Shaking Off Intermittent Reinforcement
We check our phones, on average, every six minutes (Tomi Ahonen).
Every time we do this we divert energy and attention away from whatever we’re doing at the time. Then, we out the phone down again and we invest more (finite) energy and attention into gearing up to get back to the task at hand.
Get Joe Wood’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
So, every time we check our phone we reduce our capacity to fulfil the activity at hand — be it completing a document for work, reading a book, or having a conversation with a friend — to the best of our ability.
The reason our phones — or any other connected device — have that pull and command over our attention is because of something called Intermittent Reinforcement. Intermittent Reinforcement is a term used in psychology to refer to a system that irregularly rewards its user or subject. Not knowing when we will be rewarded by the system keeps us coming back, again and again to check. In the case of our phones, that reward may be a text, a re-tweet, a ‘like’ on a photo we shared earlier — any tiny remote interaction with anyone in our ‘network’. The promise of these sporadic gratifications has a pretty strong hold on our behaviour.
This negatively impacts our ability to do other things well, because it’s a distraction. But there’s something else: eventually, we’ll become frustrated not just with the effects on our productivity, but with the actual endless stream of content itself.
I’ve stolen the term stream from Alexis Madrigal, who coined the term to refer to the streams of our timelines and newsfeeds, refreshing rapidly and endlessly. Like a stream, I guess. Madrigal made a valid point: “it is easier to read Ulysses than it is to read the Internet: at least Ulysses has an end.” (At least with Ulysses, the reader can see a light at the end of the tunnel — they can finish the book and move on to something else.)
People seek completion. If something is left incomplete we will very much struggle to stop thinking about it, and move on effectively to another task or activity. That’s why we love crossing things off lists, and it’s the same reason that writers for TV dramas use cliff-hangers.
This is something I’m thinking about at the moment — trying to put in place a system that guards against my behaviour being dictated by incompletion. On a practical note, I’m trying to check my phone less.








