• 1.92K Posts
  • 7.11K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: February 19th, 2024

help-circle
  • This begs the question: “what is religion?” For me the linked article is far too narrow in scope. For example, they don’t talk about stuff like civil religion that can be a mixture of theism, nontheism, etc.

    Personally I keep things real loose with a vague scale between “spiritualism” and “religion”. Spiritualism would be things that are more meta-physical but not necessarily bad. For example, feeling awe at a sunset or believing in a different plane/power. On the other end religion would be meta-physical stuff that’s bad, authoritarian, repressive, etc.

    A major point is to distinguish/contrast between people, ideologies, etc. that are “spiritual” versus “religious”. What are the good aspects (eg. community)? What are the bad elements? How do these work together. Can we have the good without the bad?

    For me this provides more nuance than just like: “There are a number of distinct religions. There are people who follow these religions and people who don’t. What is to be done?!?” I feel like many of these frameworks are tired and mostly used by “new atheists” which I would consider a mostly bad form of religion. No offense to this author though.