LupineTroubles [he/him, they/them]

Do not, my friends, become addicted to bad news. It will take hold of you, and you will resent its absence.

  • 0 Posts
  • 131 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: December 16th, 2024

help-circle





  • I am not basing it on the online communities I interact with of course, as otherwise I’d have a much higher opinion of Americans. I am basing it on more regular Americans I met and interacted with, political developments, media, political polling and statistics in general. Americans also often have less idea about politics of rest of the world (which is natural, as US is center of global politics and people from outside of US know much more about US politics than other way around usually) and don’t realize some of the things they complain about as uniquely American just isn’t and that funnily might be another manifestation of American exceptionalism. This is not to say that there aren’t bloodthirsty warmongers in America, you are governed by such a cohort already and both parties are more or less pro-war. It is just rightwing populism, chauvinism and jingoism exists everywhere and I don’t see Americans as particularly above average in that regard and that again is despite the American government’s efforts.




  • It some ways existence of US and Israel is a moral hazard, because it can too easily validate unexamined beliefs about the world and be an obstacle to introspection about one’s moral values because it is too easy to just take for granted the fact that US and Israel are so oppressive and destructive that it overshadows everything else. This is a pitfall I see many people fall into, especially in West, where they think their moral duty done simply because they are critical of US and Israel. It is easy to criticize others (especially when we are talking about geopolitics impact and humanitarian catastrophe that is US Israel) and difficult to self-criticize with lingering national liberal sentiments that are the foundational ideology of all nation-states but one should realize the magnitude of damage US and Israel does only makes it easier to think oneself principled without ever putting those principles to test.


  • My perspective on this is that what are we comparing this to, exactly? If we are to see American population as exceptionally bellicose does it follow naturally that other countries (especially in the Western political order) have populations less supportive of their country’s military actions? I think in most countries a large portion of the population simply doesn’t even examine this, they just think it is the government doing government things, there is a well-known tendency to rally to flag or at best simple indifference. I can’t in good faith say that American population is more bellicose because there are politicians from other countries (who very much are the same libs as you describe here in ideology and behavior alike) who criticize American government’s actions because their politics and interests didn’t bend that way while the population of those said countries are completely indifferent about whatever their military is doing at the time. A lack of opportunity and a whole lot of untested principles doesn’t make for a better morality, especially when it is so quiet as to be internalized completely.

    In that respect, the fact that I see so many Americans so starkly opposing not only their government’s actions (whether out of factionalism like liberals talking about procedure and decorum or genuine anti-war stance even if comes from weird libertarian beliefs nested in American exceptionalism) but also genuinely oppose their own state and military’s circumstances and stakes in the global order to benefit of American Empire is something that I find valuable. It is then not that America doesn’t have bloodthirsty warmongers, warhawks, outright ideological automatons lockstep with whatever their party line is or everything else, it is that those exists everywhere else as well with a larger portion of population simply existing in quiet assent or silent indifference.

    It reminds me, in a roundabout way, of Westerners accusing non-Western people from war torn countries of violent radicalism when a lot of Western populations radicalized to violent rightwing regime with some of the highest standards of living in the world and having faced no conflict or violence in their lives. Simply put, the standards are not the same to say American population is simply more bloodthirsty because American government is involved in more wars with little to no input from the population, Europe was involved in basically almost all of American adventurism and in cases where it wasn’t (like France in Iraq War, they were simply too invested in Iraq to support a war and it wasn’t due to any anti-war sentiment in France and they bombed Libya more than America did when it was in their interest to do so) yet you don’t see as much of a contentious discourse as Americans get into nor as much of a principled anti-war stance even from bizarre ideological fronts.

    So overall I do think America is not exceptionally warmongering as a population, certainly they are not as chauvinistic as some other states nor so easily pulled into jingoism despite the government’s efforts to keep those impulses under control.




  • I don’t think they are thinking this far ahead and playing 4d chess with oil prices actually, in fact I don’t even think that US was expecting Iran to retaliate this directly against Gulf States and cut the traffic through Hormuz. In fact, even if that was their goal I don’t think high oil prices even help the moneyed class that much because US economy is fundamentally a consumer economy that becomes even more contradictory at high energy costs and they are definitely not pushing for renewables nor do I think there is an oil faction this powerful to get what they want at expense of everyone else.

    There is a certain relief in the idea that the people in charge are doing things deliberately for predictable outcomes to benefit their own ends at expense of others in a very observably material way but I don’t think that’s the case here, it is just Israel is a rabid state that’s hellbent on damaging their regional rivals to keep them weak and disorganized, they are completely rogue now because since Gaza they realized they can just get away with anything they do that’s why they are outright killing crops in Lebanon and Syria with chemicals, destroying Iranian refineries to do what’s essentially a chemical attack on Tehran. In fact I believe that Israeli politicians and military, aside from having a zealous fascist ideology, also likely prefers a weak and isolated Iran rather than a “reformed liberal” Iran that’s friendly with US and pose an actual challenge for them politically and economically.

    I’d even go far as to say that Israeli behavior doesn’t even benefit Israel per se, nor the livelihood and future of Jewish people in Middle-east even in a fascist ethnostate, but they think it does. That’s all there is to it, it is senseless violence and destruction, that’s a lose-lose situation for everyone involved, including US and Israel, except few politicians who are sheltered from accountability and consequences of their actions so they can do whatever.







  • I don’t think there is any hypocrisy between straddling Byzantium with debt and representing their misfortunes at the time like the Earthquake in Gallipoli or repeated civil wars with events so you have to react to them and navigate them within game mechanics and the game rewarding you doing exact same steps in exact same order with rewards that bypass game mechanics and give you bunch of free stuff so you can take everything easily once you survive the first few years.

    Besides Byzantium is favorite country if every deus vulting GSG fan so they get the first DLC anyway above and before many other countries and regions both ascendant and troubled at this time so complaining about them specifically is silly too. We will likely see them given silly amount of momentum for recovery that they compete with Ottomans on expansion into Balkans and Anatolia soon enough.