At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked night nannies in Plain City, OH and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now in Plain City
Laura A. says "There are not enough words to describe what a blessing Nancy is to any new parent. She served as our birth doula and provided post partum care for our...
Care Member says "Jess is the only friend I have trusted with my baby girl who is now one year old. Over the past year, Jess has watched her for at least a half dozen...
Laura F. says "Nina helped me for 1.5 years, usually a few hours each week. She helped with keeping my house in order - doing laundry, vacuuming, food preparation,...
Kelli C. says "Sylvia is amazing :) I would definitely recommend her as your nanny or helper :) My children love her."
Maureen U. says "Derya was fantastic with my 4 year old daughter. I plan to hire her again!!"
Samantha B. says "Julianna has been by far the best nanny we could have ever asked for. She exceeded our expectations in all areas and that sets the bar high! She was...
Care Member says "katelyn is an absolute dream to work with. our kiddo is more reserved and katelyn met her where she was and let their relationship grow organically....
Kellie R. says "Alora was our nanny for 5 years. She cared for our twins from age 3 months - 5.5 years. She is amazing. Wonderful with the kids. Our son has autism,...
Care Member says "Jadyn did such a good job with our kiddo. He’s on the spectrum and full of energy and absolutely loved her. She’s very kind and professional. We highly...
Kurt L. says "Alyana is fantastic! We hired her for help right after our son was born, and we've hired her for babysitting since then. Great energy, great with young...
Ausha M. says "Kelsey is very bubbly and upbeat. As soon as she met my little one, she was able to take it from there. She's great with communication and following...
Emily L. says "Working variable days and shifts it is very hard to find care for my kiddos and adding to our family has only made it more difficult but Bella has been...
Haven B. says "Ryen is very mature for her age and we are so thankful to have found her on Care.com! After the interview, my husband and I felt she would be a...
Amy M. says "She is really dependable and very good with my girls. "
Heather W. says "She really loves kids! Was a great sitter! My son loves her."
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 night nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $20.00/hr as of March 2026
The average star rating for rated night nannies is 5.0
Night Nannies in Plain City, OH are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed night nannies
- Laura A.
- Care member
- Laura F.
The cost of hiring a night nanny in Plain City, OH typically depends on experience level, certifications, the number of overnight hours needed, and any additional responsibilities required. As of March 2026, families in this area pay an average of $20.00 per hour for overnight support. In addition to wages, you may also consider costs associated with benefits, overtime, or extended shifts. To estimate total childcare expenses for your household, you can use the Care.com cost calculator to explore general childcare cost estimates in Plain City or nearby areas.
Deciding between a night nanny or a night nurse in Plain City, OH depends on the level of support your newborn and family need. A night nanny typically helps with overnight care such as feeding support, diaper changes, soothing, and establishing early sleep routines. A night nurse, who often has clinical training, may be better suited for babies with medical considerations, premature infants, or families needing monitoring and specialized newborn care. Understanding the differences between these roles can help you choose the best fit for your situation, and many parents start by learning more about night nannies and night nurses before deciding.
Night nannies in Plain City, OH typically support families during overnight hours by managing feedings, diaper changes, soothing infants back to sleep, and tracking nighttime patterns. Many also help with sleep conditioning, offer guidance to new parents, and support multiples or babies with reflux or colic. Profiles on Care.com outline each nanny’s experience, certifications, and approach to newborn care so you can find someone aligned with your routine and preferences.
You can browse 1 night nannies in Plain City, OH by filtering for availability, experience with newborns, overnight care, or specialized training such as infant CPR. Reading reviews from other families and messaging candidates about your baby’s routine can help you shortlist the best options. Many parents schedule an introductory call or trial night to confirm fit before beginning ongoing care.
When interviewing a night nanny, consider asking about their experience with newborns, comfort with feeding methods, approach to soothing and sleep routines, and how they handle situations such as colic, reflux, or multiple wake-ups. It’s also helpful to discuss communication preferences and what updates you’ll receive overnight. A detailed list of helpful topics is included in our guide to night nanny interview questions.
Many families hire night nannies to get longer stretches of sleep, support newborn feeding schedules, and reduce stress during the early months. A night nanny can help stabilize routines, offer guidance to new parents, and provide reassurance for babies with special sleep or feeding needs. For more insight, you can read about the benefits of hiring a night nanny and how overnight care can support your family.