AFK BRB Chocolate (CA version)

  • 15 Posts
  • 809 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 10th, 2023

help-circle



  • But if you can, say, call up an intelligent portal virtually anywhere that’s near-omniscient and can transport things anywhere, well, that alone kind of limits the sort of things that you can run into that are real challenges to overcome. And that’s just one of the tools in Merlin’s toolbox.

    Yeah, exactly - makes things a bit too easy.

    Yeah…though to be fair, if the comparison is Corwin…a lot of the first book is just talking about how able he is to deal with situations and be cunning and see through intrigue even under extreme handicaps, like his damaged memory and with almost no information about what’s going on. That’s a high bar to follow.

    Oh, I get it - like I said, I know it was an intentional choice by Zelazny. Merlin is young, where Corwin was hundreds of years old. He’s a different char, and there’s goodness in that. But I also found it annoying in a main character.


  • I liked the earlier books the most, the ones that focused on Corwin

    That’s the first five books, the ones I said I liked better, too. For me, one of the reasons is that magic is mostly constrained to walking through shadows and using trumps. Corwyn mostly deals with his problems by training through solutions and deleting with people. In the second series, there’s a broader type of magic, and Merlin uses it to deal with his problems.

    Also, at least for the first half of the second series, Merlin is naive and easily manipulated, which I realize is intentional, but it’s frustrating.


  • I don’t know, it sounds like your biggest issue is that the books are written to be a series and not self contained. To me, that’s a narrative choice and isn’t always bad. I hate it when the author doesn’t finish and leaves he hanging forever, but I can appreciate a long story that takes multiple books to tell.

    I’m currently rereading the Amber Chronicles, by Roger Zelazny, and it’s like that. Arguably, it’s two stories of five books each, although there’s a thread from the first five that continues in the second. It’s a wonderful series, especially the first five.

    On the other hand, sometimes it feels like the author of a long series doesn’t know where he’s going, but is just trying to milk the franchise, and that’s more problematic.