Linda's Reviews > Orphan Train
Orphan Train
by
by
Reading Orphan Train was like lifting the curtain on a part of our American history that many people are still unaware of. Thousands of children, the orphaned and the unwanted, were transported from cities of the East to the farmlands and small towns of the Midwest at the turn of the century and on into the Great Depression. It was a time of no background screening, minimal paperwork, and only a willingness to alleviate the hoards of children who were homeless for a multitude of reasons. While some children were better off under this limited system, so many were relegated to the life of an indentured servant, a built-in caregiver for other children, or a hardworking farmhand. If not placed, the remaining children were transported, once again, back to institutional life in the East until they became of age.
Christina Baker Kline has done an exceptional job of presenting the story of Niamh Power, a fictional character, who represents many aspects of a child's life under this system. Her research and background work is stellar in securing historically accurate depictions of the time period. The experiential background of this child will certainly open your eyes to the sad fate of some of these individuals. The additional insights and interviews with the author at the end of the book provided such an extension to her story.
What makes this such an exceptional read is Ms. Kline's use of a parallel story of current conditions alongside the telling of Niamh's life. It's not one story overshadowing the other. You are drawn both to the past and to the present with her adept use of characterizations. Not only is Ms. Kline talented in presenting the inner turmoil and emotions of the characters, but she paints the conditions, the settings, the interactions with a fine brush of satisfying details to be savored.
I have thoroughly enjoyed this book. Christina Baker Kline has caught my attention as an author whose works will always be memorable. Bravo!
Christina Baker Kline has done an exceptional job of presenting the story of Niamh Power, a fictional character, who represents many aspects of a child's life under this system. Her research and background work is stellar in securing historically accurate depictions of the time period. The experiential background of this child will certainly open your eyes to the sad fate of some of these individuals. The additional insights and interviews with the author at the end of the book provided such an extension to her story.
What makes this such an exceptional read is Ms. Kline's use of a parallel story of current conditions alongside the telling of Niamh's life. It's not one story overshadowing the other. You are drawn both to the past and to the present with her adept use of characterizations. Not only is Ms. Kline talented in presenting the inner turmoil and emotions of the characters, but she paints the conditions, the settings, the interactions with a fine brush of satisfying details to be savored.
I have thoroughly enjoyed this book. Christina Baker Kline has caught my attention as an author whose works will always be memorable. Bravo!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Orphan Train.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 8, 2015
– Shelved as:
to-read
February 8, 2015
– Shelved
March 23, 2015
–
Started Reading
March 25, 2015
– Shelved as:
favorites
March 25, 2015
–
Finished Reading
January 11, 2016
– Shelved as:
5-star-winners
January 25, 2016
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Linda
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 31, 2016 07:20PM
Thanks, Barbara. Such a good job by this author.
reply
|
flag
Thanks, Dana. I read this last year and see that it has popped up again. Such a good book about a time in our nation's history that many were not aware of.
Great review. I also loved this book when I read it a couple of years ago. I still think about it and recommend it to family, friends and library customers. Such an interesting and touching read.
The Baking Bookworm wrote: "Great review. I also loved this book when I read it a couple of years ago. I still think about it and recommend it to family, friends and library customers. Such an interesting and touching read."Thanks so much! I agree. This book is so memorable and the writing was superb. Many people are unaware of this time in our nation's history. Heartbreaking for some and a chance for happiness for others.
Thanks, Amanda. This review popped up from last year. Don't know if you've read this one yet. It's exceptional and the author brings out so much in her characters.
Amanda wrote: "Wonderful review, Linda! This looks like a novel I would be interesting in reading."I think that you would love this book as much as I did, Amanda. It just speaks to the heart. To think that the Orphan Trains actually existed and provided for children is amazing.
Thanks, Danita. This book was based on historical facts of the time. The children really touch your heart.
Great review! I found the lives of these orphans to be absolutely heartbreaking. People treated them like it was their fault and like these children were not good for anything except being a slave. They were children! They needed to be loved!
I so agree with you, Ashley. It was like jumping from the fry pan into the fire for so many of the children. Some were turned into servants rather than family. Sad!
Thanks, Mariah. An eye-opening part of our history. It turned out well for some children, but not all.
Susan wrote: "I loved this book too - terrific review!"Thanks, Susan. This is such a special book. Hope others get the opportunity to read it.
Thanks, Baconlover312, Natalie, and Kim. Some books just stay in your memory longer. And this one always will.
Thanks, Dorreh. This was such a good presentation of how the Orphan Trains affected the lives of children during this time in history. What looked good on paper didn't always end up benefitting the very ones that needed protection.
This has been on my list of books to get for a while but I was worried about having too many wwIi novels already. But your review really makes me want to pick this one up the next time I go on a book binge!
Thanks, Ashley. It's such a good read. I know what you mean about getting to all those awaiting books. My TR pile is monstrous!
Thanks, Jenni and Stephanie. This book was so good and showcased a period in history that is not well known.
Cindy wrote: "Great review Linda. I loved that book"Thanks, Cindy. I absolutely fell in love with this book and all the emotions that it pours out. Good one!
Thanks, Carol. I don't think that many people have read this one. It is so well done and one of my favorites.
I know what you're saying, Linda. My TR pile is in the high elevations! Ha! So many books and never enough time.
Tammy Galbraith wrote: "Thanks for the review! I love reading, especially when it involves history!"This was such a good one, Tammy. It's based on a little known situation in American history. I saw a PBS Special where a woman still had the little red coat that her mother wore as an orphan on a train going West.
Thanks, Erin and Karen. This book was very special and told of a time in history where children were placed in homes for a multitude of reasons. Some were saved and some were worse off.
Thanks, Anja and Meredith. The author touches on a little known historical fact with a very fine fictional storyline.
Lovely review, Linda! You are so right - this one certainly opened my eyes. What a heartbreaking story.
Currently reading this for the book club Diversity in All Forms! Feel free to join in the discussion :)https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...







