Building a Beer Mecca
A mountain town rejuvenated by the explosive growth of craft beer
Narrative by Chris Hurlbert
I wrote this feature about Three Brothers Brewing Company and their relevance to the Shenandoah Valley as a final assignment for a writing course at Boston University.
A colorful past
Humans, like most creatures, are innovative. This was especially true in the early 1920s, when Congress passed the Volstead Act, forbidding the production, sale and consumption of alcohol in our country. While some strait edge American’s adhered to this blasphemous law, the rise of Al Capone and many other Mafioso’s in this era proves that the majority of our country did not. The meek threat of jail time did not force distillers out of business; it simply forced them to relocate their shops to less conspicuous settings.
During this time period many rural distilleries were nestled deep within the Appalachian Mountains in Virginia, lying adjacent to quiet streams, hiding in the shade of large oak trees. Distillers did not need to be an expert in their craft, and most were not, but all were able to follow a very specific process that turned rye, apples, plums, or apricots into a clear, potent, highly valuable liquid called moonshine. Moonshiners, as they were called, became notorious for ruling the “hollers” – a colloquial name given to the small, high-elevation valleys that are scattered throughout this mountainous region.
While distilling in the hollers during Prohibition may not be romanticized in the cultural canon, these moonshiners were innovators. They rose to meet a demand and produced a product that was enjoyed by many, putting Appalachian Virginia on the map. Unfortunately for these moonshiners, when President Roosevelt signed the 21st Amendment into law, their product became old-fashioned and their livelihoods were derelict. Their legacy, however, remains.
The seductions of drink are wound deep within this region. Which may explain why, over 90 years later, when Adam Shifflett was imagining what he wanted to do with his life, the thought of opening a brewery appealed to him. Shifflett, however, is an ex-Navy nuclear submarine engineer, who has a degree in mechanical engineering and experience in strategic operations and military command. Perfect qualifications for a brew-scientist and champion of craft beer? Probably not, but over the past year Shifflett has grown Three Brothers Brewing Company into one of the most popular craft breweries in Virginia, carrying impressive clout within the region and has won numerous awards for his fine ales and lagers.
Growth of a beer town
The City of Harrisonburg has a rich and interesting history dating back to before the Civil War. It was established by a group of ex-slaves in 1892 and has grown organically over the years to become one of the largest urban centers in a predominantly agricultural region of the Shenandoah Valley. During prohibition the bootleggers used the city as a hub to move their product, and while times have changed, the ability to drink booze here has not. But moonshine is no longer the drink of choice, and it is not being consumed illegally. Harrisonburg is experiencing the rise of another, more delicious liquid in the valley: craft beer.
With the short-lived success of Calhoun’s Brewing Company, which operated in Harrisonburg from 1998–2010, to use as a case study, Adam Shifflett dove in headfirst. “We’ve always wanted to do a brew pub or craft bar, and I started to get into home brewing when I was still in the Navy,” Shifflett says, in a light Southern accent, “once I started communicating with other local brewers, however, I discovered that I really wanted to do the production side of things and focus less on a restaurant.” Shifflett’s brewery, named appropriately for the three brothers who help run the company, evolved out of a passion for the area and an interest in the business.
Get Chris Hurlbert’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
“We received a lot of initial support, and it showed that the community was willing to stand behind us,” says Shifflett. The infrastructure to support a local brewery was in place before Three Brothers moved in, and they have capitalized on the growing demand for craft beer in Virginia. “Harrisonburg is a fantastic beer town because of the synergy between all the different arms of the beer business. There is a lot of interaction between our brewery and the restaurants in the area.”
Restaurant owners in town have been extremely supportive to help spread the word on his new operation, and according to Adam Brennis, General Manager at Capital Alehouse in downtown Harrisonburg, keeping product behind the bar is nearly impossible. “Three Brothers has really taken off since they brewed their first beer back in December 2012,” Brennis says. “Most of that is due to the quality of the beer they put out, but it also speaks to the beer drinkers here in town.”
