Sitemap

Unintuitive

6 min readJun 28, 2020

--

Why the principles of muscle physiology and biomechanics are so difficult to perform

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Sequence of the Pitch

Natural athleticism lends itself to increased body awareness, coordination, and the likelihood of higher level performance. However, without the strategic intervention by a skilled trainer at critical points along the chain of movement, even the most gifted can falter. This is especially so for those in overhead throwing sports like baseball, football, or volleyball, where the complexity of the movement is extremely high, often resulting in an athlete never reaching their full potential.

In my experience, the root of the problem lies in the complex and counterintuitive nature of how the body produces force. For many athletes, the act of hitting or throwing an object as hard or as fast as possible usually elicits a tensing up of the body and a pushing movement at the shoulder joint. Unfortunately, this can lead to mechanical breakdowns, a loss of velocity, and a lot of frustration.

But why is this phenomena so common? I believe it’s because most of us are much more familiar with the act of shortening our muscles to create force. This is known as a concentric muscle contraction. For example when we do a bicep curl, we are consciously shortening our biceps muscle in order to overcome the weight of the object being lifted. This type of movement is much more intuitive and a lot easier to perform.

In most overhead throwing sports however, we are utilizing our muscles in a completely different and unfamiliar way. Instead of shortening, we stretch or elongate our muscles rapidly in order to create more of a rubber band effect. The stretch reflex is even more counterintuitive, as this provides automatic muscle activation and movement of our limb. This concept is extremely hard to wrap ones brain around (covered in greater detail in the article: Hidden Potential). It’s no wonder why so many athletes are dumbfounded when a coach tells them that in order to hit or throw faster, they need to relax.

It makes a lot more sense when you understand what’s actually happening physiologically. In essence, what we are really trying to do is throw our arm backwards as fast as possible, which rapidly stretches the muscles on the front of the shoulder. The body then senses a threat and responds with an extremely forceful reflex (stretch reflex), causing those muscles (internal rotators) to rapidly contract and accelerate the limb in the opposite direction.

In essence, what we are really trying to do is throw our arm backwards as fast as possible, which rapidly stretches the muscles on the front of the shoulder.

An athlete must strike a very fine balance between muscle relaxation and muscle activation, as well as the timing of both. In doing so they take advantage of the pre-stretch (eccentric muscle contraction), which stores elastic energy and provides for more forceful concentric contractions. Applying our knowledge of muscle physiology, counter movements, and the kinetic chain, we can identify where the critical breakdowns occur.

Get Isaac Kneubuhl’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

During the initial stride in both the pitch, javelin and football throw, and during the lift off phase of the volleyball spike, the gluteus muscle of the trail leg should activate, causing the pelvis to rapidly rotate forward. Simultaneously, the left oblique should activate and the throwing/hitting arm should move horizontally across the body in order to keep the torso open or perpendicular to the pelvis, pre-stretching the core musculature. This is the first countermotion that allows the torso and pelvis to separate. Remember that pelvic/torso separation (more commonly known as hip/shoulder separation) is one of the biggest drivers and predictors of arm velocity.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Hip/Shoulder separation during the jump serve in volleyball (Jim Wolf Photography)

In improper mechanics, the hips and torso move together as one unit. If an athlete lacks proper gluteus activation, the hips will not rotate forward. Additionally, if the core musculature is too tense, the left oblique is not activated, or the arm does not horizontally abduct across the body, the torso will not be allowed to open. A lack of separation between the two segments means no pre-stretch, a less forceful concentric contraction of the core musculature, and a loss of energy.

In improper mechanics, the hips and torso move together as one unit.

The other critical malfunction occurs at the shoulder joint. This would be considered the second counter motion, and third phase of the kinetic chain when the torso is rapidly rotating forward and the arm is simultaneously rotating backwards into external rotation. If performed properly, the shoulder should rotate backwards as fast as possible, allowing the internal rotators to build elastic energy and trigger muscle spindle (stretch receptors) activity. This is the critical juncture where we are trying to generate a stretch reflex, which we know is an involuntary (unconscious) muscle activation.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Proper mechanics at the shoulder joint during the baseball pitch

In improper mechanics an athlete consciously forces or ‘pushes’ their arm forward at ball release or towards the ball at contact in an attempt to gain more speed. The result is a decreased range of motion, decreased build up of elastic/potential energy, and a weakened or inactivation of the stretch reflex.

In improper mechanics an athlete consciously forces or ‘pushes’ their arm forward at ball release or towards the ball at contact in an attempt to gain more speed.

The logical question then becomes: how does an athlete or coach go about identifying these mechanical breakdowns?

Answer: Knowledge & Technology.

An understanding of the proper sequence, which has been outlined above and in previous articles, gives you the reference points. Technology, in the form of a smart phone or tablet with slow motion video capabilities, allows you to see if those reference points (hip, shoulder, arm) are either rotating separately, or together.

If the hip and shoulder are rotating together as one unit, there will be a lack of hip/shoulder separation. The trainer can then intervene and begin the process of training this particular movement pattern. Gluteus activation of the trail leg, oblique activation on the opposite side of the body, and learning how to properly cock the arm back (horizontal abduction) should be thoroughly practiced.

Moving up the sequence, if you see the elbow of the hitting arm in front of or leading the torso, it’s very likely that the arm is being forced forward. A conscious activation of the internal rotators means a lack of range of motion, inactivation of the stretch reflex, stress on the anterior portion of the shoulder, and decreased velocity. The intervention then becomes teaching the athlete how to relax the shoulder joint while utilizing the rotational force of the torso to stretch the internal rotators and catapult the arm forward.

Often times you might see all three segments rotating together as one unit, a clear indicator that there are incorrect movement patterns occuring. A complete rebuilding of their mechanics might be necessary. Teaching the athlete the basics of the overhead throwing motion is a great place to start.

As one can see, even though we may have a firm grasp of the science, the actual performance and application of these physiological and biomechanical principles is a feat unto its own. The counterintuitive nature of muscle physiology, especially that of the unconscious and involuntary nature of the stretch reflex lies at the heart of the issue. However, armed with knowledge and technology, a coach can identify key breakdowns and begin the process of rebuilding.

--

--

Isaac Kneubuhl
Isaac Kneubuhl

Written by Isaac Kneubuhl

Biomechanics Practioner & Entrepreneur. Former Pro Volleyball Player & U.S. Men’s National Team Member. Passionate about learning, educating, and creating.