. Some go to 500°F, some to 550°F. You may have found a way to crank the temperature up higher, even. If that’s the case, you may want to experiment with New York–style, but my main bit of advice is to just stick with pan pizzas.
If you’ve got the bug, though, I could recommend using a piece of steel to cook on. There are companies who make steel baking surfaces that are ready to go — or you can look around on the web and find instructions on sourcing a DIY steel sheets. That was the No. 1 thing that really helped me with my New York–style crusts.
The OTHER huge thing is to USE A SCALE to measure ingredients. If you are serious about your pizza journey, you’ll want to throw out measuring cups, since the amount of flour in any given “1 cup” scoop can vary, depending on how tight it’s packed. If you don’t know exactly how much flour or water you’re using, you can’t consistently reproduce results — or know that the tweaks you think you’re making are accurate.
This advice — using a scale — also plays into the notion of using baker’s percentages and “hydration.” In the US, basically baker’s percentage is way of expressing the amount of all other ingredients with relation to the amount of flour in your recipe. Say you start with 1,000 grams of flour. If you use 550 grams of water, you’ve got a 55% hydration dough — which is relatively low for, say, a New York–style dough (which may be around 65–67%). The famous no-knead breads made popular by Jim Lahey (and which technique can be used in pizza — see the Kenji Foolproof Pan Pizza recipe I reference) are “high hydration” — 75% or more. As you work with pizza dough and experiment with various styles, you’ll see how the hydration affects things, and after a while, you’ll grow conversant in baker’s percentages and hydrations and will be able to look at a recipe and make certain assumptions or predictions about its outcome.
So basically, my advice is to go get some knowledge! It took me a LONG time to realize that’s where I should have started all along. And I am STILL learning and have much more to learn.
6. What’s a pizza line you’d never cross (feel free to interpret this as “Is Hawaiian pizza a Yes or a No?”…or to elaborate much more and tell me about such things as pizza burritos…)
I’ve routinely crossed a lot of pizza lines in the past. As you can tell from the rest of my answers, I’m hardly a purist. But I do often draw the line at making a pizza into something it’s not. Like, say, a cheesesteak pizza. Or a taco pizza. Or a cheeseburger pizza. It doesn’t mean I haven’t tried it. I have, and I’ve found the results are oven disappointing. And the more literal you are about it, the worse it tends to be. I think you can riff on these ideas and create something new, but just throwing on ground beef and onions and american cheese and then doing a drizzle of ketchup or something — it can be awful.
Anyway, hope that helps. If you have any more questions, feel free to email.
Hasta la pizza,
Adam