As a restaurant manager, Brennis sees how craft beer is consumed every single day. “The people here are great, always thirsty for new product and always looking for the best. They’re not looking for just anything.” Beyond his nine-to-five job Brennis is also a homebrewer, and has a particular affinity for the audacity of Shifflett and Three Brothers Brewing. “I look up to these guys because they strive to be the best that they absolutely can. Brewing beer is an art form, and the guys here, doing it now, are truly artists.”
Always innovating
If beer is the canvas for art, what are the strokes? Adam Shifflett argues that ingredients are key in the production of quality product, so for him, fresh pumpkin, roasted malts, oily hops, and festering yeast are the paint to his masterpiece. “It’s impossible to say that you’re making a great quality craft pumpkin ale when you’re releasing it with last years pumpkin puree or pumpkin extract. The only thing that’s keeping craft brewers from releasing their pumpkin ale after pumpkins are out is trying to beat the rush, which goes against the grain of what craft beer is truly about,” says Shifflett.
Fresh ingredients make Three Brothers Brewing Company stand out in terms of quality, but what exactly makes them innovative? In order to break through the clutter in the craft beer world, Shifflett’s team recently purchased a 1-barrel pilot system to test some obscure and experimental recipes. “We’re going to start running a series of small batches released into 750ml corked and caged bottles, lots of sours and wild ales. We have over 50 barrels aging right now, with everything from imperial stouts to Belgian styles, laying in wine, rum, bourbon, and even tequila barrels. We’ve got some other stuff that’s full of Brett, Lacto and Pedo aging in a separate room also – just trying to test the limits here.”
Shifflett’s innovation is paying off, as he recently won a bronze medal for his Rum Barrel Belgian Dubbel at the Great American Beer Festival, one of the most prestigious award galas in the industry. This victory was also a remarkable achievement for a brewery that hasn’t even been in operation for more than one year. He has won various other awards for craft beer in Virginia, including a gold medal for his flagship IPA, The Admiral.
Future of craft beer
According to Shifflett, the greatest defining quality of craft beer from any brewery is freshness of product, which differentiates his beer from the competition, most of which has to travel across the state or even the country to reach Harrisonburg tavern heads. “Those guys down in Richmond really have one of the best IPAs in the country right now, and have a huge leg up against most of the California breweries when you get down to it due to freshness of product. Similarly, we have a leg up in this area because of freshness of product.”
If people want fresh beer, it makes sense that they also want consistent beer, which is another industry trend Shifflett is passionate about. With his background in engineering and quality control, and his brother’s background in biology, they truly understand the brewing process, and it shows in their beer. “We’re doing everything we can do to make sure that the people purchasing Three Brothers Beer are getting what they expect: a true and reliable flavor.”
The future of this industry is also going green. Breweries like Sierra Nevada in California, who recently installed 10,000 solar panels on their property, are on the forefront of this trend. While Three Brothers Brewery definitely doesn’t have the budget for solar panels just yet, Shifflett’s mind is in the right place. “Local is a trend. People are looking for ways to be green. Is shipping a 140-pound keg in refrigerated trucks across the country green? No, not at all, you’re using up huge amounts of gas and energy. People want to talk local for supporting local economies. Is any of the money spent on west coast beer going to the local community? No. Retailers that carry local product are helping the local community.”
With the locals close to his heart, Shifflett truly embodies the spirit of a craft brewer. His innovative ways and entrepreneurial spirit liken him to the moonshiners of yesteryear, but he doesn’t have to hide in mountain hollers, working at his craft deep into the night with the threat of jail time looming over his shoulder. “We shouldn’t ever settle for the way things are going. Not now, not in the past, and not in the future,” Shifflett says as he stands; ready to shake up the world of craft beer. By helping Harrisonburg win the title of best beer town in the Blue Ridge Mountains, Three Brother’s Brewery has gained tremendous respect. Where Shifflett will take his brewery and the industry in 2014 no one knows, but it will be fun to observe – hopefully while enjoying a beer or two on the side.






