Sitemap
Joe Wood

Joe Wood

Wearer of plaid shirts. Drinker of (good) coffee. Advocate of analogue things.

Why we have metaphor. (And Pinterest.)

3 min readFeb 15, 2014

--

Recently I read about why humans might have developed metaphor. Vocabulary — being finite — allows humans to create meaning, but it is the finite nature of language that necessitates creativity in order for us to express ourselves. And so we have metaphor.

If we had infinite brain capacity and at some point developed infinite vocabulary, words would become so specific that language would become meaningless. We’d have no shared or common meaning.

***

These ideas tie (loosely) to a conversation I had the other day about the ‘death’ of Pinterest. ‘Is it dead yet?’ was the question that prompted the discussion. My thoughts simplified were ‘no, it’s not’. Some people got massively excited about it at first — perhaps a little too excited. And it’s not lived up to the original hype. This is so often the case with a new technology or platform.

What happens after this is that the people’s relationship with the technology slumps into a ‘trough of disillusionment’ in a kind of backlash against the first wave of hype. This idea is articulated nicely in a thing called Gartner’s Hype Cycle. In the trough, a technology gains breathing space and there lies the potential for the technology to establish its true value or purpose (‘the plateau of productivity’). If this happens the technology can become useful to people and has the ability to embed into people’s lives.

Back to Pinterest, I think it’s fairly evident that it indeed resides in the trough of disillusionment at present and that’s because we haven’t quite worked out what its true purpose is yet. Yes, it was novel for a while and it’s fairly aesthetically pleasing, but that’s not enough to justify an ongoing existence. Essentially, Pinterest is a nifty tool for collating images from the web and the reason I don’t think we’ve quite passed verdict on Pinterest is that it’s symptomatic of a broader human project…

Get Joe Wood’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

The proliferation of the web and digital virtual consumption has left us reeling in an onslaught of information, channels and products that is arguably now perceivable as infinite. People now face having to deal with what is effectively infinite abundance and as the development of vocabulary demonstrates, we probably don’t have the cognitive capacity for that. Probably never will.

People have always used ‘things’ — objects, artefacts — to help make sense of themselves and the world around them. Finite energy and attention have always been invested in special objects in order to achieve a kind of mental order. With borderline infinite abundance set to become a default state our ability to have relationships with things is called into question.

We are in a period where we need to work out how to cope with default settings of abundance and acquisitiveness. We need to work out how to route out, collate, process and possess stuff that is important.

***

Amendment: here’s something I only just found in Wired that deals essentially with the same topic. The prediction here: abundance will kill the web.

Thoughts?

--

--

Joe Wood
Joe Wood

Written by Joe Wood

Wearer of plaid shirts. Drinker of (good) coffee. Advocate of analogue things.