Sitemap
The Cauldron

Athlete-direct content (and a whole lot more).

The Case for Less Sports

We’re drowning in a digital sea of information and commentary, and we’ve lost sight of what matters.

--

As a Washington Nationals fan living in Chicago, the MLB Extra Innings package is more or less the only way to see my team play. Sure, there’s a random Saturday FOX game tossed in here and there, and they do actually come through town once in a blue moon, but effectively, if I want to watch — if I want to be a real pure fan for 162 games — I need to shell out the $200.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Jayson Worth homered against the Orioles? Cool, I’ll check out the highlight on my phone, maybe. (AP)

In related news, this is the first time in three years I haven’t bought the TV package. In fact, so far this year, I have seen zero Nats games. Wearing my Nats hat around, most people ask “Walgreens?” and I can shrug it off. Baseball fans, though, say “Nats fan?” and then ask me how Stephen Strasburg is pitching, and I actually have no idea. Most of the time I say something noncommittal, based on my experience of watching Strasburg’s career, like “he gives us six dominant innings in every seven-inning start,” but I’m not sure if that’s entirely accurate this season.

There’s a decent chance, though, that the other person knows all about Strasburg, or, at a minimum, has an opinion on his relative value when pegged against his contract, or whether advanced metrics are favorable to him, or some other thing they “read just the other day.”

If you’re reading this, there’s a strong chance that your Facebook wall or Twitter feed suggested that you come here, and you decided to click after a perfunctory calculation of your available time for the next however long. You’re not risking much. Most likely, the time you are spending is time with which you’re not going to be productive anyway. Maybe you’re at a stopping point in your work, refreshing your synapses. Maybe you’re on public transportation. Maybe you’re on the toilet.

You clicked because you like sports, but you are bored enough with them that spending a little time thinking about why less sports might be a good idea seems reasonable. Maybe this piece will be funny, or at least easy to read. And ideally, there will be something in here that you object to, something that compels you to repost or retweet. An add-on like “check out THIS garbage” or “no way, Joakim Noah is a BEAST” works perfectly — something that adds your opinion but is innocuous enough that you don’t hesitate before hitting the share button and moving on with your life.

This is more or less how we create and consume sports in the age of the social media-driven Internet. My job, as a content creator, is to produce something peripheral about sports and get as many people as possible to, in essence, go “ha ha, LOL!” Your job, as a person who likes sports, is to decide whether my content is worth your time. It’s like we’re playing a quasi-sport of our own; a sport of communication that happens to possess many sportslike qualities. Essentially, I am on offense and you’re the defense.

The boundary between “you” and “me” in this nonsport sport of sportslike sportthings is thin. When I finish this piece, I will return back to the Internet to decide which thinkpiece about Daryl Morey or which analysis of Carmelo Anthony to read. When you get done reading this, you will return to whatever application you came from and hopefully post something thematically — but not nominally — about your experience reading this.

Meanwhile, neither of us can dunk a basketball.

Don’t get me wrong, the experience of watching sports can be greatly enhanced by social media. It’s fun to feel like a part of a community when your team’s playing and you get to tweet strangely specific things like “Is Drew Gooden doing the Macarena?” or “I AM JOSE ABREU AND I EAT PLANETS.” In this digital era, those are no longer offhand phrases free of context. There are legions of strangers who know exactly what you mean because they’re watching the same thing, and they’re marking what you said as one of their “favorite” things. It’s like watching the game at a bar full of people you know, or a living room with your college buddies. And if you miss a game, the conversation from last night is still on the record.

Get Ben Johnson’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

There are also other conversations, like ones about what it’s all supposed to mean, and about how to rate any given player, or about how the salary cap structure will impact player movement, or about how the rules of the most recent collective bargaining agreement have had an impact on competitive parity in the league. There are limitless conversations to be had with limitless people about any damn sports subject possible. That’s just part of how we do things now.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
This graffiti, scrawled in response to the Braves’ decision to relocate from downtown Atlanta to the suburbs, could stand for many in the battle against non-sports sports. (AP)

So why “the case for less sports?” Economic reasons, for starters. Massive social media and internet revenue infrastructures have developed around analyzing and criticizing sports content. Leagues, essentially, are nothing more than for-profit corporations that have taken advantage of an environment in which revenues and valuations have skyrocketed in conjunction with the perfect marriage of sports, communications and technology. Heck, the entire tone of sports coverage has inexorably morphed from a “heckuva game” beat writers report to data-driven statistical and transactional analysis that could just as easily be at home in the business section. The added layer of sports spin, rumors, investigation and LOLing, by nature, underwrites the often predatory corporate institutions providing the sports content that makes all of this possible.

