Sitemap
Vasiliy Shikhachevskiy

Vasiliy Shikhachevskiy

i am a human!

Buzzer beater

6 min readFeb 13, 2017

--

Visualized history of clutch shots in NBA playoffs from 2001 to 2016, based on data from www.basketball-reference.com

Press enter or click to view image in full size
2013 NBA Finals, Game 6, Ray Allen scores 3-pointer which sends a game into an overtime

Boston, February 5, 2017. The game between LA Clippers and Boston Celtics will be remembered for a beautiful farewell scene. Paul Pierce (Clippers), who spent most of his career with Celtics, with whom he won the 2008 NBA championship and finals MVP award, plans to retire after the 2016–17 season. His appearance as a player at the TD Garden (home arena for Celtics) probably was the last one.

It inspired a lot of discussions over the internet, with many users agree that Pierce was a great clutch player, with memorable shots made in the last seconds of the game. Many of those discussions turned into a quarrels about…

Who was the best clutch player of all time?

Sure, there’s a lot of ratings like this one http://uproxx.com/dimemag/nba-most-clutch but it seems no one looked at the numbers yet. Users of reddit brought up some interesting data, but still without a whole picture. So i tried to do that with the help of Basketball-reference.com.

A few words on the data and methods. First of all i decided to limit the data by the games in playoff. Probably it’s harder to shoot if you know that miss means a higher chance of elimination from the series. Pressure must be real!

Here’s what’s the data contains: all shot attempts (including missed ones) fired in the last 10 seconds of the 4-th quarter or in the overtime in the NBA playoffs from 2001 to 2016 when the difference in points between the teams was 3 points or less.

in other words: all shots, that could have turned a loosing or tied game into a winning one or send it into an overtime.

Basketball-reference has a great database but it’s limited with 2001–2016. And that’s one of the reasons why you shouldn’t take this research very seriously. By now you should be saying something like: Man, you’re talking about clutch and you don’t have Jordan? Is it a joke? That’s true, no MJ down here. But the last 15 years in NBA weren’t that bad, give it a chance.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
1998 NBA Finals, Game 6, with 5 seconds left, Michael Jordan scores 2 points, winning his 6-th championship and 6-th finals MVP award (foto from http://history.bulls.com)

The idea itself is another reason — honestly, i don’t believe any statistics could describe or predict the ways how people would act under pressure in sports. That’s why we love those moments — they are unpredictable! Think of this as of a practice of working with data, and, please, don’t judge too harshly.

1. Player

There are multiple ways to consider who the best player is. Maybe the one who gets into such situations most of all? This could mean that his coach and his teammates have faith in him. Or he is just very selfish:)

We’ll be looking at different parameters, but anyway, keep in mind, that some great players just weren’t lucky enough to be in the right team at the right time (which means: in playoff). Otherwise, i’m pretty sure, Chris Paul, Tracy McGrady and Vince Carter would be a lot higher places in all of the lists — all of them have 2 successful attempts from total of 4.

There were 194 players overall, but for the final section i chose all players with at least 5 attempts.

The King (James) is definitely worthy his nickname, leading in both major lists: attempts and successful attempts. With a pretty good efficiency rate, i might add!

2013 NBA Eastern Conference Finals, Game 1, LeBron James scores 2 points in the overtime

Kevin Durant is not very successful in such moments, but team has a lot of faith in him. Anyway, KD is an amazing player, no doubts, he is one of the best of his generation. Even Jordan picks him over James and Bryant :)

Robert Horry, Reggie Miller and Ray Allen are the only players with efficiency rate no less 50% and at least 5 attempts. Horry is a 7-time NBA champion (more than MJ), while Allen and Miller are sitting at the top of the NBA all time 3-Pt Field Goals list. I’m not suggesting anything, but…

2002 NBA Eastern Conference First Round, Game 5, Reggie Miller sends game to an overtime

Allen also holds record for attempts while playing for different teams (4): Miami, Boston, Seattle, Milwaukee, making at least one successful attempt with all of them except Seattle. Probably, he should be considered the best in terms of efficiency.

2013 NBA Finals, Game 6, Ray Allen scores 3-pointer which sends a game into an overtime

Jason Terry has the lowest efficiency rate. He missed 6 attempts in 5 different games, against 4 different teams, in 3 different seasons,and his team (Dallas) lost all of this games. That doesn’t mean he is a bad player. 2011 NBA Champion, Terry is the 3-rd on NBA’s all time 3-Pt Field Goals list.

Get Vasiliy Shikhachevskiy’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

That’s another thing to be noticed: there’s very little connection between player’s efficiency and number of wins. You could miss all of your chances and still win the game (in the overtime).

2. Team

This is the most fun part, cause here you can make some connections between games, attempts and a chance to win.

The most interesting here is difference between the games where the team had an attempts and the games, where the team was only defending without trying to shoot. I’ve concealed the number of games without attempt because of lack of space, but for most teams it varies from 50% to 75% of games with attempts.

The median of wins in the games with attempts is 30%, and 85% in the games without attempts.

No doubts down here: defense is way better than attack when we’re talking a clutch game.

Lakers are leading in efficiency and wins, among top-10 (by attempts) teams. That’s fun because Kobe (whose 18 attempts helped Lakers to get into this top-10) is bad in terms of efficiency.

2002 NBA Western Conference Semifinals, Game 4, last minutes of the game

My favorite observation is Minnesota Timberwolves. 0% efficiency (only 1 attempt) and incredible 100% combined win rate. They had only 4 clutch games in total, but anyway, this is fun :)

3. Position*

This was a painful part: i had to fill all of the position data manually. *Some players have multiple positions in their profile, all of it was counted.

You can see that there’s no big difference in efficiency in terms of player’s position. Guards and forwards rarely get the ball in the clutch moments. Shooting guards and power forwards have a little better chance to score.

In other words, if somehow i’d turn up being on the GSW team having the ball, time would be running low and we’ll be needing a shot that would bring us victory or at least would put a game into an overtime… choosing between Steph Curry and Kevin Durant i’d pass the ball to Klay Thompson.

4. Conclusion

  • Basketball-reference.com has a great database.
  • Ray Allen is the man.
  • Good defense is a key to win in a clutch game.
  • Eastern conference has a better (+3%) rate of wins >_<
  • Don’t trust the conclusions based on the insufficient data!

As i told before, this research has very little scientific use. Not only because of small amount of data, but also because some things do not need a scientific explanation. But i think, main idea of this editorial is that data can tell the story! Or at least can give users some break in between of watching youtube videos :) Look here, what a drama!

2013 NBA Easter Conference First round, Game 4, Chicago won the game 142–134 in the 3-rd overtime. This date (27.04.2013) also holds multiple records: for the most attempts in a single day (9) — 1 other attempt were made in the game between Houston and Oklahoma, for the most attempts in a single match (8) and for the most missed attempts in a single match.

I didn’t want to harm anyone’s feelings, and i apologize if you found any mistakes in this research. Peace, love, basketball.

2009 NBA Easter Conference First Round, Game 5, Paul pierce scores a game winning 2-pointer

--

--