At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked nannies in Holtsville, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Browse and hire nannies near you in Holtsville:
Care Member says "Lucille is amazing with children of all ages. (I have a baby, a 10 year old and a 13 year old). My girls love when she watches them and even the 13 year...
Melissa D. says "Myra is a wonderful caring woman. She cared for my two children and became part of our family. Myra would take care of my 2 year old and would take him...
Talia V. says "I called Victoria on a last minute basis and she was on my doorstep asap. My 21 month old responded well to her and didn't even care that I was leaving...
Carrie Y. says "Karen is great! She cared for our 3 kids after school. She was always on time and helped manage unpacking, homework, and helping to straighten up. We...
Brianna M. says "Nayra is an awesome person! So organized and always very punctual! She has a lot of skills that help her so Much with the kids ! The kids always love...
Amanda K. says "Sheena provided care for 1.5 years for my daughter (6) and son (2). Sheena was a wonderful, loving and energetic caregiver and we will miss her! My kids...
Josh G. says "Megan has been, by far, the best caretaker of my kids! She has been reliable, caring, fun... I can go on an on. I can go into more and more detail, but I...
Care Member says "Emily is absolutely amazing! We were very lucky to have met Emily as our daughter’s daycare co-teacher and she started sitting for us in 2021 when she...
Katrice K. says "Claire is very professional, polished and also nurturing. She made sure all of my son's toys were tidied up after playing with them and cleaned all his...
Centereach, NY
Care Member says "Jasmine is caring, genuine, great with my kids and really has become part of the family."
Julianne M. says "Margaret is very friendly and energetic with my toddler age girls, they love playing with her and are excited when she comes to watch them! She is very...
Shannon C. says "Loved having Elizabeth as our babysitter. Worked great with the kids, punctual, and very responsible. Would hire again."
Lindsey S. says "Asking Madaly to care for our little one has been the best decision we've made and losing her will be the hardest reality of moving. If we could take her...
Care Member says "Erin was great with our 1-year-old! She was super sweet and playful, and our daughter loved spending time with her. Erin kept us updated with texts and...
Coram, NY
Care Member says "Anita has been caring for our two young children for a year and we can’t say enough wonderful things about her. She treats our children with love and...
Megan O. says "Samantha was great I highly recommend her!"
Care Member says "We love Patty! She cares for my kids (1 and 3yo) as she would her own. She sends updates throughout the day, she’s creative, engaging, and punctual. If...
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $23.33/hr as of March 2026
The average star rating for rated nannies is 5.0
Nannies in Holtsville, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 7 reviews of the 60 listed nannies
- Care member
- Melissa D.
- Talia V.
The average hourly rate for nannies on Care.com in Holtsville, NY is around $23.33 as of March, 2026. Actual costs can vary based on your location, the nanny’s experience, and the number of children who need care. Families who need specialized help, such as infant care, overnight support, or light housekeeping, may pay higher rates. For a detailed breakdown of average nanny pay and what factors affect pricing, visit our guide to nanny costs or explore the Care.com Cost Calculator for more information on the cost of nannies in Holtsville, NY.
There are a few good ways to find a trusted nanny in Holtsville, NY. Many families start by asking friends, relatives, or neighbors for recommendations. You can also post in local parenting groups or community boards to find caregivers who come with personal referrals. Online platforms like Care.com make it easy to connect with qualified nannies near you. There are currently 3 nannies in Holtsville, NY on Care.com. You can filter by experience, hourly rate, and availability, then review profiles and read feedback from other local families. For more tips and ideas on finding the right fit, see our guide on how to find a nanny.
Families in Holtsville, can find many different types of nanny services to match their schedules and needs. Options include full-time and part-time nannies, live-in nannies, bilingual nannies, and those with experience caring for infants, toddlers, or multiple children. Some families hire night nannies to help with overnight routines, while others look for caregivers who can assist with homework, school pickups, or after-school care. Many nannies also provide light household help, like meal prep or tidying up after the kids, offering families extra support day to day.
When interviewing a nanny in Holtsville, it’s helpful to ask questions that give you a sense of their experience, approach to childcare, and daily routines. You might ask about their past roles, preferred age groups, comfort with activities like meal prep or transportation, and how they handle discipline or emergencies. It’s also a good idea to discuss scheduling, communication style, and expectations around household duties. Parents often prepare a a nanny interview checklist to make sure important topics like scheduling, communication, and responsibilities are covered.
When choosing a nanny in Holtsville, NY, consider both experience and personality fit. Look for someone with strong references, a proven track record in childcare, and certifications like CPR or first aid. It’s also important to find a nanny who communicates clearly and aligns with your family’s values, routines, and expectations. Many families on Care.com take additional steps such as setting up trial days, and discussing responsibilities in detail to make sure they find a reliable and trustworthy match.
Yes, many nannies in Holtsville, NY offer flexible schedules to fit different family routines. You can find part-time nannies who provide care a few days a week, after-school help, or morning coverage. Families who need extra support can also find weekend nannies for occasional or regular care on Saturdays and Sundays. Care.com makes it easy to filter by availability, schedule, and experience so you can find a nanny whose hours align with your needs.