Sitemap
Stop trying so hard.

Hedonism: You’re Doing it Wrong.

--

Without a proper introduction to hedonism, we might live out our lives without benefiting from some of the most refreshingly honest and profoundly valuable ideas regarding how to lead an ethical life. How? Through seeking to understand how we are to maximize our experience of pleasure.

Endowed by Our Creator

In 1776, when crafting the United States Declaration of Independence, the authors wrote into its preamble their best interpretation of the rationale for separating from England:

When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness…

An “Unalienable Right”

As it is apparent, the Declaration of Independence submits the pursuit of happiness (endowed by life and enabled by liberty) as a justification for the war. The revolutionary text articulates a radical political system not regulated by obedience to any arbitrarily granted authority or humility before any god but by an ethic powered by the happiness-seeking desires of each citizen.

Hedonism

‘Happiness’ From Wikipedia:

Happiness is a mental or emotional state of well-being characterized by positive or pleasant emotions ranging from contentment to intense joy.

‘Hedonism’ from Wikipedia:

Hedonism is a school of thought that argues that pleasure is the primary or most important intrinsic good. In very simple terms, a hedonist strives to maximize net pleasure (pleasure minus pain)… Ethical hedonism is the idea that all people have the right to do everything in their power to achieve the greatest amount of pleasure possible to them, assuming that their actions do not infringe on the equal rights of others.

Ergo, the Declaration of Independence is a Hedonist manifesto.

Determinism

Over millennia, human cultures have evolved and branched into a wide variety across the Earth’s dynamic surface. As life forms developed in structure or function — adapting to their climate, availability of resources, geographic isolation, neighboring populations, etc. — each culture has developed specialized organizational structures, systems, processes, and technologies of self-preservation and multiplication.

Unlike the ethic outlined in The Declaration of Independence, many of the world’s organizational systems have enforced the suppression of our pleasures for the benefit of the group. But is the tension between our individual experiences of joy and the greater good necessarily a zero-sum game?

Hedonists say “no.” If we cannot maximize an individual’s experience of happiness, how can we maximize the world’s happiness?

Happiness is not something given to us but is something that we develop within ourselves, and each of us needs freedom (and therefore should not impinge on the freedom of others) to create a happier world.

What Gives Us Pleasure?

Even after a fulfilling meal, after overindulging in the desert, our desire can transform into physical pain. We might regret when the mirror reveals our choices. We may first find delight in the company of another that — after spending more time with them — has a similar effect. We may splurge shop and a month later find ourselves asking, ‘why did I waste my money on this?!’

We buy shit we don’t need, with money we don’t have, to impress people we don’t like. — George Carlin

Brain Candy

Serotonin, endorphins, testosterone, estrogen… there are a bunch of chemicals produced by the body to regulate our metabolism and mood, but — since our prime interest is (as it should be) pleasure — we’re going to want to focus on dopamine.

Dopamine is the happy hormone. The release of this neurotransmitter is triggered when we fulfill our thirst or hunger, taste something sweet, take a dump, have an orgasm, etc. In a nutshell, it’s a signaling hormone that reinforces behaviors necessary for survival and reproduction.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
image source: Clayman: The Primitive Brain

The “Pleasure Center”

No, it’s not an adult superstore…

The mechanics of how dopamine simultaneously facilitates our experience of pleasure and shapes our behavior are profound but also incredibly simple. You see, there’s this primitive little transmission system (shared by all mammals) within the brain:

  1. The limbic system (pictured here) is responsible for most of our instinctual (emotion-based) behavior. It is the driving force of the pleasure center.
  2. The brain’s pleasure center’s primary function is to help us learn necessary skills. How? When a release of dopamine has triggered, a feeling of pleasure is ‘turned on’, reinforcing those behaviors that lead us to the on switch (e.g., foraging for food, mating, catching prey, etc.). This feedback loop awakens and strengthens our instincts, giving us the curiosity to try new things and the desire to develop skills in attaining the things that make us happy.
  3. Dopamine is translated into pleasure by receptors within the brain’s pleasure center. Soon after experiencing something exciting, the work of translating dopamine into pleasure will ‘fatigue’ the receptors. If not given enough time to rest between doses, the next helping of dopamine will feel less pleasurable than the previous, preventing the second slice of cake from giving us the same amount of pleasure as the first. This fatigue is also known as developing a ‘tolerance.’

Whenever a thing is done for the first time, it releases a little demon.
— Emily Dickinson

Remember your first kiss? Ever wonder why the first time you did something new that you found exciting/pleasurable, you formed a strongly associated memory that you’ve carried with you since?

