Sitemap
Gary Stein

Gary Stein

Brand Strategy

Storylines. Not Taglines

A Guide to Branding in the Digital Age [part 1]

6 min readJul 25, 2014

part 1: the unstoppable pace of innovation (with the exception of the early 80s when things actually slowed down just a bit)

February 5th, 2013 was a busy day down at the old United States Patent and Trademark Office.

On that particular day (a Tuesday), the USPTO issued 6058 patents. Some of them are pretty interesting, actually, and make decent reading. Take, for example, one that went to John Troyer of Oroville Ohio for a new game feeder. The idea behind the invention is that a hunter loads the feeder up with several days worth of food, which is then released at regular intervals. From the patent application:

The feeder may not only allow a hunter to dispense various types of feed, such as apples, ear corn, and grain, but the feeder may dispense feed automatically over a period of days. This may encourage animals such as deer to feed in the same general area. In turn, this may allow for hunting that is more bountiful.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
A sketch of John Troyer’s game feeder, US Patent number RE43953. Deer: please be aware.

Other patents granted that day include an energy storage system for hybrid vehicles, a new kind of strawberry plant (called a DrisStrawTwentyfour, which promises large fruit of medium sweetness), an app for increasing typing speed, a new ornamental trash can, and something called a “Method and apparatus for modifying aircraft simulator wide-angled infinity display equipment mirror to enlarge field of vision and for reskinning aircraft simulation spherical mirror cell to minimize mirror stress and distortion.”

I read through the list of stuff from February 5th and thought “man this is a lot of stuff”. But really, that was pretty much business as usual for the USPTO, which has been on a tear lately, issuing an ever growing number of patents. 2013 was another record breaking year, with 133,593 patents granted. Put another way, that’s an average of 366 patents grated every day.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Every year, since the mid-1990s, the USPTO has granted a new “record number of patents” (SOURCE: USPTO data)

That’s a lot of new. The graph above shows the count of new “utility patents” that have been granted each year, since 1963. Per the the official definition from the USPTO, a utility patent is:

…issued for the invention of a new and useful process, machine, manufacture or composition of matter or a new and useful improvement thereof.

Think about this: every year, for the past many years, an increasing number of people and organizations have come up with either a new thing to offer the world (like John Troyer’s game feeder) or an improvement to an existing thing, already in the world (like the new strawberry plant). Over the last 20 years, there has been a 250% increase in the number of new or improved ideas there are in the world(1).

Get Gary Stein’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

But that has not always been the case. While it certainly feels like there has been a constant and steady stream of innovation—and America is certainly the place where things seem to always be getting faster and more advanced—that hasn’t been true all the way through the last 50 or so years. In fact, take a closer look at that chart. See that little dip in our progress? Right around the early 1980s?

Press enter or click to view image in full size
what’s up 1983?

Only 32,871 patents were granted in 1983. A decade before (1973), the USPTO granted over 51,000 patents, and two years before that, they granted a (then) record 55,976 patents. The most interesting about this chart is that it doesn’t seem to conform the model that we have come to expect, especially when it comes to new technologies and invention. Look at any other graph and over time, there is a steady uphill slope of adoption and growth. Often there is a sharp increase, like in the the number of computers or tablets or smartphones in the world.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
ooh..growth.

It’s tempting to think that the reason for this dip is because the government was locked up. Or, alternatively, that the USPTO got really efficient from the late 80s on and started processing a bunch of patent applications. But, in order for the drop in patents granted to be the fault of an inefficient government, we would have to expect there to be a steady rise in patent applications, but a drop in patent grants, and that’s just not the case.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
A slow and steady slowdown in patent applications and grants (SOURCE: USPTO data)

All through the seventies and early eighties, there was a decline in both patent grants and applications. The USPTO was granting fewer patents because they had fewer applications to consider. Invention and innovation was just, simply, slowing down(2).

The fact is early 1980s were a fairly difficult time for US businesses and the economy in general. The country was in a recession, for sure, but one marked by instability. One year the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) would be way up; the next way down. Over time, economists have come to refer to this time as being a “W-Shaped Recession” because of the way fortunes peaked and bottomed out. You can imagine how business managers and owners (and stockholders) felt. They had no idea what to expect next, whether relief was just around the corner, or if the good times were going to last.

Tracking the GDP of the 70s/80s recession. The peaks and valleys have given this era the moniker of the “W Shaped Recession”. W, as in “WTF?!” (SOURCE: Wikipedia)

To make things even worse, unemployment was at levels not seen since the Great Depression; going into 1983, unemployment peaked at over 10%. Mixed with high inflation and you can imagine that things were pretty grim, especially in industries like automotive, housing and manufacturing.

Patents were down during the 1980s, true. But that was only one piece of what was a essentially a crappy business environment. Eventually, something had to be done. Well, a bunch of things had to be done. From our perspective, thirty years on, we recognize that some significant changes had to come, to how business was done, that would get the economy moving and growing again.

And, a lot of things were done. There were changes in interest rates and taxes. Some of these changes were fairly short term. Changes were made and we moved on. But some things were done that—although no one realized it at the time—actually sparked a really fundamental change in the way that business worked and how the world thought about making stuff.

One of those changes was the response to The Machine Tool Crisis of 1983.

…next up: the What Crisis of When?

(1) Before we go too much farther, we should address two big elephants in the patent world: trolls and marketed products. This is a big issue and one that, if you are paying attention to the world of technology (and software in particular), is keenly on your mind. An increasing number of patents are applied for and granted specifically so that someone can sue other people who are actually making stuff. This isn’t really the right forum to discuss this issue, but let’s just say—for the sake of argument that the number of patents granted to trolls is 40% (which happens to be the best estimate of the percentage of patent litigation that is troll-based). That would still allow for a significant increase in the number of patents granted, which—as stated above—has risen over 250% over the last 20 years. So, if we were to somehow magically find and remove all the troll-motivated patent applications/grants, the point would still remain the same: there is more new stuff coming into the world than ever before.

(2) By the way, we do need to remember that a the patents applied for in a particular year are not necessarily granted in the same year. In fact, it generally takes a few years for an application to be granted, due to all the steps necessary and, of course, disputes and challenges and backlog. But you can clearly see that the two lines of applications and grants are correlated.

--

--