Sitemap

Machiavellian Pragmatism

7 min readSep 24, 2014

--

How the greatest craft of American philosophy was hijacked.

Today, we typically employ the concept of Pragmatism in a commercial, sporting, or political context wherein the goal warrants whatever it takes to get the job done. The only redeeming quality that lingers with the term is the connotation that the employed tactics are considered efficient/effective.

‘Pragmatism’ along with ‘skepticism,’ ‘hedonism,’ ‘idealism,’ ‘materialism,’ etc., are philosophical terms, each referring to a distinctly different school of philosophy. Moreover, each word has picked up or lost meaning through the social evolution of being co-opted, translated, and interpreted over time. Unfortunately, like in the childhood game of telephone, philosophical terms can be accidentally or deliberately distorted through this grapevine.

For Pragmatism, this distortion was deliberate, disruptive, and — adding insult to injury — rendered by the philosopher’s best friend.

“The Prince” is not Pragmatic.

Nicolò Machiavelli dedicated his book ‘The Prince” to a famous Italian Medici banking family member, which outlines tactics on how he could most easily seize and maintain power from neighbors and other rulers abroad. These tactics included: brutal punishment, military occupation, revenge, and massacring entire bloodlines, but — because these were deemed efficient means to the desired end of empowering a philanthropic family (the Medicis were ‘good’ folks and all) — the treatise is sometimes described as ‘pragmatic.’

However, in stark contrast to this ‘Machiavellian’ interpretation, Pragmatic theory criticizes primarily self-centered means within its original texts. In one example, the founder of the philosophy wrote:

…the conviction of (our times) is that progress takes place by virtue of every individual’s striving for himself with all his might and trampling his neighbor underfoot whenever he gets a chance to do so. This may accurately be called the Gospel of Greed.

So, how did we get here? How did Pragmatism (with a capital P) mutate from being a rallying cry against this Gospel of Greed into its philosophical champion?

The First Book

Charles Peirce (pronounced ‘purse’) — the originator of the philosophy of Pragmatism and coiner of its name — was also a founding member of a tiny social club in Cambridge, MA, of what would become a group of highly influential American thinkers. Of the group, he was the most arrogant, caustic, haunted, and brilliant.

However, Peirce was not the author of the first book to bear Pragmatism’s name. In 1907, as Plato did for Socrates (and some would say with a similar suspect), his colleague and best friend, William James, published it.

(Peirce: left, James: right) source: New York Review of Books

James’ book would help to solidify Pragmatism as the most important American contribution to the philosophy that it remains today, and we might thank him for this. However, James’ subtle but profound spin on Peirce’s philosophy would strain this friendship until its end.

The Proof is in the Pudding

Starting with where James and Peirce agree, all “Pragmatists” argue that there is no absolute truth. ‘Truth’ is a belief that is strong enough to ‘fix’ one’s behavior in a particular situation. And as even deliberate, rational behavior varies from person to person when dealing with the same situation, so do their versions of the truth. The Pragmatists posit that our actions show what we really believe is true.

Two Sides of the Same Coin

Heads or Tails?

Though multiple people might experience the same situation, their version of the ‘truth’ of the matter will vary — to a greater or lesser degree — not because they saw different things but because they saw the same thing differently. There are two levels to this:

  1. People differ in various ways, for example, their sensory abilities/disabilities, cultural, personal, and professional prejudices, previous experiences, physical proximity to specific events/objects, etc.
  2. Our concerns differ because of this variety, which focuses us on different aspects of our experience, taking different lessons away from a situation into our version of the ‘truth.’

The Pragmatic Maxim

For the most part, we can understand this. But, of course, we are different and don’t see eye-to-eye on everything (ok… on anything). But why do these personal differences affect the way we see things? Peirce drilled down into this but tried to summarize his ideas using a Maxim:

Consider what effects, that might conceivably have practical bearings, we conceive the object of our conception to have. Then, our conception of these effects is the whole of our conception of the object.

My quick and dirty translation:

Get Logan Powell’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

You see things the way you think you might find them useful.

Accordingly, the structure within Peirce’s Pragmatism that caused James’ desire to alter it was their version of what they regarded as truth. Though both felt reality and truth as a “social construct.” However, Peirce’s truth required statistical evidence of unbiased/sound data, whereas James’ encouraged a man’s “true” beliefs. James was a diplomat, Peirce a rigorous scientist. To James, faith served the same purpose for Christians as statistics/data served to give a scientist: confidence.

James had good intentions in changing Peirce’s philosophy this way; sensing its potential, he wanted to open Peirce’s unrelentingly scientific doctrine to people of faith (in those days — much as it is now — many people of influence). His formula was lucrative. By loosening this constraint, Pragmatism rocketed into the American and international mainstream consciousness. Still, this small rider that would deliver it to the aristocracy would later sell it out to the vernacular shit-stack.

Do you get your pleasure from truth or truth from pleasure?

James: Truth by Circumstantial Confidence

The individual is at the center, surrounded by experientially contextualized truths.

According to James, ‘true’ is a term for whatever proves itself to be good in the way of belief and good for definite assignable reasons. It enables one to justify means if the ends are ‘virtuous’ and productive in improving one’s circumstances. This interpretation is selfish.

Peirce: Truth by Probabilistic Confidence

The truth is at the center, surrounded by different individuals’ experiences of it.

To get closer to the truth himself, Peirce — one of the founders of the field of statistics — introduced the terms confidence and likelihood to the field. It is a social construct in universal terms. This interpretation is selfless.

This difference in formulation — boiling down to Peirce’s version of social as universal, whereas James’ version being scoped to a special interest — was so great in Peirce’s view that it later prompted him to coin a new term, Pragmaticism (much less well-known, due to it being “too ugly to kidnap”), to differentiate his distinct conveyance.

Straight Dope Pragmatism

As a patron at a nice restaurant, it’s considered bad form to add spice to a dish before tasting it. So we have salt and pepper on the table (usually) to suit our taste, but it is considered good mannered to first try the dish as prepared before knowing how much, if any, of either is required.

Imagine a chef who prepares a dish for a customer. The customer then adds their own spices and gives the leftovers to their friend, who nukes it days later, adding Tabasco to make up for the freezer burn. Of course, everyone thought they were making the dish better by altering it, but — in the end — this dish does not represent the chef’s intention, and he shouldn’t get a bum rap if this hyper-spiced, soggy, scalding hot concoction burns your butthole.

Likewise, now consider a philosopher who — with meticulous detail — lays out his thoughtful discourse to a group of his peers. One of his peers adds his flavor to it and then gives you a taste. The point is before you judge the philosophy, try its original recipe.

So What?

So, if reality and truth are not absolute or definite but somewhat impacted by the perspectives of the individual, how are we supposed to know what we should do?

Even without absolute truth, there is a ‘mostly correct’ answer. That answer is the one ‘agreed upon by all who investigate.’ Peirce argues:

The opinion which is fated to be ultimately agreed to by all who investigate, is what we mean by the truth, and the object represented in this opinion is the real.

On that note:

  • Do your very best to gather clean data and sound evidence.
  • Beware of counterfeit evidence: liars, counter-intelligent media/publications, propaganda (in all its fancy forms), flattery, advertisements, biased data, “fake news,” etc.
  • If you hear a term that ends in “ism”, find out what it means before using it. This is not only sound advice about philosophical, but any terms.

Pragmatism is the most significant American contribution to philosophy.

--

--