Anyone who has ever managed anyone (or anything) should spend an hour this week thinking about Matt Williams
I am a Matt Williams fan. I watched him many times in Candlestick Park—including Game 4 of the World Series (the one that was rescheduled, due to the earthquake). A few years ago, my family and I were in San Diego and we went to see the Padres play the Diamondbacks. We got seats low down, near third base, just so I could watch Williams coach in that spot. I even wore my Giants hat and yelled out to him. He saw me (and my hat) and gave me the thumbs up. Really!
I watched nearly all of the game this last Saturday and have to admit that as much as I was desperate for another Giants win, I was enjoying the opportunity to see Williams coach in his first post-season series.
If you didn’t watch it: it was an unexpected marathon. The game was extremely tight for nearly nine innings. Well, tight, but with the ever-so-slight advantage toward the Nationals. Jordan Zimmerman, the starting pitcher was just confounding the Giants. They couldn’t get much of anything. Then, with just one out left for the Nats, Zimmerman walked Brandon Belt, and had to face Buster Posey, an imposing hitter. The tying run on first, former MVP up to bat, a 100 pitches in your ace and one out to go.
Matt Williams made the decision to pull the pitcher and put in a closer. Evidently, that was always the plan, should they get into trouble at a key moment. The closer then gave up another hit and a double. Giants tied (and very nearly won) the game, sending it into another 9 innings, resulting in a Giants home run and a win for the visitors.
The baseball world is filled today with second guesses, debate and (on the National’s fan-side) flat out anger. Should he have taken out the pitcher? Why did he take out the pitcher? Why did he put that reliever in? Why did he leave that reliever in? Why—dear Baseball Gods—why?!
I don’t pretend to have a real bead on the baseball side of this. Baseball is a complex game and it’s hard to pick out a single decision—momentous though it may be—and tell a whole narrative around it. But there is something that everyone who has ever been in charge of a group of people trying to do a thing (ie: a team) should understand and learn from Matt’s decision: you gotta listen to your team.
Get Gary Stein’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
I’ve actually been reading a lot of comments, especially from Nationals fans, about that Game 2, and there’s one thing that keeps coming up. Yes, they are shocked at the loss, and yes they are pissed that Williams took Zimmerman out. But more than anything else, there is one action (or, rather, inaction) that people are out-of-their minds frustrated about: Williams didn’t check in with Zimmerman first.
Here, check out this comment from an article on the Washington Post:
If Williams first walked out to the mound (that is, sent his pitching coach to the mound), I think fans would feel a slight bit better about this loss. The fact is, Zimmerman was killing it for the Nationals. Yes, he was in a tough spot. But great people get into tough spots. In fact, the existence of tough spots is why you have great people on your team in the first place.
Now, I would assume that the coach would have gone to the mound and asked “Zimmerman, you OK?” and Zimmerman, being a pro, would say “Hell yes”. But that is also a chance to listen to his voice, see his eyes and have a moment of connection with the person who you have put your trust in to take you through.
Maybe Zimmerman would have then proceeded to hang a curve and that would have been that. But I think everyone would have felt better about that outcome: you stick with someone you trust and you let him do his job.
Matt Williams—you are a baseball star. But on Saturday night, you blew it. A lot of fans (including this one) chalk this up to Williams being a rookie manager. Rookies tend to think that they must act. Veterans know that, often, they must listen.
-Gary Stein