But the case for less sports is not — and probably should not be — an ideological stance against what sports are and what they represent. Rather, it’s my reaction of weariness to the dehumanizing of sports. Sports are about humans doing things as well as they possibly can, through years of dedication and practice, set in respectfully competitive opposition against other humans who are also trying their best. And to the extent that sports are about humans, enjoying and experiencing sports is most palatable by human means on a human scale.

Sports are not — and probably should not be — about netting a championship trophy as the return on investment for optimally-leveraged resources. Nor should sports be about knowing more than your neighbor does about the footwork drills being run with aplomb by your team’s third-string quarterback, and hoarding that information in order to one day crush him in a dynasty fantasy league.

That’s not sports. That’s business. That’s WORK. Let’s stop working so hard, everybody. They’re just sports.

Have you ever gotten into a conversation about sports with someone — like a real-life, in-person conversation — and you soon realize you’re both swapping facts from the same article? One of you finally admits, “Yeah, I read that,” and the conversation quickly veers somewhere else. Have you ever then had the urge to check then your phone to find additional information to buttress your sports know-it-all-ness? All while an actual person is standing right in front of you?

That is the case for less sports, in a nutshell.

The good news, and the paradoxical aspect of all this runaway sports everything, is that I no longer ever have to watch a Nats game. I can just follow Adam Kilgore on Twitter and get every Nats scoop in the world the instant it happens, even something as banal as this. I respect Kilgore and his work ethic immensely, but he is a machine. He is not human. No human can watch 162 baseball games per year for multiple years and still be tweeting things like “Soriano in for the save.” At least, I couldn’t. I would be tweeting “Soriano in for the save. Again. End my life please.”

Kilgore’s just being Kilgore, though. And I know I can rely on him to let me know whether or not Soriano’s in for the save while I wait for my girlfriend to be done in the movie theater bathroom. And because he and his ilk are all about sports sports SPORTS — and I love him for this — I actually need sports less.

It’s certainly not hard to find out enough about Strasburg. The information is everywhere you turn. (AP)

I don’t have to know anything about Strasburg, but if I ever want to, it’ll all still be there, down to the pitch counts and pitch locations and pitch types and pitch movement and heatmaps against righties and lefties. Kilgore will tell me. Fangraphs will tell me. Sports on Earth and SB Nation and ESPN and Grantland and Deadspin will tell me. Anybody who thinks I might want to hear it will tell me, because they are and want to be hopelessly entrenched in the business of telling me. Because there are millions of potentially Strasburg-curious sports fans out there with smartphones waiting for a table at Red Lobster, and their eyeballs secrete ad revenue.

So today, the day on which America has absolutely no sports to watch, you should join me in consciously avoiding sports. It’s nice. Sure, I’ll check out a game here or there, maybe tomorrow, maybe not. I may read some commentary if I like a certain writer. More often, though, I won’t. I won’t DVR a game and then go “la la la don’t tell me I’m recording it” at social gatherings. I will let outcomes be “spoiled.” If I hear that I should really watch a certain thing, maybe I’ll watch it. Maybe with a friend I haven’t seen in a while. I will not book sports as an appointment in advance unless there’s a very high chance that something incredible might happen.

I know, I know; I’m “not a real fan” because of this — which is, of course, ridiculous. There are entire branches of discussion related to “bandwagons” and “bandwagon jumping” and when is appropriate to jump on or off. The idea that anyone can paint others with a one-size-fits-all fandom brush— that person watches every game, and that person goes to the grand opening of a supermarket because Dan Hampton will be standing there, and that person has Officially Licensed brand logo cufflinks that cost $60, and if you’re not that kind of a fan, you are less worthy to enjoy the sport, the team, or the game than a person who does all those things — is ridiculous.

The time has come to obliterate the myth of the “true fan,” and forget about cap space and amnesty provisions. You can be a fan to the exact degree you want to be. You can know as much or as little as you want to know. There is no right or wrong as to where you fall on the fan spectrum. Just don’t get trapped by the mechanism, don’t purchase $60 team-logo emblazoned cufflinks as a desperate measure to prove your loyalty.

Of course, there’s a chance that I basically just called you an idiot by suggesting that your love of and obsession over sports is idiotic, which, hypocritically, flies in the face my call to humanize sports and sports commentary. You might have noticed this inconsistency and disagreed with me. You might feel a need to let me know that you are smarter than I am, that you’ve noticed that my argument has holes in it. In which case, I value your input, and I urge you to retweet and share this article to convince everyone that I have no idea what I am talking about. That would really fix my wagon.

Or, how about if we just go play shoot some hoops or toss BP to one another, instead? Let’s just not get into a debate about how much Chandler Parsons should be paid, OK?

--

--