Sitemap
Chris Hurlbert

Chris Hurlbert

Advertising / Media

A Fight for Freedom, Version 2.0

Critical Analysis of the Relationship Between Social Media, Citizens and Government in the Developing World

16 min readJul 24, 2014

--

This dissertation and critical analysis was written as a final paper for a class I took while studying in London.

Introduction

In the United States and throughout much of the Western world social media is taken for granted and the Internet is expected to be free and uncensored by government. Facebook is used to share content, Twitter is used to crowdsource news, YouTube is home to amateur films and to most people, blogs are used to share snapshots of their lives while traveling abroad. Individuals are able to search for any information they want and can openly share what they find amongst their peers without fear of getting harassed or imprisoned. Although recent law passed in the European Union has forced Google to remove certain websites from its universe, and some domains have been blocked by ISP’s in the United States due to indecent or illegal content, which some people view as a form of censorship, most governments do not have the legislative power to fully censor the information we have access to digitally.[1]

While social media and Internet technologies are generally used for fun, education and mild partisan debate in the West, these same platforms are used much differently in the developing world. The Arab Spring, a revolutionary wave of protests and demonstrations that took place throughout Northern Africa and the Middle East starting in December 2010, leading to riots (both violent and non-violent) and even civil wars, were successful in the most part due to the use of social media platforms as a means of organization. The countries of Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, Yemen, Bahrain, and Syria are all recent examples of this phenomenon and they surely will not be the last.

According to M. Papic and S. Noonan, “The Internet allows a revolutionary core to widely spread not just its ideological message but also its training program and operational plan. This can be done with e-mail, but social media broaden the exposure and increase its speed, with networks of friends and associates sharing the information instantly.”[2] In each of the Arab Spring cases, the protest movements were able to gain strength and build a strong opposition with the help of social media platforms. However, due to the transparency of social media, paired with Internet hacking and spying capabilities, authoritarian leaders also have access to this information at the same time as the opposition, which can lead to the censorship of communications, imprisonment of organizers, widespread domain blockages, and in some extreme cases, total Internet blackouts.

In this essay I am going to briefly analyze the sociopolitical and economical situation in the Arab World that caused these revolutions to occur, and then take a deep dive into understanding the role that social media played into organizing oppositional forces during this time period. I will show how the platforms were used to inspire change at the grassroots level and how the authoritarian regimes attempted to stop the uprisings by curbing social media. Finally, I will discuss an ongoing situation in Southeast Asia where the government actively controls media, censors the Internet, and fines or imprisons anyone who speaks out digitally — a situation that is ripe for change. This essay will offer two case studies, promoting the thesis that social media, despite varying degrees of Internet penetration and many broad attempts of government censorship, works well to promote and organize grassroots regime change in the developing world.

Background Information

In order to understand the relationship that media played in the toppling of some of the world’s longest standing modern authoritarian regimes it is important to understand the underlying sociocultural and economic forces that were at play, as well as other important mechanisms leading to the respective uprisings. It is important to disregard the common inclination to think of the ‘Arab world’ as a unified entity, as most Westerners tend to do, when in fact the nations are quite diverse, both culturally and geographically. While Arab societies and organizations do have common connections, the potent myth of the ‘Arab nation’ and idea of ‘Arabism,’ which is complex and tied to the history of the Middle East, are arbitrary concepts that have been cultivated by powerful media, such as the satellite television channel Al-Jazeera and even news channels in the United States such as Fox News. The contagious nature of the Arab uprisings however, beginning with Tunisia in December 2010, which were also promoted by various forms of media, are a confirmation that strong internal bonds still link the component parts of the ‘Arab world’ today.

Nevertheless, in 2010 across most of the Arab world an explosive mix of socio-economic problems and widespread, worsening political grievances were coming together to form a common causal thread to anti-government sentiment, a catalyst to the future uprisings. Poverty may be seen as one of the primary motivating factors to this issue, but Katerina Dalacoura, an International Affairs columnist, points out that “the longstanding structural problems afflicting the Arab world came to a head prior to 2011 through a combination of persistently high unemployment, especially among youth (and an educated youth at that), rampant corruption, internal regional and social inequalities, and a further deterioration of economic conditions because of the global 2008 financial crisis and food price increases.” She also notes that more than anything else, “the rebellions were a call for dignity and a reaction to being humiliated by arbitrary, unaccountable and increasingly predatory tyrannies.”[3] This provides a decent framework and paints a dry image of what life was like for individuals living in these areas in late 2010.

