Situated Significance
The Dome of the Rock/Temple Mount
The “Dome of the Rock” (to Muslims), the “Temple Mount” (to Jews) — proclaimed to be the third holiest site of Islamic practice — is also the location of the rock of ascension of Christ, and the location of the brotherly embrace (from a Jewish tale of two brothers who toiled through the night in order to provide for each other before themselves). The Dome of the Rock takes a seriously long time to get into, and has been a contested site for years. To me what was striking were the architectural vantage points in the Old City in Jerusalem from which it was possible to view the Temple Mount, the golden dome that stands iconically above the city. Particularly striking was the story repeated over and over of former PM of Israel Ariel Sharon defying unspoken norms — that are now institutionalized — by visiting the Dome of the Rock without being Muslim.
Dozens of people were injured in rioting on the West Bank and in Jerusalem yesterday as the hawkish Likud party leader, Ariel Sharon, staged a provocative visit to a Muslim shrine at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Surrounded by hundreds of Israeli riot police, Mr Sharon and a handful of Likud politicians marched up to the Haram al-Sharif, the site of the gold Dome of the Rock that is the third holiest shrine in Islam.
He came down 45 minutes later, leaving a trail of fury. Young Palestinians heaved chairs, stones, rubbish bins, and whatever missiles came to hand at the Israeli forces. Riot police retaliated with tear gas and rubber bullets, shooting one protester in the face.
The symbolism of the visit to the Haram by Mr Sharon — reviled for his role in the 1982 massacre of Palestinians in a refugee camp in Lebanon — and its timing was unmistakable. “This is a dangerous process conducted by Sharon against Islamic sacred places,” Yasser Arafat told Palestinian television…
Palestinian protesters followed Mr Sharon down the mountain, chanting “murderer” and “we will redeem the Haram with blood and fire”. They narrowly escaped clashing with Orthodox Jews who shouted “go back to Mecca”.
{http://www.theguardian.com/world/2000/sep/29/Israel}
Get Kirin’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The contestation of the site — to which a visit can cause furor and physical violence — speaks to the mobility and fluidity of architecture and site preservation. In class with Professor Asani, “For the Love of God and His Prophet,” we have discussed the ways in which architectural patterns are Orientalized and posited as immovable and transhistorical (or, more precisely, ahistorical, as part of an idea of monolithic religion that is often applied to different faiths). Markers of “Islamic architecture,” a category as arguable as a potential category of Islamic art (i.e. whose Islam? in what context? with what perceptions of the divinity of Beauty or the profanity of it?) are visible in the arabesque, gilding, and calligraphic inscriptions that abound around the Dome of the Rock. But the symbolic significance of the site, the rock at the heart of it, speaks to the use of architecture as a marker of claims. This is another way of looking at “Islamic” architecture — to see the ways in which it can mark sites as one’s own — and the ways in which it will be reviled, contested, and even made invisible by lore and claims of other natures (political, ideological, through the lens of martyrdom and victimhood). Architectural patterns are movable and subject to shifting meaning through changing political structures as much as anything else — and to imagine it a s monolithic/immovable/ahistorical/permanent disregards centuries of past and ongoing destruction and renewal in construction and deconstruction of sites and meaning.