When we experience something extraordinarily pleasurable, our brains effectively record a high-resolution, multidimensional snapshot of our senses: what we smell, see, hear, touch, and taste. The evolutionary functionality of this allows us to spontaneously identify circumstances in the future that seem familiar to that memory so we can modify our behavior and increase our chances of reliving the ‘high.’ This recording is called a trigger and the sense of opportunity: intuition.

Food for thought:

  • Identify your dopamine triggers as such.
  • Prepare when you can predict experiencing those triggers to add sophistication to your automatic response.

Appetites

Along these same lines, as we mature, we find that the things that gave us pleasure when we were younger no longer do the trick. We need new and stronger experiences to trigger our interest: robust flavors, designer shoes, travel, “sex, drugs and rock’n roll,” etc… Why?

Just as these dopamine receptors get fatigued by small pleasures, they can become worn out by extraordinarily exciting/pleasurable experiences. These effects reduce our ability to experience pleasure in general. We develop a new object of desire, all other desires taking a back seat. We’ve thus acquired a new appetite.

The appetite-building process follows our growth and development from infancy to adulthood. Roughtly speaking, these are our maturing desires in terms of appetite building:

  1. Metabolic desires (i.e., ‘needs’): security, sleep, nourishment, excretion
  2. Novelty desires: curiosity, exploration, discovery
  3. Relationship desires: companionship, inclusion, sex, communication, self-expression, community

Depending on our environment, these appetites will form in different ways. The farmer’s child is more likely to enjoy skeet shooting while his cousin in the city develops an appetite for art.

Communication

Over the past million years, as social animals, we have been developing an exceptional tool to help us work together: the ability to communicate complex ideas. Through communication, we can imagine/visualize shared information through description, instruction, and storytelling.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Rock painting at Tassili n’Ajjer, Algeria. © DPK-Photo / Alamy

Early human communication likely had the same practical purposes many animals gained from communicating. For example, they helped us call to our parents for food, alert each other of danger, and coordinate hunts for the larger and tastier game (e.g., mammoths and buffalo). Later, they helped us hand down practical technologies and methods from generation to generation.

Just as we, individually, build highly expressive vocabularies — from childhood — upon simple phonetics and words, each generation of evolving humans built a new vernacular structure on the work of the last. Early on, sentence structures would emerge, then storytelling architectures, and later, the propensity for dramatization, plot twists then background music. Stories would evolve into legends, epics, myths, folk songs, movies, etc.

As language developed, it would move from a practical means to a desirable end to an end in itself. Then, in a cultural explosion, humans would give rise to a spectacular diversity of art forms seeking to titillate the senses differently.

Informing Perceptions

Stories originally served to explain the world and perpetuate culturally encouraged behaviors. By invoking fear, stories would discourage ‘bad’ behavior. By inspiring ambition, stories would encourage and inspire model behavior (courage, honesty, chivalry, etc.).

Those early storytelling experiments have now evolved into an advanced and deliberate science. Political propaganda would replace ghost stories; advertisements would replace our desire to become heroes with a desire to buy the latest gadget.

“We are governed… largely by men we have never heard of.”

At the turn of the century, there arrived an innovator in storytelling who would take selling products and politics to a new state of the art: Edward Bernays.

Get Logan Powell’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

From Wikipedia:

Edward Louis Bernays (November 22, 1891 − March 9, 1995) was an Austrian-American pioneer in the field of public relations and propaganda, referred to in his obituary as “the father of public relations.” He combined the ideas of Gustave Le Bon and Wilfred Trotter on crowd psychology with the psychoanalytical ideas of his uncle, Sigmund Freud.

In his book Propaganda, Bernays says:

If we understand the mechanism and motives of the group mind, is it not possible to control and regiment the masses according to our will without their knowing about it? The recent practice of propaganda has proved that it is possible, at least up to a certain point and within certain limits.

He called this scientific technique of opinion molding the ‘engineering of consent.’ In his book, Bernays posits:

The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in democratic society. Those who manipulate this unseen mechanism of society constitute an invisible government which is the true ruling power of our country. We are governed, our minds are molded, our tastes formed, our ideas suggested, largely by men we have never heard of.

Bernays revolutionized the art of advertisement and propaganda. The lessons he incorporated from his uncle Freud’s toolbox (which he helped popularize in the US) into his framework remain canonical within the public relations and advertisement industry.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
The American Tobacco Company hired Edward Bernays to address the stigma surrounding women and smoking. The risky campaign proved to be a great success, and scores of women took up smoking.

“Image is Everything”

Edward Bernays understood that our natural inclination — whether we like to admit it or not — is to idealize or internalize images promoted or villainized by those we trust and that we are inclined to trust the news, which he would often leverage for his promotions.

