Building with Systems
While it might be that digitalisation is the most important trigger initiating the construction revolution, it will not be enough without rethinking the processes and re-evaluating the whole construction value chain. True, today the design of a building is mostly ones and zeroes and if the information quality is high enough it can generate enormous value, but at the end of the day it is a physical product, which manifests with and is perceived by human senses. Instead of thinking about the application of BIM as an end, we should merely consider it as a means of achieving a wider restructuring of a dysfunctional industry.
More haste, less speed
The housing industry faces a huge challenge of responding to the growing demand in urban environments. The common reaction to this seems to be just pushing the same old machine faster and faster. Instead it should be about systematically reducing all sorts of waste and not looking at costs at face value. The affordability aspect is often linked with the problem that each building is architecturally and structurally unique and every time the invention of the wheel starts from zero. Although building systems have been — and increasingly are — used in the construction business, it is mostly still a “prototype” industry, which makes achieving economies of scale virtually impossible. With so many constantly changing companies in a building’s value chain that all have different motives it is natural that nobody actually has the incentive to take the lead in developing a solution that could be reused in future projects and improved over time. By definition a system is an organised, purposeful structure that consists of interrelated and interdependent elements (components, entities, factors, members, parts etc.). These elements continually influence one another (directly or indirectly) to maintain their activity and the existence of the system, in order to achieve the goal of the system.
The interchangeability of building components is essential to the overall design of a product of mass customization (1).
The challenge is to create a system so that complex connections work in simple ways and even when the size and visual parameters of the components vary, the efficiency of assembly remain.
Architecture vs. system building
After the initial idea from the developer or client every building process starts with design so the challenge first and foremost is for architects to figure out how to create a customised product with a finite number of parts within a system. Naturally the spectrum of different types of buildings is wide and mass customisation can not easily be applied to for instance infrastructure projects or landmark buildings like museums or opera houses. Sadly the words standardised and building can generate a mental picture of an Orwellian dystopia with grey uniform buildings from the USSR. Talking about the visual aesthetics of buildings can be problematic and understandably so because the space around the buildings is often public and “beauty” is a subjective opinion. So whatever the solution it must come with options and variety but at the same time if one of the key criteria is affordability, then variety has to have certain limits and rules. A simplified example here is Lego, which has an endless possibility of combinatorial solutions but the interfaces constrain certain “freak” movements (round objects or weird angles etc.) Construction in a very plain sense casts new Lego pieces with new connections for each new building. It is a common misconception to think that system building brings about a tradeoff with architecture and a standardised process requires visually copy-paste buildings with minimal variety.
Affordability and aesthetics don’t need to contradict, they just require ingenuity and knowledge of certain principles (like Design for X) from the beginning.
Degree of Prefabrication
To benefit from offsite construction the degree of prefabrication must be as high as possible. At the end of the spectrum we have volumetric modular units where all the primary systems are done at the factory. The degree of onsite work is the lowest, but it sets a limit to the dimensions and complexity of the building. Between large-format 3D modules and on-site masonry units there is a spectrum of panelised systems. Precast concrete units can perform some, but not all the functions of a wall. For instance prefabricated timber frame walls can be fitted with windows and cladding at the factory. Compared to modules they are cheaper to ship to the site, but require more onsite work. In other words, the higher the degree of prefabrication the more different components are handled by a centralised source and the easier it is to control quality and plan reliably. Already the mindset of prefabrication makes the project team plan more elaborately since it systematically forces the counterparts to communicate and plan ahead.
Get Lauri Tuulberg’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
(1) Prefabricated Systems — Knaack, Chung-Klatte, Hasselbach











