Sitemap
Talent & Technology

Winning the war on talent

The Importance of Networks

To the Labor Market and the US Economy

5 min readJul 3, 2014

--

We have always been social creatures. The way we grow, learn and create is hugely affected by our surroundings and the people that surround us. An old African proverb (and a book by Hillary Rodham Clinton) states “It takes a village to raise a child”.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Anthropologists have long studied how our communities and networks form — a british guy called Robin Dunbar saw correlation between brain size and cognitive capacity to maintain cohesive and stable relationships, the so called Dunbar’s Number. For us humans it’s around 150. That’s our social network.

But I have 1,000+ Facebook Friends

Sure you do. How many of them do you really speak to regularly? Ever? Dunbar himself did research on online social networks and found that our actual circle of friends remains stubbornly small, and technology simply enables us to maintain that circle in a fractured, dynamic world. The limitation is not technology but human nature.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Online Social networks like Facebook and LinkedIn remove a key friction point — time. We devote on average 40 percent of our social time each week to the five most important people we know, who represent just 3 percent of our social world, a minute fraction of the population.

Power of Networks and Labor Economics

Back in the 1980’s an American called Robert Metcalfe argued that the value of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of connected users in the system (n2), known as Metcalfe’s law. More recently others have argued that the value follows a more linear pattern of n(log n) originally derived from Zipf’s law.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

A similar idea can be applied to social networks. But what exactly is the ‘value’ of a social network? Outside of sending images that disappear after a few seconds or showing the world how great you look in yoga pants — social networks have long been considered an important feature in labour markets. Approximately half of all American workers report learn about their job through their social network (friends, acquaintances, relatives etc.).

Get Abakar’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

In the labour market, this value is realised through referrals, which reduce frictional unemployment by mitigating search. They also create a virtuous cycle — the more people in your network that have jobs, the more likely they are to refer you, then you have a job and refer others etc. ad infinitum. Labour supply and productivity is one of the primary axioms in modern economic theory. The likelihood of referral has a direct positive impact on economic growth. Surely then, vast social networks connecting everyone in America is the solution to our governments’ regulatory and fiscal blunders?! All Hail the Zuck?!

Friction in Referrals

Sadly, as always in the real world, things aren’t that straight forward. The vicious cycle also pertains — unemployment reduces the flow of referrals in addition to increasing congestion in the unemployment pool. The unemployed cannot refer. Your referral capacity is limited by your tiny social circle. Your network is homophilious — a worker has more links with workers of his own type. So the unproductive refer more of the unproductive. Then, there is always the human factors: do I want my smarter friend to work at this company and show me up; can I be bothered to refer people when I have better things to do; do I even know what my network is good at; do I know what my company is looking for?

Dunbar vs Metcalfe vs Zipf

The limiting factor to network nirvana and eternal happiness (for owners of FCBK and LNKD) seems to be human and our capacity to form relationships. But, things are not as bleak as they appear. Technology has been instrumental in removing some of the time and information frictions that stand in the way of our networks, and allow a compounding effect to the network. If my network value of V is derived from a size S. Two of me has a network size 2S but a value of greater than 2V because the value function is non-linear (see diagram above).

The key is the ability to be able to connect those individual networks together to derive the value. Referrals startups have made a splash in the techno-sphere over the last 2 years and every established recruitment software provider is touting the social referral features of their products. However, this only acts to solve part of the problem — accessing the individual’s network, but not adding the networks together to create the scale effect.

Emergence of Talent Communities

Press enter or click to view image in full size

In order to get increasing returns to the size of your network, you need to ensure the strength of the relative connections, which you can achieve by breaking down the frictions in communication. In fact research shows that the numerous ‘weak’ ties (e.g. acquaintances) for transmitting information about job opportunities are far more useful than the ‘strong’ ties (friends).

Just like with the Italian and Scottish Renaissance periods — a string of factors that brings (or breeds) like minded, innovative people in one place can spawn a collective surge forward. From antiquity we have found natural factors that brought us together — a water source led us to build a village, a river estuary became a city. We are social creatures, but some things are more naturally social than others. Looking for work is not high up the list (unless you are unhappily unemployed).

Some of the most famous Silicon Valley companies proudly tout their company culture as being one of the core pillars for their success. The very best have started to use that beacon to their advantage to attract more talent.

By creating the proverbial watering hole around their brand, an employer can tap into the network homophily, foster communication, hire better and innovate. Over the next few years we should see a wave of innovation that enables companies to cultivate the growth of such communities.

--

--

Written by Abakar

Co-Founder and CEO @Seed_Jobs. Finance dropout, music lover and aspiring cyclist