Just as we can be triggered to climb a tree if we believe a story from a friend that there’s a tasty bundle of bananas at the top, the sight of someone slow-mo chomping into a juicy double cheeseburger compels us to haul our jiggly ass to Mickey D’s. By framing information in a certain way, we can nudge others’ behavior.

We become afraid of imaginary monsters when we see horror films as children. As adults, we see images of murder on the local news, creating a fear of our neighbors. The exploitation portrayed in pornography encourages us to approach sex partners as sex objects. Every girl’s gotta buy what the newest version of Paris Hilton is wearing. We thus accumulate unnatural fears and nurture strange desires.

This information embellishment calls for a Hedonist’s (as well as a pragmatist’s) solution and is why it’s best to steer clear of too much fiction or staged ‘reality.’ Real life is more rewarding when we approach it with realistic expectations. Not that we shouldn’t dream, but we should first seek to know ourselves, then create our dream. Don’t let someone else (especially “men we have never heard of”) determine what that dream should be.

Fun fact: Mark Bernays Randolf (Cofounder of Netflix) is Ed’s great nephew

Don’t Believe the Hype

During a trial over obfuscation of facts, Fox News asserted that, under the First Amendment, broadcasters have the right to lie or deliberately distort news reports. Given this and other cases of misuse of such power, we must be careful when receiving information from religiously, politically, or commercially motivated gatekeepers.

Food for thought:

  • By looking for ‘clean’ information (from reputable sources), we are more likely to react appropriately to the world and — thereby in our OWN best interests.

Looking for Love in All the Wrong Places

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Epicurus (Greek: Ἐπίκουρος, “ally, comrade”; 341–270 BC)

One of the pioneers of hedonism, Epicurus, strongly criticized advertisement’s rudimentary forms. Even in the 4th century BC ancient Greece, Epicurus saw the destructive potential of advertising in its early stages, attempting to take advantage of our pleasure-seeking brains by promising us one or more of the three things that we need to be happy: an analyzed life, freedom, and friends (sound familiar?). He felt so strongly against advertising that he proposed counter-advertisements (imagine a billboard showing an obese couch potatoe next to a double cheeseburger) as an ‘antidote.’

In another triad, Epicurus categorized three types of desire:

  1. Natural and necessary desires: food, clothing, shelter, etc.
  2. Natural but unnecessary desires: luxury items. Epicurus was a vegetarian and practiced mild asceticism.
  3. “Vain and empty” desires: power, wealth, fame, etc. These are difficult to satisfy because they have no natural limit.

In a similar approach to life that the Buddhists teach, the Hedonist Epicurus encouraged the elimination of pain caused by the last two types of desires to attain tranquility and maximum pleasure. He relished simple pleasures every day, and — he argued — this was the way to happiness. How do we appreciate life in this way?

To maximize our pleasure, we must actively engage in those of our behaviors that prove ultimately pleasurable (more pleasure returned than pain cost/invested). If we are thus constantly engaged, all of our waking hours will give rise to satisfaction. Yet, knowing what we find ultimately pleasurable is not so straightforward.

No Pain, No Gain

We either pay for pleasure before or after we benefit from the experience. For example, going for that morning run is not pleasurable (for most), nor is getting out of bed an hour early to do it, but it pays off in having more vitality/energy the rest of the day (note: I don’t run, I hate running, but I’ve done it a couple of times… and that’s basically how it went). When taking drugs, lying, or stealing, it’s the opposite payoff sequence; we get the pleasure immediately and pay for it afterward.

Jordan Belfort: Before

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Many addicts will tell you they feel like they have a hole inside them, one that can only be filled by their habit. More often than not, these ‘negative’ (enjoy first, pay later) pleasures of debt are not ‘fixing’ their pain but are exacerbating it.

When faced with a suspicious desire, the appropriate Hedonist questions to ask yourself is “is this worth the trouble?” and — as a Hedonist — if we estimate the aftermath of the pleasure will amount to more pain than it’s worth, the answer to the question should be a definite ‘No.’ You may be saying to yourself “Yeah Logan, but there are a bunch of things I enjoy now that I didn’t really want to do before I tried them.” My only response would be you also don’t know how happy you would be now if you hadn’t tried them.

So, how can we choose the behavior that will maximize our pleasure? Unlike the objective world, enjoyment varies subjectively from person to person. But, we can still discuss the subjective nature of happiness productively if we understand that anything that will bring us enduring happiness/pleasure will require effort.

Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi: Flow, the secret to happiness on TED

Mihály Csíkszentmihályi wrote a book about what he calls ‘flow.’ In a nutshell, one achieves flow when one — who is practicing a skill they enjoy — experiences when the challenge is just above their current ability. This practice enables them — with just a bit more effort than before — to succeed in meeting the challenge. Flow is what we feel when participating in addictive and healthy behavior. Just as we can build appetites for consumption, we can also build cravings for performing an activity.

It’s important to remember that the goal has to be almost within reach, just as Epicurus knew 2400 years ago; if we find that we desire more than we can attain, we will always find ourselves wanting. Improvement is a rewarding but slow process and should be enjoyed one step at a time.

Food for thought:

  • The lesson is not to compare ourselves to ideals but to ourselves yesterday. So what can you add to the formula you used yesterday to improve your experience today?
  • Find your zone.

Learning How to Practice

Learning is the only higher pleasure we are left with after our primitive needs are satisfied. However, learning how to learn is something we don’t learn in school. Therefore, it’s a personal skill we must pick up along the way. We must take this on ourselves because it is a very private matter and, therefore, challenging to teach.

For some, operating within the enigmatic flywheel of pleasure and pain can be confusing, discombobulating. Getting to know ourselves and what activities/behaviors will give us maximum pleasure takes time, and it’s a challenge in and of itself because our surroundings change. In addition, we change (we grow up, go through puberty, moods, hormone imbalances, etc.). But, there are ways we can enhance our everyday pleasurable experiences through practice.

What does almost every religion on Earth have in common? First, they all stress the importance of introspection and reflection in leading a happy life. Call it meditation or prayer; the value of this practice seems well-established. To make sense of the world and our changing place within it, we must sort out what is working for us from what is not. This sorting is how we learn and build our skills, including life.

Food for thought:

  • What motivates you? What gets you excited and why? Think about it. Try new things.
  • Find something you enjoy doing for the practice itself, not just in the hope of attaining some goal.

A quick way to tell if someone’s a liar is if they tell you they don’t regret anything. If they didn’t regret acting like an eight-year-old monkey up in that tree that they fell out of, breaking their arm, they’d be a 40-year-old banana sandwich. Regret is our most eloquent teacher. So try, fail, and regret, but think about why you failed. Just try not to regret the same thing more than once. If you got into it because you wanted to try something new, just lean in harder on that instinct. Go deep. You may find that you just tried incorrectly or you may find that you should try something else entirely.

Patience as a Pleasure

In some situations, nothing is the best thing to do: silence, patience, fortitude, non-participation, awkward pauses in a conversation. There are a number of these kinds of behaviors that many of us must deliberately practice as they are not instinctual.

The real opportunity for happiness comes from an understanding that certain types of pain can be enjoyable as they improve our capacity for pleasure. If we see the struggle as an exercise, hunger as an appetizer, and the failure as a lesson — we can improve in skill and, thereby, success/happiness now and in the future.

At the center of almost every ‘unnecessary’ or ‘unnatural’ desire, you will find a seed of impatience. Not wanting to wait for the hunger to apetize, so resort to uber-sweet, salty, or overly extravagant foods. Not wanting to spend the time earning/developing real friendships and so buying a fancy car to impress people leads us into ‘friendships’ based not on respect for the person but their possessions.

This superficial valuation leads us to believe that the meal is more important than the company with whom it’s shared. It leads us to enter partnerships without trust/respect, sex without intimacy/emotion, and obesity without nutrition.

The revered composer Claude Debussy said, “Music is the space between the notes.” Patience enables us to enjoy both the emptiness and the fullness of life, the hunger and fulfillment, the seclusion and the party, the silence, and the music. It is a skill of happy living, and we should also find a way within ourselves to enjoy the practice.

Conclusion

The way we accumulate appetites will differ between us as we go through life with less or more exposure to the various stimuli available in our environment.

The tricky part of making the right move comes not from self-denial but from radical self-awareness. If you are anything like me, you’re weak to your desires. If this is the case, you’ll struggle with them. Pleasure can be a beast, and if we don’t take the time to understand it, just as a beast, it will tear us, our families, and friendships (and, I argue, the world itself) to pieces.

If watching Sex and the City makes you want to buy something that would stress your bank account, stop watching it. If you’re tired of your kid whining that he wants McDonald’s every time he sees a commercial on his iPad, take the iPad away. If you start sleeping with strangers after the fifth drink, stop at the fourth.

Understand these choices as self-rewarding, not self-punishing. When indulging, try to savor each pleasure. Don’t multitask. Focus. Focus even on the space, the emptiness. Enjoy these moments. With the right mindset, anticipation can be a significant part of the pleasure and, when matured, makes the consummation even better.

As The Most Interesting Man in the World says:

Stay thirsty my friends.

Indeed.

--

--