Sketches around Talmudic Logic
On the Root of Faith (I)
There is an aspect [known as] the root of faith, for faith itself has vitality and a root. That is, there is a World of Faith from where faith is derived. And the World of Faith also has faith in God — this being the root of faith, the inner aspect of faith.
Sometimes, one comes across a sentence that doesn’t sound like metaphysics at first, but which seems to carry with it an entire structure of thought — something dense, recursive, and strangely coherent. The line that says ”faith itself has vitality and a root” is like that.
I’m thinking about this idea that there’s a World of Faith, from which faith comes. It’s not immediately clear what that means, and I don’t think it needs to be clear right away. Maybe it’s best to sit with it and see what structure unfolds. If faith has a root, that suggests it isn’t groundless. It doesn’t just emerge out of nowhere or float as a feeling — it comes from somewhere. So the image of a root helps: faith as something that draws from deeper soil.
The phrase World of Faith could be taken metaphorically, but for now I want to let it mean something stronger. Maybe it’s not just a metaphor. Maybe it’s like a kind of modal or ontological region — somewhere faith already **is**, or always was, and we participate in it. Not unlike the way possible worlds work in modal logic, though this one isn’t just a “possibility” among others, but more like a source.
If I write it like this:
Then I’m saying: the fact that some individual has faith is grounded in this world W𝑓 — the World of Faith. Not caused by it in any mechanical sense, but rooted there, in a metaphysical way.
Now the next line: ”the World of Faith has faith in God.”
That changes things. It’s not just that our faith comes from it, but that it has its own relation to the divine. So:
To me that’s a strange but beautiful thought. It makes the whole structure recursive — faith coming from a world that itself is faithful.
Get Haniel Ulises Vásquez Morales’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
So maybe this is the whole picture:
And maybe:
I think the idea is that this faith in God, coming from the World of Faith, is not only the source of our faith, but its inner form. That’s what the last line meant: the root and the inner aspect. The root, because that’s where it comes from; the inner, because that’s what it carries in itself, invisibly.
I don’t know how to fully formalize that. And maybe I don’t need to. But it feels like something coherent is unfolding — a structure of grounding, intentionality, and recursion. Not to be proven, maybe, but to be inhabited.
