• 0 Posts
  • 429 Comments
Joined 5 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 1st, 2025

help-circle


  • They also reported, in the very same survey, that they are using AI for homework more than ever before, with usage climbing from 48 per cent to 62 per cent in barely seven months. The students, in other words, can see the problem clearly. They simply cannot stop participating in it.

    This suggests that what students using AI lack isn’t critical thinking skills. If they didn’t have those at all they wouldn’t be able to see the problem. This suggests that what they actually lack is self control and the discipline to quit using AI for their homework.

    This is not cognitive dissonance in any simple sense. It is something more structurally interesting: students have correctly diagnosed a systemic problem, but they exist within a system that gives them no rational incentive to behave differently.

    The incentive would be that they gain the skills they are supposed to gain by doing the school work. School work pretty much has always been designed to be a framework of building blocks designed to build skills. Skills like the ability to retain information, the ability to recall information learned and put it together with other new information, the skills to build info on info to go from understanding the barest concepts to understanding the technical details. Those skills are what bring reading and writing, math, science, etc together so we can go from 1+1=2 to πR^2, and understand the real world applications.

    While I can get behind the idea that teaching critical thinking has been minimized to its most basic form in schools in order to facilitate better test scores for decades, I don’t think it’s fair the say that school don’t teach critical thinking skills. I think perhaps it’s fairer to day that schools don’t prioritize teaching them, relying on people’s ability to observe and Intuit and come to conclusions which is exactly what critical thinking skills are.

    I do agree that Generative AI LLM’S are exacerbating the problems that were already there in this system. I even agree that administration at pretty much all levels of teaching is failing to mitigate the problems with Generative AI LLM’S.

    But students wouldn’t know this without critical thinking skills:

    Assignments are graded. Grades determine university admissions. University admissions determine (or are perceived to determine) life outcomes. If your peers are using AI and getting better grades, opting out is not a principled stand.










  • I’m not a mod. Literally have never been a mod. Pretty sure I can’t be trusted to be a mod.

    At any rate what I’m trying to say is other people might also report the comments if you link to them and call them out.

    If you want action, that’s how you get it. But the rhetoric you’re spewing turns people who might otherwise be on your side (against Israel for what they are doing in Palestine), and nobody gets anything done by themselves.



  • In some cases it doesn’t have an effect. Some things are just so big and have so many revenue streams that avoiding the products means removing approximately 4 cents from their revenue stream per person. Millions of people would have to do it all at the same time and that is difficult to organize and maintain.

    This doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t stick to your guns and not support things you have objections to. Something something integrity is doing the right thing when no one is looking something something.




  • There have been at least three different mods who have responded to you. Which one are you calling biased.

    More importantly (from the standpoint of moderation tools being pretty elementary to non-existent here on Lemmy), can you link to the individual comments?

    My best guess is that the user who you spoke to reported your comments which is why they were all removed.

    But with a backlog of over 300 reports when the mods are essentially volunteers, they can’t read the entirety of every conversation in order to find fault with comments that weren’t reported.

    So, if the comments were bad enough that you feel they should be removed, please report them.

    And stop with the all caps and the “Zionist” stuff. I don’t like genocide and don’t agree with Israel on most things but it’s hard to take you seriously when you sound like you’re raving.