Sitemap
CodeWithLuv

This is literally to show people I know what I’m doing (kinda). I guess you could say I’m putting the luv in CodeWithLuv

The Crud-ity of Data

6 min readOct 15, 2019

--

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Hi, hello. It’s me, again.

I went on a date the other day, and I got told something that confused me. The girl said she couldn’t get a “read” on me. I don’t consider myself an enigma in any way, but that baffled me. What do people want to know about me? I’m beginning to believe that companies may have a better “read” on me than even I do of myself. What does that mean? Here I am, having a pretty intimate chat over Indian street food with a lovely woman and my smartphone is ready to suggest me to go get toilet paper at the store next door. That terrifies me.

If you haven’t noticed, I like these posts to be an open conversation. So, let’s converse. Why does this terrify me? Well, because there are entities on this world that know my exact habits to a tee. I’m not a repetitive person in the slightest, but when Google or Apple suggest that I need to get a new bottle of Dove post-shave moisturizer after I get a haircut, it makes me wonder if I am. Have we all really become that predictable that something that doesn’t breath can get a read on us to the point it can help? Ah, but wait, is it helping? I believe it’s offering help, but what’s the limit? When does this help become a form of marketing?

Let’s walk through this, step-by-step. Forgive the crud-ity but I’ll stick to toilet paper as an example (pun intended). I’m with my friends for a day and I mention that I need to do groceries and get toilet paper — as a joke (partly, post college life is hard, man). In this hypothetical world, Google is now trying to enter the toilet paper industry with their brand new optimization algorithm for ply-count (you get the idea). Now when my phone tells me there’s a Walmart close-by and I can get Google branded toilet paper, is that helping me? It is, but isn’t it also leading me to only get a certain brand of toilet paper? I may sound very tinfoil-hat like here but follow me through a more real world version where this can be implemented. Ever received a notification asking for a review on a certain place or about a certain type of food you’ve been talking about with people? That tells me that entities are able to combine our location with phrases it can capture from us and provide an output. Getting from that to just putting in a simple suggestion towards a product that is paying for advertising isn’t so hard.

You know what seems so innocent? Those little quizzes you find online about “Which Marvel hero are you?” or something. I opened one of those up the other day (spoiler alert, I am Iron Man). The first question it asked was about “what your favorite type of take out is”. I thought, okay, maybe these heroes have a take out order, interesting. Next question was “where do you like shopping”. Now hold up. These types of questions went on through about 30 more “next” button presses and by the end I realized I had just been played. In 35 odd questions, this quiz had just taken so much of my data and probably sent it to some advertising company that now knows where/when/how I like certain things. In return, I got told I was Iron Man.

Why?

In a great post describing how Machine learning works by Adam Geitgey, he writes: “As machine learning becomes more important in more industries, the difference between a good program and a bad program will be how much data you have to train your models”. He goes on to point out “that this is why companies like Google and Facebook need your data so badly!”. That’s great, I’m all for machine learning and progressing with technology. This got me curious though in regards to the data that has already been collected about me. I decided to do some investigation as to what my “read” is to Facebook and Google.

First Google, come at me Sergey. I personally subscribe to Google play music and have a wide variety of music preferences usually dependent on mood. I think like most people, my mood alternates throughout the day. I opened up my Google play playlists and looked at the songs that I liked and added to them. I have three main playlists:

Rise — Wake up, blood pumping stuff to get me ready for my exciting day (it always amuses me to bump Kanye when I’m writing code for a bank).

Get Luv Jain’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Chill — Deep beats for actually working and focusing.

Mood — Everything from old school Bollywood to modern hip hop.

Now the brilliant engineers over there, have actually attached a time and weather condition to all the music I’ve ever interacted with. They even track if I finished listening to the track or not. So, if it’s bright and Google knows it’s my shower time and my phone suggests me to listen to some Shakira, will I listen? Unfortunately, that’s the precise time when my hips don’t lie, so yes. But, do I really need that level of detail?

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Alright, let’s do this, Zuck. This honestly made me sad. Here’s one of my favorite pictures of my brother and I at Mt. Rainier over a summer, during a surprise visit. This picture holds so many special memories and always makes me smile. And below are the tags that Facebook has decided to mark this as. “people smiling, sky, cloud, outdoor and nature”. Now I love computers, I’m a techie at heart. But, this is sad. Such a special memory and one of the only permanent labels that this will go down having is “people smiling”. Maybe it’s a good thing, that it’s not able to process all the emotion behind the picture.

How to do this: Go to any picture on facebook, right click -> inspect

But why is this being done at all? If any artist decided to pay Google or Facebook to advertise their track for a “person smiling in outdoors” to listen to their new soundtrack about that, is it because I would like it or because there was money transferred? What model is being trained and how is it going to affect me? Can we imagine a world where there are deeper tags on the picture like “proudly smiling, surprise, bliss”? More importantly, are we ready for that world?

I’m not. But hell, maybe this will go well for dates in the future. I can hand over a little text document telling her all the tags that Facebook and Google have me as. After all, who has the better read on me at that point ;

Me or the data?

Hi! I don’t like to end these blurbs without saying thank you to the people who talk data with me, that’s all of you. But especially you, thanks for conversing with me.

If you’re new, hi! Here’s my first post to find out who I am: Here

--

--

Luv Jain
Luv Jain

Written by Luv Jain

Mad scientist gone software engineer, Relentless problem solver, Pun master. When I’m wrong, I’m only off by a bit.

CodeWithLuv
CodeWithLuv

Published in CodeWithLuv

This is literally to show people I know what I’m doing (kinda). I guess you could say I’m putting the luv in CodeWithLuv