Moving forward, it is also critical to understand that successful regime changes throughout the developing world depend on three factors, and the presence of one is essential to inspire a revolution. First, there must be an active group of reformers with a similar desire for regime change. Second, a democratic opposition must be present that is capable of using the limited freedoms offered by the authoritarian regime to compel the ruling elites to release their control of the country or negotiate a peaceful transition out of power. Third, there must be an end to any external support of the authoritarian regime or external obstruction of democratization.[4]

While all of the above is true, there is yet a fourth factor that is also critical to the successful democratization of a country: a grassroots movement or as Abdel-Fattah Mady calls it, “change from below.” When divisions amongst the ruling elite do not occur, and when there is no formal or organized opposition to the authoritarian leaders, political regimes have been seen to collapse under the pressure of mass demonstrations. In cases such as this, external powers, no matter how tied to the existing political regime, have been unable or are unwilling to save them. These grassroots movements are often caused by a singular motivating event, such as the self-immolation of Mohamed Bouazizi in Tunisia, and are then promoted through various media channels including the social media platforms Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. These events gain coverage, promote social outcry and organization, and fuel the fire of a revolution.

Tunisia, the birth of a revolution

Many academics believe that the self-immolation of Mohamed Bouazizi, as mentioned above, was the main catalyst to the Arab Spring movement across Northern Africa and in other parts of the Middle East. Kareem Fahim of the New York Times reported that on the morning of 17 December 2010, Bouazizi was slapped in the face by a police officer after trying to take back a bag of apples she had confiscated from him. He was accused of selling them illegally on the street, as he had neither permit nor the means of acquiring one. Fahim argues that in this moment, Bouazizi “became the hero — now martyred hero — and [the police officer] became the villain in a remarkable swirl of events in which Tunisians have risen up to topple a 23-year old dictatorship and march on, demanding radical change in their government.”[5] While Fahim and other academics are correct in this description and analysis — Bouazizi, for all intents and purposes, did start the revolution in Tunisia — it is critical to note that his self-immolation would not have promoted mass rioting and the formation of a strong opposition had social media platforms not been involved.

An image of Mohamed Bouazizi, the martyred Tunisian hero, held by his mother.

Tunisia was fertile ground for an internet-enabled uprising as most of its population was well educated, tech savvy (85% of the population had a cell phone, 2 million of them were on Facebook) and young (the median age in 2010 was only 24). At the time of the revolution, Twitter had a much smaller footprint in the country, with only perhaps 500 active users, but in the traditional Malcolm Gladwell ‘connector’ sense, who was actually tweeting mattered more than how many people were using it.[6] Facebook and Twitter were also leveraged as tools for activism because they were the only guns in the country’s Web 2.0 arsenal that were not government-censored, which was the case amongst the blogging community and on YouTube.

As the story of Bouazizi’s death spread amongst the digital community and started leaking from social media into the real world by word of mouth, dissent of the regime’s tyrannical nature became ubiquitous. Within a day of Bouazizi’s immolation, for example, individuals were already organizing around a common Twitter hashtag. The goal of the digital opposition then became to inspire and motivate people to leave the comfort of their homes and move to the streets, where chaos was starting to occur in a face off against the government and it’s internal security forces. In a few days the size of the protests had grown tremendously and they eventually provoked a violent response from police. Political organizers and cyberactivists were amongst these demonstrators and used digital videos and Twitter to spread the word of violence throughout the country.[7] This encouraged people to get off their couches and move into the public sphere where many of their neighbors and fellow comrades were already starting to fight back.

In a few short days the revolution spread 259km from Sidi Bouzid in central Tunisia to Tunis, the nation’s capital.

Within two weeks the protests began to spread from Sidi Bouzid, the poor area where Bouazizi had lived, into more prosperous parts of the country, including the large city of Sfax and the capital Tunis. Once this occurred, the uprising effectively went viral in Tunisia as it drew more and more people in, and the center of online action moved to Facebook, which was a much more popular medium in Tunisia than Twitter—and a much more visual one. Photos and videos posted on Facebook made the protestors’ case in an intuitive way as they spread through people’s online social circles.[8]

Get Chris Hurlbert’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

At this stage, the outside world also began to play more of a part. Bloggers from Western Europe and the United States began covering the events that were unfolding in Tunisia as images of the riots became more and more accessible. For example, the Netherlands-based organization Nawaat.org, which was founded by two Tunisian free-speech activists who fled the country in the 1990s, would post videos originating on Facebook, shot with cell phones, to its blog. Global activists would then republish this content and spread the videos through every digital channel imaginable.[9] This amplification effect went far beyond the dusty borders of the Tunisian community, with activists in many countries and from many backgrounds helping to promote their cause.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
A screenshot from Google Latitude showing Amamou’s last known location: in a government building. He had been arrested for his role in the mobilization of the opposition.

All of this happened so fast that the authoritarian regime, headed by President Zine el Abidine Ben Ali, was forced to play catch up. When they realized that the battle was not only being fought on the streets, but also being waged online, they began trying to curb the movement through unjustified arrests and media manipulation. For example, activist and blogger Slim Amamou was detained on 6 January 2011 for his role in the digital revolution.[10] He had been using the social network Google Latitude to reveal his location to other fellow rioters. The government wanted to keep arrests like this quiet, but because of cell phone location tracking Amamou was able to broadcast his location live to the world (until they shut his phone off). The cyber community made the connection that once Amamou’s location was updated inside an interior ministry building, he had been detained by the regime. This news went viral.

There are many other instances where measures like this were taken by the Tunisian regime during the revolution. A rapper called El Général—real name Hamada Ben Aoun—was arrested in Sfax because of a music video he posted online. In his song, “President, your people are dead”, he challenged President Ben Ali over corruption and unemployment.[11] Reporters Without Borders, a publication that promotes the freedom of information, reported that at least six bloggers and activists had been arrested or had disappeared in locations across Tunisia, and that there were probably others who had been targeted.[12] The Atlantic reported that the Tunisian government had been running a malicious piece of code on their servers that allowed them to record the Facebook passwords of anyone inside the country.[13] This piggybacks on an Al Jazeera article that accused the government of hijacking the Facebook and Gmail accounts of various reporters and activists. One blogger told Al Jazeera that his accounts were hacked, giving the government access to his four blogs and their respective content, all of which was swiftly erased.[14]

Despite the many acts of violence, arrests, censorship and hacking made by the regime in the weeks following the start of the revolution, there was not much that could be done to stop the rioting. The government tried to push back via their controlled mass media, but the Internet provided a way for protestors to poke holes in the stories disseminated through official channels.[15] When video of a counter-protest in favor of President Ben Ali was shown on television, for instance, cameras used by the government-controlled media carefully placed their shots to give the illusion of a large crowd. Activists were able to post their own version of the events, showing small crowds, calling the government’s bluff.[16]

There was also a systematic and organized silence within the state media, placing a blackout on any information covering the riots.[17] This strategy quickly backfired because individuals, eagerly seeking up-to-date news, turned to Facebook and Twitter, where it was easily accessible. The media subsequently started a campaign to demonize the protestors as thugs and outlaws, which also failed. As the revolution become more and more prominent, the propagandizing effect that the state run media had on the population became fleeting due to the quick response on social media by activists.

Throughout the last days of the street protests, social channels helped people come to a consensus quickly as the situation was constantly evolving and demands needed to stay consistent across the country. When the government detained activists, protestors were nimble and could hastily switch their demands, arguing for their release. Every time the President spoke individuals could vote in mass surveys online to reach an agreement on whether the demonstrations needed to continue. And when the country’s Prime Minister attempted to invoke the Tunisian constitution on 14 January 2011, after President Ben Ali had fled the country, lawyers and other individuals were able to show that he was siting the wrong part of the document and therefore was attempting to act illegally on behalf of the President, a move that flopped.[18]

As the revolution climaxed, the President prepared to flee the country and the police began to pull out of the streets, simple chaos became the greatest danger to the Tunisian people. Their demands had been met, but their government was now left in shambles. Here again, social media channels provided a platform for people to share information regarding rumors of destabilization and helped individuals organize themselves to help protect their neighborhoods and communities. Some people used Facebook to organize and start cleaning up the streets after the days of violence and rioting. Others gathered to help local shop owners get their businesses back up and running.

Social channels also helped people fight more sinister enemies: rumors and misinformation. Claims might have spread of massive shootings in a neighborhood, for example, but people in the area could join the conversation online and say what was really happening—and post pictures to prove their point. In other cases, rumors of unsafe water or electrical outages might threaten to spark a public panic, but Facebook and Twitter let people pass along the truth, instantly. Overall, social media tools helped activists counter those who were still trying to terrorize the population, helping to soften the situation and spread the message that people were helping to keep things in control.

Tunisia was the first example throughout the Arab world where social media helped activists unite a nation to topple their authoritarian regime. As I have shown through various examples, social media was not only critical to the organization of protestors, but also to the spread of accurate and free information. The Tunisian government tried to curb the measures taken by social activists by censoring their content, arresting their curators, and demonizing their followers—all of which failed, giving clout to the argument that social media is a powerful agent of change. Tunisia was the first of many subsequent revolutions that took place across the Arab world, the effects of which are still being felt around the globe, as more and more nations seek justice from their respective governments.

Vietnam, a digital fight for the freedom of speech

While the ouster of long-time authoritarian President Ben Ali in the Arab nation of Tunisia may have inspired democratic movements around the world, it has provoked other authoritarian regimes to further flex their muscles to protect their hold on power. Many aristocratic and socialist nations, after witnessing the role that social media played in the Arab Spring, took great lengths to ensure that their country could not do the same. Censoring the Internet, shutting down blogs, and blocking popular social media platforms became normal across the developing world, and some nations even enacted laws to send activists to jail for posting anti-government content.

One of the worst offenders in this impedance on free speech is the socialist nation of Vietnam in Southeast Asia. Ever since the Internet was introduced to the country in 1997 the government has played watchdog over its growth, enacting a nationwide firewall to block unwanted content—something known to the international community as the “Bamboo Firewall.” This firewall, which serves to digitally centralize all of the information transmitting across the country, essentially blocks Internet users from accessing sites that are deemed politically, religiously or sexually offensive.[19] While this firewall has been controversially been in place for nearly two decades, only recently has the government begun clamping down on social media and content produced by bloggers that is deemed “anti-government.”

The Vietnam socialist party has traditionally done a decent job at hiding their corruption, human-rights violations, political repression and censorship from citizens, but recently news of such atrocities surfaced online and have started to cause internal dissent. In order to calm the dissidents and stop future ‘problems,’ Vietnam enacted something called Decree 72, which gives the state yet another powerful legislative tool of repression. The law restricts all use of websites and online social media to the exchange of “personal information” only. It also bans the publication of material that “provides information that is against Vietnam, undermining national security, social order and national unity.”[20] The decree also requires Internet giants such as Google and Facebook to keep at least one server in Vietnam itself, giving the government control over their content.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Vietnamese blogger Pham Viet Dao, a prominent supporter of the opposition, was sentenced on 14 May 2014 to 15 months in jail for acts that were deemed “dangerous to the society” by the communist government.

Not only do bloggers have to worry about their sites getting shut down and their content erased, they may also face jail time if the government believes their actions to be “propaganda against the state.” Numerous cases of jailed journalists and bloggers can be found online, and Reporters Without Borders reports that currently there are 31 netizens (a term used when describing internet users in this situation) and three journalists currently behind bars in the country.[21] Along with Decree 72, the communist government also recently enacted a law that will fine dissidents 100 million dong ($4,740) for spreading “reactionary ideology,” meaning anything that does not constitute a criminal offence that the ruling party does not approve of. It also states that anyone posting an online map of Vietnam inconsistent with the county’s sovereignty claims will face a fine.[22] This issue is becoming hugely sensitive in Vietnam, where China’s perceived intrusion of territory has begun generating a kind of quiet anger that can cause an opposition to form, especially in a space where the government is failing to act.

At what point will the citizens of Vietnam reach their tipping point? When will their Mohamed Bouazizi emerge, catalyzing the nation into an opposition strong enough to fight these draconian laws and oppressive party leaders? As evidenced in the Tunisian revolution, social media has the power to rally citizens into action, but is this possible in a state like Vietnam, where the government exerts total control over the Internet? These questions are difficult to answer because no one truly knows; we can only analyze individual situations and make an educated guess as to what their outcomes will be. When levels of social repression and political grievances hit a certain threshold, however, it seems that the solution of modern times is clear: mobilization of an opposition through the use of social media platforms, clearing a path to revolution.

Personal Considerations and Conclusion

After deeply researching the Tunisian revolution and understanding the role that social media played in organizing dissidents, and being aware of the Arab Spring’s parallels to the so called Autumn of Nations (revolutions of Eastern Europe in the late 1900s), I find it hard to believe that the trend of Internet censorship will continue for much longer. Freedom of speech is a human right, fought for by the west and policed through entities such as Amnesty International and Reporters Without Borders. It is something that younger generations are willing to fight and die for, unlike their programmed older cohorts, who fear the powers that be. These young dissidents understand the power of information, can image living in a free democratic state, and are not willing to continue down the road of oppression. As more and more individuals in the developing world become aware of what their leaders are doing to them, they will swiftly organize, secretly if need be, and eventually revolt.

It is true that this will be difficult in nations such as Vietnam, where party leaders are virtually in complete control of the information spread online, but as Evgeny Morozov mentions several times in The Net Delusion, anonymizers, proxy servers, VPNS, and other digital tools can be used to protect dissidents from the watchdog eye of the state. Children across the planet are growing up into a world where technology is ubiquitous, and as these children grow they will search for the light at the end of the tunnel—an end to tyranny and government censorship, and will be willing to fight for it. I often look at the world with total optimism, which is sometimes naïve, but after researching and writing this essay I firmly believe this outcome is achievable.

--

--